What do YOU want the next OT title to be?

  • New Personal Best

    Votes: 113 37.3%
  • White Castle Crystals

    Votes: 100 33.0%
  • Dreamed And Directed By

    Votes: 23 7.6%
  • How To End A Toxic Friendship

    Votes: 22 7.3%
  • The Footlong Experience

    Votes: 45 14.9%

  • Total voters
    303
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Joeku

Member
Oct 26, 2017
23,481
The Lenny scene is fantastic and a top moment of the year contender.
It's...fine. It's an escalating one in a line of many drunk scenes in games

It sure as shit is no God of War "Getting the thing" scene.

Nor the last act of Celeste.

Nor the final mission of Into the Breach.

Nor the chapter finales in Vampyr.

Nor the final act in Spider-Man.

Nor the general store scene in Life is Strange 2.
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 1041

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,725

Deleted member 1041

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,725
honestly the most memorable thing this year, that includes Giant Bomb

is Jeff and Dan getting into anime
 

bomma man

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,073
Actually, you're right, God of War had one killer moment, that I'd give a bunch of credit to because of how mostly silent it is. Good call.


Usually late November/Early December. Fits right in there. It's why Smash and Just Cause are gonna miss the GotYcasts.

Nintendo send out stuff pretty early don't they? They'll probably have smash soon. Not that it'll make a difference.
 
Oct 25, 2017
15,110
Oh man, Jeff ripping into RDR2 so hard and getting NOTHING in return on the Bombcast was funny. They didn't even acknowledge how he repeatedly said it feels like an old game at all lol
 

Joeku

Member
Oct 26, 2017
23,481
There's an extended sequence in God of War where you take a slow, ponderous rowboat and the character leans into his fists, watching the wildlife and the weather change into a fiery, red shape (including looking at the old games' Athena taunting you from the head of the canoe you're in) until you go back to the cabin and recover the old Blades of Chaos, relatively quietly working your way through icy enemies to get back to the main thrust of the game.

It's the really powerful moment of the game because it's a tacit admission that as much as the soft reboot wants to be a reboot...the past cannot truly be let go, and it surfaces in a gameplay sense, halfway through a 30-hour+ game. It's one of those very few things that a video game sequel is going to be better at than most other mediums.
 

Deleted member 1041

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,725
There's an extended sequence in God of War where you take a slow, ponderous rowboat and the character leans into his fists, watching the wildlife and the weather change into a fiery, red shape (including looking at the old games' Athena taunting you from the head of the canoe you're in) until you go back to the cabin and recover the old Blades of Chaos, relatively quietly working your way through icy enemies to get back to the main thrust of the game.

It's the really powerful moment of the game because it's a tacit admission that as much as the soft reboot wants to be a reboot...the past cannot truly be let go, and it surfaces in a gameplay sense, halfway through a 30-hour+ game. It's one of those very few things that a video game sequel is going to be better at than most other mediums.

Honestly it'd be cool if GoW takes best moment of the year. The whole game seems to have a whole lotta love given to it compared to RDR2, which looks to be a game that was just massively tested in and out until it hit R*s quality pole.
 

Joeku

Member
Oct 26, 2017
23,481
Honestly it'd be cool if GoW takes best moment of the year. The whole game seems to have a whole lotta love given to it compared to RDR2, which looks to be a game that was just massively tested in and out until it hit R*s quality pole.
I don't even particularly like God of War much as a game overall, but I agree. There are particulars in a way that RDR2 is just broad.
 

Deleted member 1041

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
10,725
I don't even particularly like God of War much as a game overall, but I agree. There are particulars in a way that RDR2 is just broad.

Right.

Like, GoW is an attempt at making an established series completely different, and making it completely fresh in a way that can't be compared to previous games, and it's done in a way that's earnest.

RDR2 is taking RDR, and simply adding a bunch of stuff that they've added to their games throughout the years, and just more of RDR just more modern? Not a knock of it, but it's like...like I'd rather play GoW than RDR2 because its more interesting in alotta ways.
 

bomma man

Member
Oct 25, 2017
3,073
Oh man, Jeff ripping into RDR2 so hard and getting NOTHING in return on the Bombcast was funny. They didn't even acknowledge how he repeatedly said it feels like an old game at all lol

It's actually a pretty good description. I don't think anyone at Rockstar has played anything released since 2008. Probably because they're working 100 weeks.
 

Deleted member 46641

User requested account closure
Banned
Aug 12, 2018
3,494
Best music
Best moment
Best story
Best surprise
Best looking
Best styyyyyle
Please stop
Hottest mess
Worst game
Best game
I've got my gimmick idea planned

It'll be all of those categories plus an inverted dark world version of each

So worst moment, worst story, worst looking, and worst styyyyle are all going to show up.
 

TiamatSword

Chicken Chaser
Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,748
Oh man, Jeff ripping into RDR2 so hard and getting NOTHING in return on the Bombcast was funny. They didn't even acknowledge how he repeatedly said it feels like an old game at all lol
Jeff was saying this as a negative???

Nah, Ben also responded with how inflexible the missions are.
This really bothered me in a mission I did yesterday.
I had to go steal an oil wagon and the place you're supposed to steal it from has two. So naturally I throw a fire bottle at one of them to act as a distraction, but it's just an automatic failure for destroying one of the wagons.
 
Oct 27, 2017
2,481
United Kingdom
There's an extended sequence in God of War where you take a slow, ponderous rowboat and the character leans into his fists, watching the wildlife and the weather change into a fiery, red shape (including looking at the old games' Athena taunting you from the head of the canoe you're in) until you go back to the cabin and recover the old Blades of Chaos, relatively quietly working your way through icy enemies to get back to the main thrust of the game.

It's the really powerful moment of the game because it's a tacit admission that as much as the soft reboot wants to be a reboot...the past cannot truly be let go, and it surfaces in a gameplay sense, halfway through a 30-hour+ game. It's one of those very few things that a video game sequel is going to be better at than most other mediums.
I didn't really like it.

It was inevitable it would happen, but it was a sign that the exciting reboot was slipping back further and further to the old formula which was getting rather dull by Ascension.
 

Deleted member 22476

Account closed at user request
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
5,858
I assumed that post was a joke because it was so batshit.

Maybe I'm not giving Jubbster enough credit


Jeff was saying this as a negative???


This really bothered me in a mission I did yesterday.
I had to go steal an oil wagon and the place you're supposed to steal it from has two. So naturally I throw a fire bottle at one of them to act as a distraction, but it's just an automatic failure for destroying one of the wagons.

You can actually do a lot of fun things with that part of the mission because gunfire scares horses easily. It's actually a good example of the opposite of what you're using it to highlight.

Think like a cowboy
 

Strafer

The Flagpole is Wider
Member
Oct 25, 2017
29,469
Sweden
Honestly, I honestly can't wait for this goty crap to be over, it honestly is ruining my enjoyment out of this thread.
 

J_Viper

Member
Oct 25, 2017
25,808
Oh man I'm still only now like half way through GoW, I'm a bit passed the "whoops, wrong mountain bro!" part, but if the moment you guys are referring to is the thing I think will have to happen I might lose my shit in a great way

GoW is one of those rare games that only improves the further along I get into the narrative

wowe you get bfv this week with origin accesses
col


https://streamable.com/zy3rs#

This will never not be hysterical
 
Oct 27, 2017
2,481
United Kingdom
I'm still amazed how Rockstar's engine has got so much better over the years.

GTA3/VC/SA were just about average.

GTA4 & RDR were better looking but by no means the best of the gen.

GTA5 looked very good and was near the top tier last gen.

RDR2 is the first game in years to stun me graphically and is easily the best looker this gen.

And it's been without compromising world size along the way, too. Really impressive.
 

Hella

Member
Oct 27, 2017
23,441
The Lenny mission is far and away the most imaginative and fun a Rockstar mission has ever been.

It's also a pale imitation of stuff Saint's Row the Third did throughout the entire game.
 
Oct 25, 2017
22,423
Honestly, I honestly can't wait for this goty crap to be over, it honestly is ruining my enjoyment out of this thread.
Hahaha, oh you.
We will talk about the Goty 2018 at least until E3, I expect the GotY 2019 talks to slowly ramp up shortly before that.
If we all work together I think it's possible to talk about GotY throughout the entire year, gang!
 

Strax

Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,301
I've been having a lot of fun with RDR2 but I liked RDR1 much better when it came out. But I still have like 30 hours to go.
 

Hella

Member
Oct 27, 2017
23,441
I preferred the sheep herding mission
I feel like that one (assuming there's only one) was tuned to be more difficult, no one could figure it out, then they retuned it to be mindlessly easy, while keeping all of the esoteric mechanics in.

There's like... 3-4 tutorial pop-ups for a simple escort with no time pressure. It's silly.
 

Forkball

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,943
Are there direct links to The Quiet Man playthroughs? Everyone is up in arms about that game and I want to see it.

Also I like how Ben is supposed to be the Smash expert yet can't explain anything that happened in the Direct.
 

Deleted member 22476

Account closed at user request
Banned
Oct 28, 2017
5,858
I feel like that one (assuming there's only one) was tuned to be more difficult, no one could figure it out, then they retuned it to be mindlessly easy, while keeping all of the esoteric mechanics in.

There's like... 3-4 tutorial pop-ups for a simple escort with no time pressure. It's silly.

City folk don't understand animals

Some of the best emergent gameplay involves the animal AI. Most even.
 
Oct 27, 2017
2,481
United Kingdom
I don't think those are broken, more like, inconsequential?
No they are definitely broken.

Broken karma system: Mission giver tells you to do X but not kill anyone. You use your fists when they shoot at you. Negative karma for each KO.

Broken bounty system: Knock someone over by mistake, $70 dollar bounty. Do a heist with dozens of police killed, $30 bounty. Get caught by a sheriff in a Dead or Alive bounty area, surrender, go to jail for a day and pay a $13 bounty. Upon release, the area bounty is still Dead or Alive, as if the arrest didn't happen.

Borderline broken weapon inventory: Sometimes equip your weapons on the horse, get off, they've gone. Sometimes equip your weapons on the horse, get off, they've stayed. Sometimes equip your weapons on a horse, get off, you have them, start the mission, one is randomly missing for no reason.
 

kambaybolongo

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,127
It's...fine. It's an escalating one in a line of many drunk scenes in games

It sure as shit is no God of War "Getting the thing" scene.

Nor the last act of Celeste.

Nor the final mission of Into the Breach.

Nor the chapter finales in Vampyr.

Nor the final act in Spider-Man.

Nor the general store scene in Life is Strange 2.
The thought of anything in Celeste being called a 'best moment' is really funny
 
Last edited:
Oct 27, 2017
2,481
United Kingdom
I forgot you can wear a bandana, do a crime, and somehow all the cops know you're ARTHUR MORGAN immediately.

Plus the game is totally inconsistent about which main story missions add to your bounty or just have no impact on it whatsoever.
 

Hella

Member
Oct 27, 2017
23,441
While the bandana protects your identity, it doesn't stop them from recognising the outfit you're wearing, or horse you're riding.

But yeah it's very inconsistent, even knowing that. The trigger for getting a bounty might as well be a dice roll for how inscutable it is.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.