Is Witcher 3 really terrible on consoles..
Serious question as I'm a PC player and thought it was regarded as generally good on all platforms.
It had significant issues at launch which were by and large fixed after a few patches over the years. The issue is that some patches fixes a few things and breaks others. Prior to the latest patch the game was as good as it got (which was very good) aside from a game crashing inventory bug. Now with this patch which was only supposed to add HDR it introduced a new and highly visible problem which actively works to shatter any sense of immersion.