I initially was annoyed at Nolan's decision to simply film in Chicago as well until I actually went to Chicago and walked around downtown for a bit and realized; "oh shit, this place actually IS Gotham in the real world". That being said, I still prefer my depictions of fictional comic-book cities to err more on the side of the fantastical, so I'm probably going to have to give it to the Burton films. Haven't seen Gotham, though.
You know what, the movie was garbage, but there was something I genuinely dug about the weird, hyper-pop, Dick Sprang on acid aesthetic of Forever's Gotham.It's 89/Returns. But I want to give a shoutout to the Bladerunner neon Gotham from Forever.