I figured I'd check out the state of the game, first time I do so in many months now.
I think I gave up on the possibility this will be a smooth, polished game experience at any point of its life cycle. The menus are a lagfest on X, and the game decides to put me on NA servers claiming not enough people play the game in my region, Europe. Hard to believe but it is what it is. Matchmaking takes anywhere from 5 seconds to 5+ minutes, it's a dice roll basically. Even if you put performance mode, the framerate is nowhere near 60fps and it still has tons of drops, stutters, freezes, sometimes up to like a second even. ADS still feels laggy and unprecise, and again there's often a little frame loss when snapping from one mode to another. Parachuting and swimming are still janky as before, so is encountering slopes. Audio still goes from pixel perfect location of your enemy to random noises you can't hear for shit, and footsteps still come and go. Having separate playlists for Erangel and one with all new maps means 90% of the players don't want those maps, so finding matches on those becomes a lot harder.
There's some QoL changes I appreciated like the auto-equip attachments or some map improvements, but overall the game still feels as janky and unpolished as it did in its Game Preview state. The new assets look slightly better, but there's still texture load issues, pop-up and so on. But I'm glad that between all that they managed to add half a dozen ways to monetize the game, like an awkward battle pass system and such. Crossplay should at least make some of the less populated areas and modes feel more lively again, but when people in this very board said the game got drastically better, I expected more than some random QoL stuff. Movement, shooting, menus, and most game mechanics still feel extremely janky even when they work ideally, and performance is still not sufficient. Jumping to this from any other semi-competent battle royale game is going from Forza Horizon 4 on Xbox One X to Crash Time on X360.
And it's not even about the graphics, it's about how nearly everything in this game feels unfinished, laggy, slow, clunky. I could live with it when no other competent BR was around (Fortnite BR at launch was insanely boring), but just about anybody figured out how to do these games right by now, and yet this one remains in a state that does not resemble a game past its 1.0 at all. I've had so many great memories with this game, but at no point I imagined it would still be in such a state after almost 2 years on Xbox. I might try it again in a while again but if this is the pace they improve the core gameplay, it might take them years to go anywhere near what other BR games are currently doing, let alone what they'll be doing then.
A shame, really. I keep coming back to this game and walking away disappointed.