hello!
Japanese tech journalist's commentary and interview with Otori-san (1/2)
(There are some images at the link.)
Zenji Nishikawa's 3DGE: I'll tell you how to make PS5. The internal design of the PS5, according to a mechanical designer(in Japanese)
2020年10月7日,SIEが公開した「PlayStation 5」の公式分解動画は大きな反響をもたらした。この中では,液体金属を採用した熱伝導材料など,初めて公開となるトピックがいくつかあった。今回は分解動画に登場したPS5のメカ設計を担当する鳳 康宏氏へのインタビューをもとに,より詳細な解説を行いたい。
www.4gamer.net
On October 7th, 2020, Sony Interactive Entertainment (SIE) released a disassembled video of its then unreleased next generation gaming console, the PlayStation 5 (PS5). The video caused quite a stir, as the company released a video explaining the internals of the PS5 in great detail before the product's release. If you haven't seen it, please watch this one.
I had a chance to interview Mr. Yasuhiro Otori, who introduced the inner workings of PS5 in this video. In this article, we will explain the details of the PS5 based on the information we got from the interview.
Mr. Otori is a specialist in housing design and internal structure design, especially cooling design, and he will be giving a presentation at CEDEC 2014 on the internal structure of the PlayStation 4 (PS4) titled "How the PS4 is made, and what's inside the PS4 is revealed! I have also done the following. For those interested, see the report by the author.
PS2以降のPlayStationで「メカ設計」を担当するSCEのエンジニア・鳳 康宏氏がCEDEC 2014に登場。1月にPS4の冷却周りを事細かに紹介して話題を集めた氏が,今度はPS4がどのようなパーツで構成されており,それらがどのように製造されているかを徹底解説してくれたので,その内容をお伝えしたい。
www.4gamer.net
First, let's review the basic information in the PS5 disassembly video
First, let's get some basic information on the PS5's physical structure based on the disassembly video released by SIE.
The PS5's nominal body size is 104 (W) x 260 (D) x 390 (H) mm when placed in portrait mode. The PS5's nominal body size is 104mm (W) x 260 (D) x 390 (H) mm when placed in portrait mode, which is considerably larger than the PS4's nominal body size. Mr. Otori says in the video that it is "a size larger than the initial PS4".
However, as you can see as the video progresses, the PS5's curved surface design is narrower from the center of the body to the edges, so the actual volume of the regular PS5 is about 7.2″, and the digital edition without the optical drive is about 6.4″. The volume of the competing Xbox Series X is about 6.86. so it's about 1.05 and 0.93 times.
The back of the PS5 was not available for filming at the media event, so this is the first time the video was shown in disassembled form.
There is a slit on the upper part of the front side for air intake, and the back side has exhaust holes all around.
On the front, there are USB Type-A ports for USB 2.0 and USB Type-C ports for USB 3.2 Gen 2.
On the back are two USB 3.2 Gen 2 compliant Type-A ports, a 1000BASE-T wired LAN port, an HDMI 2.1 output terminal, and an eyeglass-shaped power connector.
The PS5 comes standard with a dedicated stand that can be used for both vertical and horizontal installation. The stand is held in place with coin screws when the unit is placed upright, and the claws of the stand are hooked to the side of the PS5 unit when it is placed horizontally.
The white cover panels on either side of the PS5 are made of ABS resin. They can be removed by sliding them off.
When you remove the cover panel, the most noticeable thing inside is the air cooling fan. The fan is 120mm in diameter and 45mm in thickness, and it goes through the body.
In addition, there are two dust catchers on the right side to collect dust, which can be vacuumed up by the vacuum cleaner. The cover panel can be easily removed so that users can easily maintain it themselves.
Next, let's take a look at the additional SSD slots, and while the PS5 features a high-speed SSD, there was a lot of confusion as to whether the standard SSD can be replaced when the storage capacity is increased, or whether it should be added to a separate slot. In the disassembly video, it was revealed that an M.2 slot was available for adding an SSD, which settled the issue. The connection interface is said to be PCI Express (PCIe) 4.0 compatible.
In the movie, the optical drive covered by the steel chassis is removed to reveal the main board. The interesting thing is that there is only one main board, while the Xbox Series X has two boards, a main board and a sub board. This is one of the points that we would like to pay attention to as it shows a big difference between the two products.
The SoC (System-on-a-Chip) on the main board is a dedicated APU that integrates a CPU core based on Zen2 and a GPU core based on RDNA 2. Aside from the main memory, the standard SSD is also directly attached to the board, so it cannot be replaced by the user, and the board appears to have a total of six flash memory chips, three on the front and three on the back side of the board.
The video also shows a customized SSD controller from SIE. Just to add to the misunderstanding, this SSD controller is not equipped with the data-expanding chips necessary to achieve PS5's high-speed data transfer. The difference is that the PS5's SSD controller has a 12-channel configuration, whereas a typical SSD controller has 8/16/32 channels.
The scene that follows is the climax of this video.
In the following scene, Mr. Otori revealed the use of liquid metal for the thermal interface material (TIM) between the APU and the heat sink in the PS5.
Although liquid metal is an excellent thermal interface material, it is not actively used in consumer electronics due to its tendency to corrode aluminum. The fact that PS5 uses liquid metal on purpose is interesting. According to Otori, SIE has been preparing for the adoption of liquid metal for more than two years.
The heat sink that cools the APU is about 30% of the size of the housing. Six heat pipes extend from the part of the housing that touches the APU, which has the highest thermal density, towards the heat sink. Mr. Otori says, "Although we used standard heat pipes, we were able to achieve the same level of performance as a vapor chamber by improving the shape of the heat sink and airflow design.
The power supply unit that was removed at the end is said to have a rated output of 350W. Since it is a rather high power supply unit, we can clearly see that it also accounts for a large portion of the PS5's overall volume.
Ask about SSD expansion, a concern for gamers
Now that we've reviewed the PS5's internal structure, let's take a look at some of the information we got from our interview with Otori.
The PS5 can use M.2 SSDs for PC's that support PCIe 4.0. However, there are several products with different board sizes for M.2 SSDs. I wonder how much of it can be built in?
Otori: PS5 supports board sizes that are 22 mm wide and 30 mm/42 mm/60 mm/80 mm/110 mm in length, which are common for M.2 SSDs, and the studs and screws that hold the SSD module in place are built into the SSD expansion slots from the start.
It's a minor detail, but some M.2 SSDs have heat sinks attached to them. Are there any precautions that need to be taken when installing such SSDs in the expansion slots?
Otori: The physical design of the heat sink is designed so that it can be stored as long as it is no higher than 8 mm from the board surface. Although there is a metal cover on the expansion slot, it is best to avoid contact with it.
If you install an SSD with a tall heatsink, it may interfere with the metal cover. The chassis and screw holes to which the metal cover is attached are made of plastic, so there is a possibility that they will be damaged. For this reason, it is likely that you should avoid using an extremely tall heat sink for an additional SSD.
Also, it is well known that M.2 SSDs that support PCIe connections generate heat under high loads, and some PC motherboards are equipped with heat sinks for M.2 SSDs, so we wonder what kind of innovations are used in the PS5.
Otori: We have two exhaust holes for additional SSD slots. Because the slots for expansion are located near the intake fan, the structure is designed to suck out heat from the exhaust holes with negative pressure.
The secret behind the stand, which can be placed vertically or horizontally
Along with the SSD, we also found out some interesting things about the included stand, which is likely to be of great interest to readers in terms of "how to set up the PS5".
The height of PS5 is nearly 40cm when placed vertically, so the center of gravity is also suitably high. So it is easy to understand why PS5 is attached with a special stand as a standard accessory to prevent it from falling down.
As mentioned above, the stand can be used for horizontal installation, but in the disassembly movie, the stand was rotated when switching from vertical to horizontal installation. This gimmick may have intrigued many people. What is the meaning of that rotating mechanism?
Otori: The PS5 stand looks simple, but it's quite elaborate.
If you look closely at the stand, you can see that the indentations where PS5 is placed in portrait mode are inclined on both sides. When the PS5 is placed horizontally, this inclination is designed to support the white cover panel. However, the curved surface of the cover panel and the shape of the stand do not mesh with each other when it is oriented as it is.
So we have to rotate it. When the slide is rotated, the non-slip pedestal in the dent in the stand rises up. At the same time, the hook to fix PS5 on the stand moves to the designated position. The raised non-slip base and the slopes on either side of the base catch the curved surface of the cover panel perfectly.
Depending on the stand, the PS5 can be placed either horizontally or vertically, but does the way it's placed make a difference in heat dissipation performance?
Otori: This is a question we are often asked. As a designer, I can say that there is no difference in cooling performance between vertical and horizontal mounting. I know that some people think that the chimney effect makes the vertical installation more efficient in terms of heat dissipation. However, the chimney effect is at the level of measurement error in a cooling system with an active fan (electric fan) installed. Both horizontal and vertical mounting will perform as specified. Personally, I like the vertical installation, which shows the PS logo correctly.
Do you use the latest computer aided engineering (CAE) to analyze how the air flows through the chassis?
Otori: CAE is sometimes used to optimize the airflow of individual parts, but we don't use it to design the whole thing; we develop it by conducting real-world experiments. Specifically, we made a transparent model of the chassis and observed the dry ice smoke flowing through it, and took temperature readings in each part of the system as we made improvements.
Why is PS5 so tall?
At about 390mm, PS5's height is the tallest in PlayStation's history. This protruding vertical (or horizontal when the unit is placed on its side) shape seems to be a secret too.
Otori: After the design department provided us with the required dimensions, we began to consider the design of the PS5's body. For example, we reduced the height and widened the width by that amount. This time, however, the design department asked us to make it look thinner when it's placed on its side, so we decided to make it taller and narrower.
Hearing this story alone, it sounds like the result of focusing on appearance, but of course, that's not the only thing we did. In fact, there is another major benefit of this design, which is to reduce the number of mounting boards. That is to reduce the number of mounting boards. If the width is made wider, it would be difficult to install on a single main board, resulting in a double-board configuration with a main board and a sub-board.
I'm not sure if this is due to the increased width of the Xbox Series X, but the system is actually made up of two boards.
Otori: Having two boards increases manufacturing costs and thermal design challenges. We wanted to make it look thinner when it is placed horizontally, and we wanted to keep the cost down with a single board.
Translated with
www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)