Emerald getting 76 is a travesty. I'd personally score it the same as diamond.
I'd score pretty much every one of those games differently, and we all know damn well soul silver should be in the 90's
Emerald getting 76 is a travesty. I'd personally score it the same as diamond.
It's a drop of 7, not 6. Please stick to the facts.Lol, in what world is a 6 nearly a 10???XD
"i had only 6 from 10 points in this test..."
"woo, almost perfect!! Super close!!"
A 8 from 10 seems like a good score for me. So the games are fun but FAR from outstanding.
There's no too much difference in content between the positive and negative reviews. It's all coming down to emphasis.Just read Eurogamer's review. Seems as praising as it is scathing, which matches up with the leaks and datamines. Fun because it's Pokémon, but it's certainly missing a lot that will drag it down.
But what if it wasn'tWe should change this from a thread about sword and shield, and turn it into an outrage that's universally justified. How bw2 was robbed
I mean, fair's fair- Explorers of Sky has a really good story, but, like all Mystery Dungeon games, the gameplay is something to be tolerated at best, rather than something enjoyable.
The thread we need, but not the one we deserve.We should change this from a thread about sword and shield, and turn it into an outrage that's universally justified. How bw2 was robbed
We should change this from a thread about sword and shield, and turn it into an outrage that's universally justified. How bw2 was robbed
This was about a decade ago when roguelikes were barely in the public consciousness and got reviewed harsher as a result.Times like this are why I appreciate user reviews to some degree. That disparity is excellent. I've never particularly understood why the mystery dungeon series gets trashed so hard.
Regardless if you think these are great scores or not, it is still the lowest scored mainline game by a decent amount. 80 is about the bare minimum I'd expect a Pokemon game to get regardless of its quality.Jesus wept
They'll always get away with everything for the rest of time, it seems.
Emerald deserves a 90. ORAS is a 65. This is the only correct opinion.Blasphemy! I actually held this opinion when I played ORAS until I replayed Emerald. Probably one of my favourite regions
It's pretty much what I hate about review scores.There's no too much difference in content between the positive and negative reviews. It's all coming down to emphasis.
Is there an existing Pokemon review generator lol"Pokémon Assault and Battery looks like the bastard child of Bubsy 3D and Sonic 2006. Every time I see a new challenge in the game, I want to punch through the screen. I have nothing but seething hatred for the graphics, sound design, story, and gameplay.
But despite all those issues, Pokemon Assault and Battery still is Pokémon. The formula is a little long in the tooth, but it's always a wonderfully charming one.
Also you can knit wool sweaters with your Pokémon and that's adorable.
9.75"
They say Jesus was hated because he tried to tell people the truth.We should change this from a thread about sword and shield, and turn it into an outrage that's universally justified. How bw2 was robbed
Actually, for the review thread it was moreI've seen this many times before:
- Donky Kong Tropical Freeze: another DK ?! why not Metroid? why not AAA GAME BY THE AMERICAN STUDIO RETRO TO SHOW OFF THE WIIU HARDWARE?
and it turned out that Tropical Freeze is probably the best 2D platforming game ever made.
I don't see how anything cut in swish made it better.It matters how and what. Trimming fat can be a good thing. If there are specific features that were cut, that if included would make it a better game, go ahead and make your case. Note, I said a better game, not the game you personally want.
So much of the criticism of new games of well established series is long time fans criticizing what a game isn't, instead of what it is.
Fire Emblem recently reviewed extremely well despite its glaring technical issues.
Outside of special cases like starters and legendary special moves? Not from what I've seen.
They didn't "cut massive amounts of content from the game"What I'm learning is that GF can cut massive amounts of content from the game, but as long as it's not something journalists would typically spend time with, it ultimately will not affect review scores or sales much if at all.
I've said it before, but I honestly don't know if reviewers even care to be critical about Pokemon games. With others you'll see comments on tech, performance, comparisons to previous titles and others in the genre, actual analysis. With Pokemon "Pretty easy, kinda the same as last time, not the best looking, but I had fun 🤷🏽♂️. 8-9/10"The fact that Emerald has a 76 lol. It still holds up 15 years later. 60fps and no gates. It deserved better.
That person was stating false information to suit a narrative. X/Y were 88 and Sun/Moon 87, SwSh is an 80. 7 is generous, arguably one could go with the 8.Didn't the guy you quoted saif it is down from 86/87 to 80? Could be also either 6 or 7. Stick to the facts. ;)
Come on, no need to be upset I'm just messing around with you. Damn, it's just a game and tbh I don't care about those numbers. I will get the game mainly for my son to play it and I know he will enjoy it.
Once again I can't see a review thread in the gaming forum, this time is this one. Can't see it in the first page or any other. I can only access the thread if someone links it to me, or if I google it. Am I shadow banned for some topics or something? Any mods here?
Maybe you ignored Mazi.Once again I can't see a review thread in the gaming forum, this time is this one. Can't see it in the first page or any other. I can only access the thread if someone links it to me, or if I google it. Am I shadow banned for some topics or something? Any mods here?
The day/night cycle thing was quickly disproven and everyone moved on. The rest of the criticims people had were legitimate.Sure, the game made some decisions that deserved criticism, but people took things too far, lied a lie to themselves that this is a trash game, and believed their own-made fiction and started to push their narratives on every single piece of info, no they even made issues out of nothing (like the night/day cycle they imagined).
Lets be honest.A 9.3 from ign means GF will ignore all american criticism lol. Sales gonna be as high as usual maybe higher. This series isn't taking any leaps
Once again I can't see a review thread in the gaming forum, this time is this one. Can't see it in the first page or any other. I can only access the thread if someone links it to me, or if I google it. Am I shadow banned for some topics or something? Any mods here?