-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Star Trek: The Next Generation Mafia |OT| The First Duty Of Every Starfleet Officer Is To The Truth (Except In Mafia)
- Thread starter Fanto
- Start date
It's alright. It is what it is at this point. GG everyone
Well I said it was Nat yesterday and nobody listened. As for the other one I think it's Fate or you.
I'd like to just vote Nat and hopefully I'll get killed overnight so I don't have to deal with a final 3. Knowing my luck I'll still be alive though.
OP
OP
Day 8 End / Game End
OP
OP
Natiko has died!
And with that, the Romulans have reached a majority, and have killed the remaining Federation members as well.
Lone_Prodigy has died!
FateShirou has died!
----------
HPSauce has won the game!
malus has won the game!
-------------
And with that, the game is over! Thank you everyone for playing!
And with that, the Romulans have reached a majority, and have killed the remaining Federation members as well.
Lone_Prodigy has died!
FateShirou has died!
----------
HPSauce has won the game!
malus has won the game!
-------------
And with that, the game is over! Thank you everyone for playing!
Good game everyone. Thanks Fanto for the fun game.
Shoutout to HP and malus for the hard fought scum win. Y'all played well.
Shoutout to HP and malus for the hard fought scum win. Y'all played well.
Big ouf this game had some huge emotional manipulation
Fun game to observe but I think its put me off forever!
Fun game to observe but I think its put me off forever!
Thanks for running the game Fanto! Sorry for shitting it up. Apologies to the townies I got murdered and smack talked.
Literally never feeling sorry for HP in mafia again. Your emotions are now irrelevant to me in game lol
Malus' role is maybe the most broken scum role I've ever seen in a game not labeled bastard. Public, mod verified action? Check. Can give you a BP so you have an excuse to never be NKed? Check. Also a bunch of other abilities and can take a player with you upon death? Check. Yikes.
Literally never feeling sorry for HP in mafia again. Your emotions are now irrelevant to me in game lol
Malus' role is maybe the most broken scum role I've ever seen in a game not labeled bastard. Public, mod verified action? Check. Can give you a BP so you have an excuse to never be NKed? Check. Also a bunch of other abilities and can take a player with you upon death? Check. Yikes.
Then replace out. It was absolutely not fun to deal with, and while it worked I stand by if I'd been your scummate I would've been pissed off.
Woo! Congrats malus and HP, it's impressive to skirt by so much suspicion and pull out a win.
Also, thanks Fanto for a great game. Testament to how good it is even when you don't know the source material.
Also, thanks Fanto for a great game. Testament to how good it is even when you don't know the source material.
Yeah, I was totally bought in on that theory but yours was just too nuts. What insane cover to have as scum in a non-bastard game lol Everything else felt fair all told though.
OP
OP
Malus' role was def OP in hindsight, but meh, take it up with Faddy and Loki, they reviewed it lol. :P
In all seriousness though, the game prob should have been labeled Unusual Role Madness at the least to set expectations properly, because there were a lot of wacky roles, and it was set up in a pretty "unusual" way in terms of balancing against mass claims and whatnot.
In all seriousness though, the game prob should have been labeled Unusual Role Madness at the least to set expectations properly, because there were a lot of wacky roles, and it was set up in a pretty "unusual" way in terms of balancing against mass claims and whatnot.
Yeah, I think if this has been labeled differently we maybe would've looked at Malus closer. Balance issues happen at times, not a big deal.
Scum won 6-2 on players voted out.
i mean town had their chances, they just fluffed them. There was a whole lot of town talk about no one was confirmed by roles but let the two mafia skate on claims.
You obviously had the worst role in the game but town had a bunch of super strong and confirmable roles too.
Sorry for not bringing you home the win pal, but you can rest assured that mostly everyone town read you =D.
Oh come on now, we probably would've flipped everyone alive at the end there except LP before Malus, and even if we had landed on him sooner unless he's the final mafia he could still have cost us the game upon being voted out lol Scum BP granter alone is a wildly good role to be able to claim because it's verifiable AND gives you a reason to keep surviving.
You don't have to be sorry! I know you did better than I would have.
OP
OP
This is a big thing, yeah. Launch would have given out a Vig shot, a Cop shot, and a Lightning Rod, any of which could have had dramatic effects on the game.
I don't think saying town had their chances is a fair argument to role balance. At least to me, one is specifically the backend portion of the game and the other is deduction.
Maybe if the backup doctor had been a full backup it would've been different - but in that world I'm sure a shit role gets voted out D1 instead lol
Reminder: Town voted out Anex because they said the role was too powerful for town!
And then after flipping town never went back to the fact they blocked HP the night there was no kill.
There were powerful roles on both sides.
We reiterated it multiple times, but we also had two other possible explanations lol
YOU FUCKING IDOITS
COULDNT FUCKING WAIT
FUCK YOU
WHAT HTE FUCK WAS THE POINT OF THAT
MAN IM FUCKING SEEING RED
COULDNT FUCKING WAIT
FUCK YOU
WHAT HTE FUCK WAS THE POINT OF THAT
MAN IM FUCKING SEEING RED
EAT SHIT