• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Weltall Zero

Game Developer
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
19,343
Madrid
All right guys, I was finally able to boot up the Wii U this past weekend, and I spent some time trying to recreate some pictures for comparison. I haven't played Smash 4 in so long, so I might have gotten some animations/stages incorrect. The camera is pretty limited, and not knowing which stage many pictures were taken on kinda limited me, and the differences in stage lighting may have an effect on the pictures. I didn't have much time so I was only able to hit some easy comparisons.

ss_6.jpg
29292827818_1d523e3024_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg

29292830228_9ffc873af8_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294428107_2542601223_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163865041_664f4ba013_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
29292830088_006ecc39d8_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163862141_72a7e06bbe_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163862271_98ed2468f4_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292830448_174e706f45_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg
28294428477_8326cafc17_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163862601_32b9abde3a_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163862671_18b8ed159a_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294430847_a7d27056e5_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294431067_fc6b9e0c91_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294428667_4bb5c383b1_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
29292828468_28cdfe33ee_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163862931_9cbcdd39ba_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
42259639865_97b3856fe2_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163863141_4bd89cd228_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292828688_efd88639ba_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
42259639945_c14d255f4f_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163863261_520c9e5289_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294429107_6ac27f97f0_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
42259639995_fe6058e975_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg
28294429197_c3958e3430_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163863471_41017edcdc_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292829178_aa341afcc5_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294429407_d536ec2d8d_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
42259640115_6b1b610b80_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163863651_aa728c3677_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294429657_c7d3c44fa0_o.jpg

ss_6.jpg
28294432097_6c12d966f1_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163863981_56fb520681_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163863851_2d816aa5bd_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163864161_cdf10eb24f_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
28294432437_378be11249_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
29292828218_e304fbaa78_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294429787_bbeb12bfe5_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864381_98b5c0f998_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
28294432607_d8bcd32746_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294429887_f24dbc60a0_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
29292829858_79e23d1667_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864751_672eb67f92_o.jpg

ss_6.jpg
28294432757_5e82db4981_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294433037_5d5884c38b_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163861971_2e80e666b2_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864871_798ed2bf5f_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294433227_7cc17b3c98_o.jpg

Yikes. Really not a fan of how much more washed out / whited out / desaturated Ultimate looks in pretty much every shot. Lucina's hair looks nearly grey. :( Really hoping it's something they'll fix / roll back before release.
 

Weary Bones

Member
Nov 7, 2017
1,029
SoCal
Didn't we get a little Microsoft development on handhelds before? There was a Banjo game on GBA right after Rare was bought by Microsoft, although it wasn't Microsoft that published it. There was also a Halo DS briefly in development but I don't know the full story behind that. I remember reading at some point that Microsoft was less concerned with Nintendo handhelds because they didn't compete in that area.

In the past, I feel like Microsoft never looked at Nintendo's handheld division as a "threat" or a competition.

With the Switch being a portable console now, and Nintendo's lack of pursuit of a "power console" I can see why Microsoft and Nintendo are more willing than ever to work with each other.

Minecraft is probably doing amazing on Nintendo consoles, or something. There has to be some basis or ground for this "buddy buddy" that's been going on lately. Maybe that has nothing to do with Smash Bros. But if people are saying that this isn't anything new or out of the ordinary is kidding themselves.
 

Clov

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,929
AAAAAA I've been bamboozled once again!

Serious rebuttal: the timing of the Project Plan and Inkling being the first revealed character implies that there will be some significant Wii U representation here.

While true, it doesn't nessasarily mean that Wonder Red would make it, let alone ahead of someone like Elma, for example. Unless Wonder Red did very well on the ballot, I can't see them being playable at all due to how poorly the game sold in general.
 

r_n

Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,535
All right guys, I was finally able to boot up the Wii U this past weekend, and I spent some time trying to recreate some pictures for comparison. I haven't played Smash 4 in so long, so I might have gotten some animations/stages incorrect. The camera is pretty limited, and not knowing which stage many pictures were taken on kinda limited me, and the differences in stage lighting may have an effect on the pictures. I didn't have much time so I was only able to hit some easy comparisons.

ss_6.jpg
29292827818_1d523e3024_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg

29292830228_9ffc873af8_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294428107_2542601223_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163865041_664f4ba013_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
29292830088_006ecc39d8_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163862141_72a7e06bbe_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163862271_98ed2468f4_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292830448_174e706f45_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg
28294428477_8326cafc17_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163862601_32b9abde3a_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163862671_18b8ed159a_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294430847_a7d27056e5_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294431067_fc6b9e0c91_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294428667_4bb5c383b1_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
29292828468_28cdfe33ee_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163862931_9cbcdd39ba_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
42259639865_97b3856fe2_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163863141_4bd89cd228_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292828688_efd88639ba_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
42259639945_c14d255f4f_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163863261_520c9e5289_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294429107_6ac27f97f0_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
42259639995_fe6058e975_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg
28294429197_c3958e3430_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163863471_41017edcdc_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292829178_aa341afcc5_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294429407_d536ec2d8d_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
42259640115_6b1b610b80_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163863651_aa728c3677_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294429657_c7d3c44fa0_o.jpg

ss_6.jpg
28294432097_6c12d966f1_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163863981_56fb520681_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163863851_2d816aa5bd_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163864161_cdf10eb24f_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
28294432437_378be11249_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
29292828218_e304fbaa78_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294429787_bbeb12bfe5_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864381_98b5c0f998_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
28294432607_d8bcd32746_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294429887_f24dbc60a0_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
29292829858_79e23d1667_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864751_672eb67f92_o.jpg

ss_6.jpg
28294432757_5e82db4981_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294433037_5d5884c38b_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163861971_2e80e666b2_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864871_798ed2bf5f_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294433227_7cc17b3c98_o.jpg
some of these are quite nice, others about the same. Only one I'd say is worse is DK which is weird since I like the updated Diddy fur texture. Hopefully he gets another pass before release.

Dr. Mario in particular looks nicer which surprised me. Something about the coloring and the revised coat & undershirt textures
 

Deleted member 42221

User requested account closure
Banned
Apr 16, 2018
2,749
While true, it doesn't nessasarily mean that Wonder Red would make it, let alone ahead of someone like Elma, for example. Unless Wonder Red did very well on the ballot, I can't see them being playable at all due to how poorly the game sold in general.
Elma and (maybe) Captain Toad being in the game doesn't mean that Wonder Red won't. I feel like with Bayonetta in, another Platinum rep that is first party Nintendo would be relatively easy to organise, and Kamiya has shown that he loves characters from games he directed being in Smash. And like I said - PROPORTIONALLY Wonderful 101 shits on Xenoblade's (and several other Smash entrants') sales/overall game sales ratios.
 

Gartooth

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
8,440
The difference is that DK, Zelda, and Pokemon already have multiple characters in the game. Rhythm Heaven has close to nothing. In fact it has a weirdly low amount of representation for a million seller series with 3 games (at the time). No remixes, no assist trophy, no stage. Even series like Baten Kaitos, Mysterious Murasame Castle, and Style Savvy got remixes, yet Rhythm Heaven still has nothing. It's bizarre.

I don't think that increases Chorus Kids chances though. There are many popular IP that show up in Smash without characters but do come with stages or assist trophies. It could really go either way in being treated more like Wii Fit or more like Nintendogs.
 
Oct 27, 2017
3,257
All right guys, I was finally able to boot up the Wii U this past weekend, and I spent some time trying to recreate some pictures for comparison. I haven't played Smash 4 in so long, so I might have gotten some animations/stages incorrect. The camera is pretty limited, and not knowing which stage many pictures were taken on kinda limited me, and the differences in stage lighting may have an effect on the pictures. I didn't have much time so I was only able to hit some easy comparisons.

ss_6.jpg
29292827818_1d523e3024_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg

29292830228_9ffc873af8_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294428107_2542601223_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163865041_664f4ba013_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
29292830088_006ecc39d8_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163862141_72a7e06bbe_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163862271_98ed2468f4_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292830448_174e706f45_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg
28294428477_8326cafc17_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163862601_32b9abde3a_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163862671_18b8ed159a_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294430847_a7d27056e5_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294431067_fc6b9e0c91_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294428667_4bb5c383b1_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
29292828468_28cdfe33ee_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163862931_9cbcdd39ba_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
42259639865_97b3856fe2_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163863141_4bd89cd228_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292828688_efd88639ba_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
42259639945_c14d255f4f_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163863261_520c9e5289_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294429107_6ac27f97f0_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
42259639995_fe6058e975_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg
28294429197_c3958e3430_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163863471_41017edcdc_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292829178_aa341afcc5_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294429407_d536ec2d8d_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
42259640115_6b1b610b80_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163863651_aa728c3677_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294429657_c7d3c44fa0_o.jpg

ss_6.jpg
28294432097_6c12d966f1_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163863981_56fb520681_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163863851_2d816aa5bd_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163864161_cdf10eb24f_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
28294432437_378be11249_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
29292828218_e304fbaa78_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294429787_bbeb12bfe5_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864381_98b5c0f998_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
28294432607_d8bcd32746_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294429887_f24dbc60a0_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
29292829858_79e23d1667_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864751_672eb67f92_o.jpg

ss_6.jpg
28294432757_5e82db4981_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294433037_5d5884c38b_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163861971_2e80e666b2_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864871_798ed2bf5f_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294433227_7cc17b3c98_o.jpg
Thanks for doing this. I absolutely love the new lighting engine and all the new designs/animations. I really like what they did with Mr. Game & Watch.

Are you trying to give me hope, 'cause you're giving me hope.
I really want Wonder Red too, but I've given up hope. Maybe if we're lucky someone stuffed the Smash Ballot box with a thousands of vote through a bunch of ip address changing shenigans.
 

Deleted member 2793

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
15,368
I don't think that increases Chorus Kids chances though. There are many popular IP that show up in Smash without characters but do come with stages or assist trophies. It could really go either way in being treated more like Wii Fit or more like Nintendogs.
Nintendogs didn't become a recurring big IP like Rhythm Heaven tho. Also, RH actually has characters.
 

Clov

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,929
Elma and (maybe) Captain Toad being in the game doesn't mean that Wonder Red won't. I feel like with Bayonetta in, another Platinum rep that is first party Nintendo would be relatively easy to organise, and Kamiya has shown that he loves characters from games he directed being in Smash. And like I said - PROPORTIONALLY Wonderful 101 shits on Xenoblade's (and several other Smash entrants') sales/overall game sales ratios.

I mean, sure, it's not impossible. But in all honesty, how many people actually want Wonder Red? Plenty on this forum, sure, but outside here? I don't have the impression that many people care about W101, as fun of a game as it was.
 

Deleted member 42221

User requested account closure
Banned
Apr 16, 2018
2,749
I mean, sure, it's not impossible. But in all honesty, how many people actually want Wonder Red? Plenty on this forum, sure, but outside here? I don't have the impression that many people care about W101, as fun of a game as it was.
How many people WANTED Duck Hunt Dog? How many people WANTED Wii Fit Trainer? Villager? ROB? Marth? Ike?

Every Smash game has to have at least one pick that's either a weird choice for the game, or from a niche cut. Wonder Red fills that role well, and then some.

Also, there are a lot of people portbegging for Wonderful 101 on Switch.
 

Neoxon

Spotlighting Black Excellence - Diversity Analyst
Member
Oct 25, 2017
85,612
Houston, TX
How many people WANTED Duck Hunt Dog? How many people WANTED Wii Fit Trainer? Villager? ROB? Marth? Ike?

Every Smash game has to have at least one pick that's either a weird choice for the game, or from a niche cut. Wonder Red fills that role well, and then some.

Also, there are a lot of people portbegging for Wonderful 101 on Switch.
Seriously, is your goal specifically listed as "Fill Neoxon with as much hope for Wonder Red as possible"?
 

FiXalaS

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,569
Kuwait.
All right guys, I was finally able to boot up the Wii U this past weekend, and I spent some time trying to recreate some pictures for comparison. I haven't played Smash 4 in so long, so I might have gotten some animations/stages incorrect. The camera is pretty limited, and not knowing which stage many pictures were taken on kinda limited me, and the differences in stage lighting may have an effect on the pictures. I didn't have much time so I was only able to hit some easy comparisons.

ss_6.jpg
29292827818_1d523e3024_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg

29292830228_9ffc873af8_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294428107_2542601223_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163865041_664f4ba013_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
29292830088_006ecc39d8_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163862141_72a7e06bbe_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163862271_98ed2468f4_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292830448_174e706f45_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg
28294428477_8326cafc17_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163862601_32b9abde3a_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163862671_18b8ed159a_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294430847_a7d27056e5_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294431067_fc6b9e0c91_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294428667_4bb5c383b1_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
29292828468_28cdfe33ee_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163862931_9cbcdd39ba_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
42259639865_97b3856fe2_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163863141_4bd89cd228_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292828688_efd88639ba_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
42259639945_c14d255f4f_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
43163863261_520c9e5289_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294429107_6ac27f97f0_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
42259639995_fe6058e975_o.jpg

ss_5.jpg
28294429197_c3958e3430_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163863471_41017edcdc_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
29292829178_aa341afcc5_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
28294429407_d536ec2d8d_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
42259640115_6b1b610b80_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163863651_aa728c3677_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294429657_c7d3c44fa0_o.jpg

ss_6.jpg
28294432097_6c12d966f1_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163863981_56fb520681_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
43163863851_2d816aa5bd_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163864161_cdf10eb24f_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
28294432437_378be11249_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
29292828218_e304fbaa78_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294429787_bbeb12bfe5_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864381_98b5c0f998_o.jpg

ss_3.jpg
28294432607_d8bcd32746_o.jpg

ss_4.jpg
28294429887_f24dbc60a0_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
29292829858_79e23d1667_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864751_672eb67f92_o.jpg

ss_6.jpg
28294432757_5e82db4981_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294433037_5d5884c38b_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
43163861971_2e80e666b2_o.jpg

ss_2.jpg
43163864871_798ed2bf5f_o.jpg

ss_1.jpg
28294433227_7cc17b3c98_o.jpg

This is awesome, that is a lot of work, thanks!

Loving the look of Ultimate, The scale is looking different but it could be just the pictures. Villager not much but most of the rest is a big improvement.
 

Gartooth

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
8,440
Nintendogs didn't become a recurring big IP like Rhythm Heaven tho. Also, RH actually has characters.

At the time of Smash 4, Nintendogs was a recurring series though.

I'm not seeing why the Rhythm Heaven IP is considered likely for a character any more than say a Nintendo Land character. It just seems to circle back to that Smash 4 Chorus Kids concept.
 

Weiss

User requested ban
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
64,265
How many people WANTED Duck Hunt Dog? How many people WANTED Wii Fit Trainer? Villager? ROB? Marth? Ike?

Every Smash game has to have at least one pick that's either a weird choice for the game, or from a niche cut. Wonder Red fills that role well, and then some.

Also, there are a lot of people portbegging for Wonderful 101 on Switch.

Duck Hunt Dog was like Ice Climbers, Game & Watch, and ROB: the Retro pick.

Villager is from a massively popular franchise.

Wii Fit Trainer was deliberately meant to be an Out There choice.

Marth was there to rep Fire Emblem (and apparently was supposed to be in the first game), and Roy was there to promote his upcoming game.

I'm not saying it's impossible or that I don't want him, but given the failure of his game and Sakurai's statement that games with no future tend not to get representation, I don't think his chances are good.
 

Deleted member 2793

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
15,368
How many people WANTED Duck Hunt Dog? How many people WANTED Wii Fit Trainer? Villager? ROB? Marth? Ike?

Every Smash game has to have at least one pick that's either a weird choice for the game, or from a niche cut. Wonder Red fills that role well, and then some.

Also, there are a lot of people portbegging for Wonderful 101 on Switch.
I mean, dude, I also would love him, but he's not comparable at all to these characters. Duck Hunt and ROB are retro characters, Wii Fit Trainer is from one of Nintendo's biggest sellers, Villager was heavily requested lol, Marth was heavily requested as well and Ike wasn't that much but he was a character from the 9th FE game.

W101 is a recent flop, no other game in Smash fits this.
 

Village

Member
Oct 25, 2017
11,811
Sometimes I fear Sakurai will end up jaded by the Smash community and just not give a shit anymore. Man works way too hard to get harassed over adding MORE characters to the game.

Just be like Harada

ClVo2vAWIAA9ARh.jpg


just don't end up like Kamiya

Harada is the shit.

He strait up said something all fighting game devs should say

I'm not gonna put in that obscure ass character you ain't gonna play just because you like having them around, or unpopular ones. That shit is a waste of money and dev time
 

Clov

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,929
How many people WANTED Duck Hunt Dog? How many people WANTED Wii Fit Trainer? Villager? ROB? Marth? Ike?

Every Smash game has to have at least one pick that's either a weird choice for the game, or from a niche cut. Wonder Red fills that role well, and then some.

Also, there are a lot of people portbegging for Wonderful 101 on Switch.

Woah there! For one, Villager was a popular request people thought impossible because of Sakurai's comments. Two, I'm sure Marth was wanted by the Japanese fanbase at the time. Three, I definitely wanted Duck Hunt Dog.

Look at those franchises you've listed, though. They've sold well, or are part of a larger series that's sold well. Did W101? What's the future of that franchise? At the moment, it's looking like a whole lot of nothing.
 

Golnei

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,823
Dante, Amaterasu, Claire Redfield, Wonderful Ones and Viewtiful Joe are the only remaining newcomers.
 

Weary Bones

Member
Nov 7, 2017
1,029
SoCal
I'm expecting quite a few newcomers that don't fit the rules of newcomers in past smash games.

People keep saying "bottom of the barrel" and if that's true, we're going to get a lot of popular requests and maybe a few niche ones too. I think as far as sales go, it's not going to be as big of a factor anymore.
 

L Thammy

Spacenoid
Member
Oct 25, 2017
50,134
I actually think that there are some decisions made more in terms of prestige than on selling power. Mother gets a lot of love, and while we might not see it on bestsellers lists, the games appear high up on Famitsu's top Nintendo games list as determined by reader votes. Same went for Xenoblade, which was why I was confident that Shulk was going to be in Smash 4 going in.

In fact, let me go post that old list again. I'll bold every franchise that has a playable rep, lumping all the Mario stuff together. (Although, notice that Mario RPG is high up there - no wonder Geno got a Mii costume.)

  • 1. Super Mario Bros. NES
  • 2. Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time N64
  • 3. Super Mario 64 N64
  • 4. Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past SNES
  • 5. Mother 2 SNES
  • 6. Xenoblade Wii
  • 7. Legend of Zelda NES
  • 8. Super Mario RPG SNES
  • 9. Smash Bros. Melee GC
  • 10. Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword Wii
  • 11. Fire Emblem – Seisen no Keifu SNES
  • 12. Famicom Mukashi-banashi Famicom-DiscDrive
  • 13. Super Mario Kart SNES
  • 14. Famicom Tantei Club Part II Famicom-DiscDrive
  • 15. Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker GC
  • 16. Fire Emblem – Monsho no Nazo SNES
  • 17. Legend of Zelda – Links Awakening GB
  • 18. Super Mario World SNES
  • 19. Super Mario Sunshine GC
  • 19. Smash Bros. Brawl Wii
  • 21. Donkey Kong Country SNES
  • 22. Ice Climber NES
  • 23. Mother NES
  • 24. F-ZERO SNES
  • 25. Kirby Super Star SNES
  • 26. Mario Kart Wii Wii
  • 27. Mario Kart 64 N64
  • 28. Pokemon Red/Blue/Green/Pikachu GB
  • 29. Super Mario Bros. 3 NES
  • 30. Super Mario Galaxy Wii
  • 31. Star Fox SNES
  • 32. Magical Vacation GBA
  • 33. Kirbys Air Ride GC
  • 34. Golf NES
  • 35. Joy Mech Fight NES
  • 36. Donkey Kong Country 2 SNES
  • 37. Super Mario 64 DS DS
  • 38. Legend of Zelda – Twilight Princess Wii
  • 39. Legend of Zelda – Majoras Mask N64
  • 40. Animal Crossing: Wild World DS
  • 41. Donkey Kong NES
  • 42. Smash Bros. N64
  • 42. Volley Ball Famicom-DiscDrive
  • 44. Banjo-Tooie N64
  • 45. Baseball NES
  • 46. Famicom Tantei Club Famicom-DiscDrive
  • 47. Fire Emblem: Ankoku Ryū to Hikari no Tsurugi NES
  • 48. Metroid Famicom-DiscDrive
  • 48. Metroid II – Return of Samus GB
  • 50. Super Mario: Yoshis Island SNES

For better clarity, let's take all the bolded stuff out:

  • 12. Famicom Mukashi-banashi Famicom-DiscDrive
  • 14. Famicom Tantei Club Part II Famicom-DiscDrive
  • 32. Magical Vacation GBA
  • 34. Golf NES
  • 35. Joy Mech Fight NES
  • 42. Volley Ball Famicom-DiscDrive
  • 44. Banjo-Tooie N64
  • 45. Baseball NES
  • 46. Famicom Tantei Club Famicom-DiscDrive

That's most of them, and from what remains, Famicom Detective Club and Banjo Kazooie reps have both been discussed by Sakurai before. Famicom Detective Club got its trophy in Melee. Joy Mech Fight's main character was planned as an item in Melee and is an assist trophy in Ultimate now. Magical Vacation's got a number of trophies in Brawl.

Now, I'm not nearly confident enough to say that Wonder Red is likely because it's a little more than just niche. But I feel that he had some possibility get on for this reason, particularly as a DLC pick as that would already be geared more to the core audience. He does appear highly in online polls on English-speaking websites, so I don't think it's totally outside of belief that he could be in a Bayonetta situation.
 
Last edited:

r_n

Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,535
How long til the Smash Blog posts new content beyond Alolan Vulpix
Alolan Vulpix was in the e3 demo
The only new things shown by the blog have been music

e: And of those I think only Snipperclips & Brinstar Depths weren't in the demo. And Brinstar was an at-launch tune, not one detailed by the blog.
 

Deleted member 42221

User requested account closure
Banned
Apr 16, 2018
2,749
I want Geno so I don't think I should be disparaging any other characters' chances.
I legit believe Geno is more likely for Smash Ultimate than Wonder Red.

Truth be told, I know Wonder Red is unlikely. But he's an underdog, and I support the underdog. I made up all these statistical things to try and convince myself he's more likely than he is. But it's all hollow. I'll die alone and unloved, with a family that hates me.
 

Crayolan

Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,796
I don't think that increases Chorus Kids chances though. There are many popular IP that show up in Smash without characters but do come with stages or assist trophies. It could really go either way in being treated more like Wii Fit or more like Nintendogs.

Yeah, but Rhythm Heaven hasn't even been given the Nintendogs treatment despite it being well past the point that it'd deserve it. Like, if Rhythm Heaven got a stage, a remix, and an assist trophy I might be convinced that that's all it's gonna get because Sakurai doesn't think it's the right fit for a fighter. But it has none of that. And while there's nothing to really support this but my gut feeling, I feel like the absence of Rhythm Heaven stuff is due to them planning to add a bunch of stuff alongside Chorus Kids, but then scrapping it all and saving it for the next game after it was determined that the Chorus Kids were no longer on the roster.
 

Clov

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,929
I legit believe Geno is more likely for Smash Ultimate than Wonder Red.

Truth be told, I know Wonder Red is unlikely. But he's an underdog, and I support the underdog. I made up all these statistical things to try and convince myself he's more likely than he is. But it's all hollow. I'll die alone and unloved, with a family that hates me.

Hey, it's alright. I feel the same way about Lip! We all have characters we want that are super unlikely. Nothing wrong with that.
 

L Thammy

Spacenoid
Member
Oct 25, 2017
50,134
Animal Crossing is probably bigger than your favourite franchise, so Villager isn't really something to include in this argument. Let me post this from vgsaleswiki to keep us grounded:

Super Mario (627.51 million)
Pokémon (301.5 million)
Wii Series (203.15 million)
The Legend of Zelda (105.62 million)
Donkey Kong (56.1 million)
Game & Watch (43.4 million)[8]
Super Smash Bros (40 million)[9]
Kirby (36.5 million)[9]
Brain Age (34 million)[10]
Animal Crossing (32.4 million)[11][12][13]
Yoshi (29.17 million)[14]
Nintendogs (28.25 million)[15][16]
Wario (22 million)
Metroid (17.44 million)
Star Fox (12 million)
Splatoon (10.95 million)[17]
Big Brain Academy (10 million)
Fire Emblem (10 million)*
Luigi (10 million)
Tomodachi (9.96 million)[18][19]
F-Zero (5 million)
Pikmin (5 million)
Excite (5 million)
Nintendo Land (5 million)
 

L Thammy

Spacenoid
Member
Oct 25, 2017
50,134
I keep trying to post a list in quote tags so they don't take up too much space, but I end up typing spoiler tags instead. FUCK YOU FINGERS. DO WHAT I WANT YOU TO DO
 

Weiss

User requested ban
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
64,265
I legit believe Geno is more likely for Smash Ultimate than Wonder Red.

Truth be told, I know Wonder Red is unlikely. But he's an underdog, and I support the underdog. I made up all these statistical things to try and convince myself he's more likely than he is. But it's all hollow. I'll die alone and unloved, with a family that hates me.

Uh

Are you okay?
 

L Thammy

Spacenoid
Member
Oct 25, 2017
50,134
I legit believe Geno is more likely for Smash Ultimate than Wonder Red.

Truth be told, I know Wonder Red is unlikely. But he's an underdog, and I support the underdog. I made up all these statistical things to try and convince myself he's more likely than he is. But it's all hollow. I'll die alone and unloved, with a family that hates me.

Plenty of us support underdogs. You'll always be loved by the Underdog Club.
 

Gartooth

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
8,440
Yeah, but Rhythm Heaven hasn't even been given the Nintendogs treatment despite it being well past the point that it'd deserve it. Like, if Rhythm Heaven got a stage, a remix, and an assist trophy I might be convinced that that's all it's gonna get because Sakurai doesn't think it's the right fit for a fighter. But it has none of that. And while there's nothing to really support this but my gut feeling, I feel like the absence of Rhythm Heaven stuff is due to them planning to add a bunch of stuff alongside Chorus Kids, but then scrapping it all and saving it for the next game after it was determined that the Chorus Kids were no longer on the roster.

You're definitely right on the series being a weird absence so far in Smash. I feel like it has to be getting something more substantial this time around.
 

TriggerShy

Member
Mar 26, 2018
1,602
I'm expecting quite a few newcomers that don't fit the rules of newcomers in past smash games.

People keep saying "bottom of the barrel" and if that's true, we're going to get a lot of popular requests and maybe a few niche ones too. I think as far as sales go, it's not going to be as big of a factor anymore.

I don't get "bottom of the barrel" as a complaint, it's a good thing if you ask me. I don't see it as desperation to fill out a roster, but more as a chance for those "bottom of the barrel" characters to not be at the bottom anymore.
 

Deleted member 5535

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
13,656
Mojang has games on every platform out there, they're not an exclusive Microsoft studio. They were bought as a third party developer from day 1.
http://www.ign.com/articles/2014/09/15/microsoft-officially-buys-mojang-for-25-billion

And yes, Switch has Sony games that are as Sony as Minecraft is Microsoft.
https://www.polygon.com/2017/10/17/16488326/sony-nintendo-switch-game-tiny-metal-unties-label

I mean, one is Sony Music with a video game division and the other is SIE so there's a difference between them.
 

Deleted member 42221

User requested account closure
Banned
Apr 16, 2018
2,749
I'm going to ask this thread a specific question

Do we think this roster is going to have more characters from previously unrepresented series, or more characters from previously represented series?
 

Weary Bones

Member
Nov 7, 2017
1,029
SoCal
I don't get "bottom of the barrel" as a complaint, it's a good thing if you ask me. I don't see it as desperation to fill out a roster, but more as a chance for those "bottom of the barrel" characters to not be at the bottom anymore.

I am with you 100%

The two characters I want the most, one is a Zelda one-off villain and the other is the protagonist of a series in constant limbo.

I want both of them to be considered 'Nintendo all-stars' but to many others, they're considered 'bottom of the barrel'
 

Clov

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,929
I'm going to ask this thread a specific question

Do we think this roster is going to have more characters from previously unrepresented series, or more characters from previously represented series?

I think more characters from previously represented series, personally. I feel like Sakurai's going to focus a lot on fan favorite requests. I'm sure there's still more new franchises that will join, though!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.