This will probably be locked but what the hell, it's cool to revisit games years after they come out.
Looking back, I would still pick MGS4 as my GOTG despite all the backlash. No game did story and setpieces better and the gameplay was still sublime.
The Last of Us is a close second. MGS4 wins out because of the boss fights and setpieces.
Uncharted 2 is one game that i have second thoughts on, just couldnt get myself to play through the HD remaster. I would pick Mass Effect 2 as my third game with Uncharted 2 taking the fourth spot.
God of War 3 is another game i just cant play again despite loving it originally. I think KZ2 probably edges out GoW3, Halo 3, MAG, LBP2 and Resistance 3 to take my fifth spot.
This gen, Horizon is still my GOTG. Best combat in an open world game ever.
The Last guardian is probably the most emotionally exhausting game i've played since MGS4.
MGSV is still in my top despite the terrible story, lack of boss fights and setpieces. The ending and the sublime gameplay pretty much guarantee a spot in my top five.
Bloodborne and Battlefield 1 round out my top 5. I doubt BF1 would make the top 10 by the time this gen is done. DICE really ruined that game.