• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.

androvsky

Member
Oct 27, 2017
3,507
I'd hazard it's much more likely due to licensing and getting the games to work properly in the emulator, but if anyone has proof to the contrary I'd love to read it.
Any PS2 game currently available for sale on the PS3 has already cleared all hurdles needed to sell digitally and is current. There's no reason for publishers to want to avoid selling those games on a much hotter platform.

The emulator on the PS4 has a variety of very resource hungry games that the PS3 emulator would have struggled with. Simply getting one game to work as well as these do would mean dozens more work by default, and it's difficult to imagine Sony taking the extra power of the PS4 and somehow making an emulator with worse compatibility than the one they used for PS2 Classics on the PS3.

And Sony has stated outright several times that the trophies take a lot of work.
 

KalBalboa

Member
Oct 30, 2017
7,945
Massachusetts
The ability to add trophies to PS2 games seemed easy enough, but maybe their strategy should be to put a much larger team on the effort for a few months and build a catalog they can release monthly.
 

Deleted member 426

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
7,273
Any PS2 game currently available for sale on the PS3 has already cleared all hurdles needed to sell digitally and is current. There's no reason for publishers to want to avoid selling those games on a much hotter platform.

The emulator on the PS4 has a variety of very resource hungry games that the PS3 emulator would have struggled with. Simply getting one game to work as well as these do would mean dozens more work by default, and it's difficult to imagine Sony taking the extra power of the PS4 and somehow making an emulator with worse compatibility than the one they used for PS2 Classics on the PS3.

And Sony has stated outright several times that the trophies take a lot of work.
There's an awful lot of speculation passed off as common sense in this post.

Many but by no means all of the hurdles needed to republish the PS2 games on PS4 will be dealt with, but there are always new issues. The negotiations will have been for PS3 and PS3 only, so most negotiations will have to start again.

The emulator is entirely different to the PS3 one, so the idea that PS4>PS3 means it should be easier is just not correct. Especially as the PS3 emulator ups the resolution.

Also if Sony have said that adding trophy support takes tons extra work then fair enough, but imma need to see some receipts.

The real reason will be because:
-Sony do the emulation themselves, and I reckon they've just not put enough resource on it.
-Publishers prefer to release proper remasters or remakes and sell them for more than double the price. It's no coincidence that the PS2 games we've seen are Sony games, or games that were never going to get a proper remaster. It could also add a layer of complexity because publishers would be undecided as to whether they'd consider a full remaster in the future, and then they'd err on the side of safety and not do a PS2 Classic as a result.

Obviously last few points are my conjecture
 

AceofSpades

Banned
Oct 27, 2017
300
how can I find PS2 games section on the store?

I remember it was listed in the first column once you start the store.

US store btw.
 

Deleted member 8106

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,451
I find funny when people try to justify Sony. In my opinion all what Sony does, it needs to bring money as soon as possible. If Sony doesn't see the money immediately, they stop supporting that initiative. They did this already in the past with projects like Move, Vita, the 3D support for games during the Ps3 etc.
And they are doing it right now with PS2 Classics. Sony simply...tries, without even investing so much money or time on the project. If it's successful, they will keep on supporting it, if not they will dump it.
And with PS2 Classics Sony did so many wrong things, starting with the price, which is simply insane if compared to older games provided by GOG, Steam or whatever. Those are the original, untouched games running on an emulator. They only thing Sony does, it's introducing trophies, and they explained how tropy implementation works for PS2 games and it looks very easy to implement, honestly. But the price Sony asks for...is insane. It's totally random, with titles priced 20€ or more, some 15€, some 10€ and going on. There's not a vision, at least with PS1 Classic titles you had like two prices usually, here it seems each game has its own price.

If the PS2 Classics initiative failed, it's only Sony's fault.
 

erlim

Member
Oct 26, 2017
5,513
London
I find funny when people try to justify Sony. In my opinion all what Sony does, it needs to bring money as soon as possible. If Sony doesn't see the money immediately, they stop supporting that initiative. They did this already in the past with projects like Move, Vita, the 3D support for games during the Ps3 etc.
And they are doing it right now with PS2 Classics. Sony simply...tries, without even investing so much money or time on the project. If it's successful, they will keep on supporting it, if not they will dump it.
And with PS2 Classics Sony did so many wrong things, starting with the price, which is simply insane if compared to older games provided by GOG, Steam or whatever. Those are the original, untouched games running on an emulator. They only thing Sony does, it's introducing trophies, and they explained how tropy implementation works for PS2 games and it looks very easy to implement, honestly. But the price Sony asks for...is insane. It's totally random, with titles priced 20€ or more, some 15€, some 10€ and going on. There's not a vision, at least with PS1 Classic titles you had like two prices usually, here it seems each game has its own price.

If the PS2 Classics initiative failed, it's only Sony's fault.

PlayStationNow is a failure too, but they keep supporting that. It's not even worth the servers they keep it on.
 

Deleted member 8106

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 26, 2017
2,451
PlayStationNow is a failure too, but they keep supporting that. It's not even worth the servers they keep it on.
Probably it's because Sony paid for Gaikai and they need to do something with it. Also I think enough people use PSNow, if Sony keeps on supporting it, probably enough people subscribed to the service in order to make it on staying alive. Well, for now at least.

But it's a failure, yeah, if you consider the fact it's not even available in most countries.. It would be better, in my opinion, on offering something similar to XBox Game Pass, you pay a monthly fee, but you can download the game directly in your hdd. I mean, the original purpose was to play the games even without the original device they were released on, but they killed like 80% of devices capable to run PSNow.
 

Vashetti

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,554
I find funny when people try to justify Sony. In my opinion all what Sony does, it needs to bring money as soon as possible. If Sony doesn't see the money immediately, they stop supporting that initiative. They did this already in the past with projects like Move, Vita, the 3D support for games during the Ps3 etc.
And they are doing it right now with PS2 Classics. Sony simply...tries, without even investing so much money or time on the project. If it's successful, they will keep on supporting it, if not they will dump it.
And with PS2 Classics Sony did so many wrong things, starting with the price, which is simply insane if compared to older games provided by GOG, Steam or whatever. Those are the original, untouched games running on an emulator. They only thing Sony does, it's introducing trophies, and they explained how tropy implementation works for PS2 games and it looks very easy to implement, honestly. But the price Sony asks for...is insane. It's totally random, with titles priced 20€ or more, some 15€, some 10€ and going on. There's not a vision, at least with PS1 Classic titles you had like two prices usually, here it seems each game has its own price.

If the PS2 Classics initiative failed, it's only Sony's fault.

Sony has stated many times that Pubs set the prices for non-first-party content.
 

famikon

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
4,604
ベラルーシ
how can I find PS2 games section on the store?

I remember it was listed in the first column once you start the store.

US store btw.

good luck :)

TNHpvDb.png


The PS4's Library Of PS2 Games Is Only Getting More Disappointing / Kotaku

edit: if you use web store on PC, here's direct link – https://store.playstation.com/en-us/grid/STORE-MSF77008-PS2GAMESONPS4G/1

How different is the Japanese list?

it's bit weird, but there's no PS2-on-PS4 games at all in Japanese PS Store.

edit: actually they started adding games – but I see only Jak1/2/3 there.
 
Last edited:

Jamiethecomic

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5
UK
You would think with Xbox actively pursuing Xbox OG BC on Xbox One, sony would follow suit. I will always prefer PlayStation over xbox, but recently playstation have gotten so lazy and cocky that even their exciting features like trophies on PS2 games are slowly fading into the background of "I forgot they did that". I thought they were taking suggestions of games people want to put on their store? I understand there may be a case of licence and tech issues to iron out, but it would be nice to see they have acknoledged our requests, like a simple blog post of their playstation blog site. I want my Shadow Hearts 1-3 damn it!

Also, was JAX really worth the effort considering 1-3 had HD remakes on the PS3? Surely it would of been easier to port the PS3 HD Classics rather than programming the PS2 version.
 

Vashetti

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,554
You would think with Xbox actively pursuing Xbox OG BC on Xbox One, sony would follow suit. I will always prefer PlayStation over xbox, but recently playstation have gotten so lazy and cocky that even their exciting features like trophies on PS2 games are slowly fading into the background of "I forgot they did that". I thought they were taking suggestions of games people want to put on their store? I understand there may be a case of licence and tech issues to iron out, but it would be nice to see they have acknoledged our requests, like a simple blog post of their playstation blog site. I want my Shadow Hearts 1-3 damn it!

Also, was JAX really worth the effort considering 1-3 had HD remakes on the PS3? Surely it would of been easier to port the PS3 HD Classics rather than programming the PS2 version.

Porting the PS3 versions would be far more costly and intensive than dropping the PS2 .ISO files into the PS4's PS2 emulator.

There's little to no programming involved, the PS4 has a purpose built PS2 emulator designed to run as many PS2 titles as accurately as possible.

The PS3 versions are also missing graphics effects that the PS2 versions on PS4 keep intact.
 

dabri

Member
Nov 2, 2017
1,728
I'm still hoping xenosaga series comes out. I don't want to pay $50 for a used copy of 3
 

Terraforce

One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
18,918
how can I find PS2 games section on the store?

I remember it was listed in the first column once you start the store.

US store btw.
You go to the "Explore" section under games then scroll all the way to the right and you should see it. It's basucally like upttung something on the bottom shelves at the far end of a closet. And they wonder why they don't sell.
 
Oct 25, 2017
1,700
Sony is the absolute worst with their classic content. Out of the big 3, I'd argue they've been handling it the worst out of everyone. (Yes, even worse than Nintendo, who doesn't exactly do the best with their classic stuff either).

It's so frustrating that the PS2 on PS4 games have been all but buried on the store and there doesn't seem to be much else coming out. Big surprise, yet another program Sony dumped at the first sign of resistance. Not to mention the absurd prices attached to the games that ARE on there. Meanwhile PS Now is still limited to PS3/4 games, with no sign of that changing anytime soon. If I want to play Metal Gear Solid, I seriously have to dig out my PS3 and play it on there? Because reasons?

If Sony doesn't straighten out this BC/Classic stuff by the time PS5 rolls around, Xbox is going to get my money instead. The fact that it hasn't been sorted already and we're 4 years into the PS4's life doesn't give me much hope for the future.
 

kc44135

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,725
Ohio
Sony is the absolute worst with their classic content. Out of the big 3, I'd argue they've been handling it the worst out of everyone. (Yes, even worse than Nintendo, who doesn't exactly do the best with their classic stuff either).

It's so frustrating that the PS2 on PS4 games have been all but buried on the store and there doesn't seem to be much else coming out. Big surprise, yet another program Sony dumped at the first sign of resistance. Not to mention the absurd prices attached to the games that ARE on there. Meanwhile PS Now is still limited to PS3/4 games, with no sign of that changing anytime soon. If I want to play Metal Gear Solid, I seriously have to dig out my PS3 and play it on there? Because reasons?

If Sony doesn't straighten out this BC/Classic stuff by the time PS5 rolls around, Xbox is going to get my money instead. The fact that it hasn't been sorted already and we're 4 years into the PS4's life doesn't give me much hope for the future.
Well said! I agree completely, and will also be passing on PS5 if things don't improve on the BC front at least. Hopefully, Xbox's efforts in this area will force Sony to reevaluate their stance on this, and provide better legacy support in the future. It's such a shame that they have so many fantastic games on their previous platforms, yet view and treat them like trash.
 

LiquidSolid

Member
Oct 26, 2017
4,731
There's an awful lot of speculation passed off as common sense in this post.

Many but by no means all of the hurdles needed to republish the PS2 games on PS4 will be dealt with, but there are always new issues. The negotiations will have been for PS3 and PS3 only, so most negotiations will have to start again.

The emulator is entirely different to the PS3 one, so the idea that PS4>PS3 means it should be easier is just not correct. Especially as the PS3 emulator ups the resolution.

Also if Sony have said that adding trophy support takes tons extra work then fair enough, but imma need to see some receipts.

The real reason will be because:
-Sony do the emulation themselves, and I reckon they've just not put enough resource on it.
-Publishers prefer to release proper remasters or remakes and sell them for more than double the price. It's no coincidence that the PS2 games we've seen are Sony games, or games that were never going to get a proper remaster. It could also add a layer of complexity because publishers would be undecided as to whether they'd consider a full remaster in the future, and then they'd err on the side of safety and not do a PS2 Classic as a result.

Obviously last few points are my conjecture
You really think Sony engineered a new PS2 emulator from scratch just for the PS4? That would be a complete waste of time and resources. The PS4's PS2 emulator will be the "2.0" version of the PS3's PS2 emulator, with the same core but adding the ability to reward trophies, increase the native resolution (not just upscaling like the PS3's one) and so on.

I also don't buy the reasoning that publishers would prefer to release their games as remasters or remakes than as PS2 Classics. That might be the case for the most prominent games but there's hundreds of PS2 games out there that wouldn't justify a proper remaster/remake, especially from companies who've seemingly forgotten they have great games in their back catalogues anyway (I'm looking at you, Konami and Sega). Plus, if that were the case then I think we would've seen far more remasters than we have.

That said, I agree with a lot of what you said. I don't buy that trophies are some huge problem that slows things down, I think the big issue is Sony's handling everything themselves and they haven't put many resources onto it. I'm betting the recent PSP remasters have cut into those resources too. Sony overall just doesn't seem to give enough of a shit to put many resources into this initiative, which seems like a really f'n stupid plan if the goal is for the PS4 to be the beginning of Sony building a library that will be compatible with and built on by future PlayStation's.

it's bit weird, but there's no PS2-on-PS4 games at all in Japanese PS Store.

edit: actually they started adding games – but I see only Jak1/2/3 there.
Star Ocean 3 as well.
 

5taquitos

Member
Oct 27, 2017
12,897
OR
You really think Sony engineered a new PS2 emulator from scratch just for the PS4? That would be a complete waste of time and resources. The PS4's PS2 emulator will be the "2.0" version of the PS3's PS2 emulator, with the same core but adding the ability to reward trophies, increase the native resolution (not just upscaling like the PS3's one) and so on.
Obviously I have no actual insight, but I'd be willing to bet most, if not all, of the emulator was built from scratch for the PS4, considering the massive architectural differences between the two systems.
 
Last edited:
Dec 2, 2017
3,435
I just want Suikoden IV. I know it's not the best one but it's the only one of the original five that I haven't played, and that series will probably never be seen again in the form that it was.
 

DangerMouse

Member
Oct 25, 2017
22,402
Finally got Star Ocean 3 thanks it finally getting on sale.

Obviously I have no actual insight, but I'd be willing to bet most, of not all, of the emulator was built from scratch for the PS4, considering the massive architectural differences between the two systems.
This would be my guess as well, that they've had to mostly start over on their emulator due to this.
 

erlim

Member
Oct 26, 2017
5,513
London
It's a catch 22 at this point. Sony seems to have a Kylo Rennian philosophy of killing the past. On one hand, we see their first parties taking creative risks with new franchises, but then we see a absolute refusal to offer BC.
 

Revven

Member
Oct 27, 2017
834
Man I'm sad we definitely won't get niche anime fighting games like Dragon Ball Z Infinite World or just even Dragon Ball Z Budokai Tenkaichi 3. Such a wasted opportunity. It's literally the only way BT3 could probably come out since Bamco seems unwilling to do any remastered collection of 1-3.
 

lupinko

Member
Oct 26, 2017
6,154
I personally blame trophies again for this poor effort. Not only are they pointless but it gives Sony an "excuse" for the dearth of titles.
 

xem

Member
Oct 31, 2017
2,043
they really should just release socom with even LAN support and let the community figure out the online infrastructure.
 

xGrizzly

Member
Dec 3, 2017
1,148
Atlanta
Man I'm sad we definitely won't get niche anime fighting games like Dragon Ball Z Infinite World or just even Dragon Ball Z Budokai Tenkaichi 3. Such a wasted opportunity. It's literally the only way BT3 could probably come out since Bamco seems unwilling to do any remastered collection of 1-3.
A shame that Budokai 3 isnt on this, the potential for this initiative is massive if they took it seriously like Microsoft but instead they rather half-ass it, a damn shame really.
 

Terraforce

One Winged Slayer
The Fallen
Oct 27, 2017
18,918
Man I'm sad we definitely won't get niche anime fighting games like Dragon Ball Z Infinite World or just even Dragon Ball Z Budokai Tenkaichi 3. Such a wasted opportunity. It's literally the only way BT3 could probably come out since Bamco seems unwilling to do any remastered collection of 1-3.
Right? I'm loving FighterZ, but boy I'd pay double for the Budokai collection to be ported over.
 

KalBalboa

Member
Oct 30, 2017
7,945
Massachusetts
So, Metal Slug Anthology is on sale for ~$5 this weekend.

Metal Slug 3, standalone, is ALSO on sale for $4.50.

Can anyone give me some insight on the PS2 on PS4 version of the Anthology? I see nothing but glowing reviews for Metal Slug 3 on PS4 (cross-buy, too), but I know jack about the series.