• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Oct 29, 2017
2,619

View: https://twitter.com/alecrobbins/status/1618335768631734273?s=20&t=8jWmQo4WpBR_VXZqQIE_Eg

aLec robBins
@alecrobbins

·

to my knowledge, justin's only real creative involvement with rick & morty since probably season 3 is that he recorded the voices from his own basement. i'm told he wasn't welcome in the writers room because of multiple covered-up internal WB investigations re: sexual misconduct.

Alec Robins is narrative director at SquanchGames.

If true, WB has been covering for Roiland for years.

So, like… here's the thing.
I get why you wouldn't outright kill the show (innocent people get to keep their jobs, it makes a lot of money for AS, and likely single-handedly keeps them from getting the WB axe, etc), but this point, as it's becoming more and more obvious that people knew, and knew for YEARS… yeah fucking kill the show jesus.

Between the sexual assault cover up at Squanch Games itself, this, him being buddy buddy and giving known Neo-Nazi Jontron money (which is where I personally got on the "fuck this guy and the horse he rode in on" train), the already well documented toxic workplace ("fuck the union").

Like it's becoming more and more clear this dude is a monster, and for the fanbase is effectively inseparable from the art. Perhaps the early warning signs should have been that the Dhoc and Mharty "pilot" shorts was Doc tricking Mharty into performing sexual favors for him. It's been rotten from the core from the very start. Why not start anew, give those writers and animators some time to pitch new shows and go with one of those.
 

BaconHat

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,162
So, like… here's the thing.
I get why you wouldn't outright kill the show (innocent people get to keep their jobs, it makes a lot of money for AS, and likely single-handedly keeps them from getting the WB axe, etc), but this point, as it's becoming more and more obvious that people knew, and knew for YEARS… yeah fucking kill the show jesus.

Between the sexual assault cover up at Squanch Games itself, this, him being buddy buddy and giving known Neo-Nazi Jontron money (which is where I personally got on the "fuck this guy and the horse he rode in on" train), the already well documented toxic workplace ("fuck the union").

Like it's becoming more and more clear this dude is a monster, and for the fanbase is effectively inseparable from the art. Perhaps the early warning signs should have been that the Dhoc and Mharty "pilot" shorts was Doc tricking Mharty into performing sexual favors for him. It's been rotten from the core from the very start. Why not start anew, give those writers and animators some time to pitch new shows and go with one of those.
I don't think we live in a world where that is in any way feasible. No company will pay to keep an entire staff to try to pitch stuff for an indeterminate period of time to try to find interesting pitches, with no guarantees. Especially when their current contract ensure that they have their jobs for at least 4 additional seasons, which is almost unheard us in animation, much less in our current situation with the inflation, so no way adult swim would create a new contract that offer so much based on nothing but wishes that they get the genie in a bottle a second time.
 
Oct 29, 2017
2,619
I don't think we live in a world where that is in any way feasible. No company will pay to keep an entire staff to try to pitch stuff for an indeterminate period of time to try to find interesting pitches, with no guarantees. Especially when their current contract ensure that they have their jobs for at least 4 additional seasons, which is almost unheard us in animation, much less in our current situation with the inflation, so no way adult swim would create a new contract that offer so much based on nothing but wishes that they get the genie in a bottle a second time.
Yeah, I know its not realistic, but I still think it should be done.
When the announcement broke, and they claimed the show would continue, I assumed that they're gonna run out the current contract and choose not to renew when it ends, which probably will be the best option (but, unless Justin's really bad with contracts he'll still technically get paid for all of it)
 

Vonocourt

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,650
Yeah, I know its not realistic, but I still think it should be done.
When the announcement broke, and they claimed the show would continue, I assumed that they're gonna run out the current contract and choose not to renew when it ends, which probably will be the best option (but, unless Justin's really bad with contracts he'll still technically get paid for all of it)
The still have forty episodes for the current contract that's the thing. They're years off from having a discussion of renewal, which I doubt will happen.
 

Jive Turkey

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,169
Considering how quickly AS, Hulu, and Squanch made these announcements, I wouldn't be surprised if they had these contingencies in place already. They knew who he is.
 

SpankyDoodle

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,082
Just to add to this. Buying the DVDs, which are still printed puts money in John's pockets.
Right, for clarification he's only been cut out of the reboot. I don't think I said/didn't mean to imply otherwise but good to specify for those who still like the show but don't want to give money to a child rapist

Also makes me wonder if he got anything from that Nicktoons Smash clone or if that happened after Nick did whatever they did to excise him from the franchise

So, like… here's the thing.
I get why you wouldn't outright kill the show (innocent people get to keep their jobs, it makes a lot of money for AS, and likely single-handedly keeps them from getting the WB axe, etc), but this point, as it's becoming more and more obvious that people knew, and knew for YEARS… yeah fucking kill the show jesus.
Or, hear me out, keep the show going for the people who aren't abusive predators and kick the one who is the fuck off when you learn about it, not years later when it leaks that you've been covering it up. From what it sounds like in that tweet, the writers did what they had the power to do to keep him out, it was on the higher ups to do the right thing and remove him instead of hiding it.
 

crimsonECHIDNA

▲ Legend ▲
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,681
Florida

View: https://twitter.com/alecrobbins/status/1618335768631734273?s=20&t=8jWmQo4WpBR_VXZqQIE_Eg

aLec robBins
@alecrobbins

·

to my knowledge, justin's only real creative involvement with rick & morty since probably season 3 is that he recorded the voices from his own basement. i'm told he wasn't welcome in the writers room because of multiple covered-up internal WB investigations re: sexual misconduct.

Alec Robins is narrative director at SquanchGames.

If true, WB has been covering for Roiland for years.


Explains why they are so steadfast in playing damage control for Ezra Miller.
 

Dakkon

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,292
Considering how quickly AS, Hulu, and Squanch made these announcements, I wouldn't be surprised if they had these contingencies in place already. They knew who he is.

I imagine most (smart) companies have contingencies in place if anything happens to higher ups, not just because of stuff like this but because well, dying happens.

Like, I would bet money that Disney has a backup plan if Kevin Fiege isn't around anymore, not because he might be a pedophile but because he could just die out of nowhere at any minute.

The only reason it happened so fast is because the charge is so severe, obvious, and out in the open that there's no reason to really deliberate about it. The opportunity cost isn't really there. If anything, I'd argue it happening so fast says a lot about how much they think he is important to the show.
 
Oct 27, 2017
15,139
When the show comes back, I'm sure they'll address this in some weird, meta way.

They could just have them come out of a smoke dimension in the cold open at the beginning of S7 coughing and make some comment about how it makes them feel like they've been smoking 40 a day for the last decade and they hope it doesn't change their voices.

I think it could be fun if they did a pair of celebrity voice actors for a season or a few episodes before settling back into regular VAs. They could do any crazy shit and justify it through multiverse shenanigans. Someone like George Clooney and Emma Thompson as R&M doing the same vocal affectations would be super fun!

But yeah, fuck Roiland and I'm glad the show isn't cancelled. Hopefully there is something contractual that if convicted of a certain crime he loses all rights and royalties for future episodes.
 

RagnarokX

Member
Oct 26, 2017
15,840
I told my girlfriend they should try an episode similar to the Return of Chef. Extra points for the results sounding as crude!


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCgp9gwYaIU

That situation was pretty bad how it all went down. Hayes objected to how Matt and Trey depicted Scientology but understood them. Years later a statement was made in his name saying he wanted to be released from his contract citing religious intolerance. After they killed off Chef it was revealed that Hayes had had a stroke and couldn't make decisions for himself and one of his Scientology friends had forged the statement. His income was sharply reduced as a result and he died 2 years later from another stroke.
 
Oct 31, 2017
12,181
wow look at this guy bragging about having a girlfriend

wut

That situation was pretty bad how it all went down. Hayes objected to how Matt and Trey depicted Scientology but understood them. Years later a statement was made in his name saying he wanted to be released from his contract citing religious intolerance. After they killed off Chef it was revealed that Hayes had had a stroke and couldn't make decisions for himself and one of his Scientology friends had forged the statement. His income was sharply reduced as a result and he died 2 years later from another stroke.

When I found that out, I was sad.

Strangely, we wouldn't have had much more Hayes either way considering those issues.
 

beat

Member
Oct 28, 2017
2,658

View: https://twitter.com/alecrobbins/status/1618335768631734273?s=20&t=8jWmQo4WpBR_VXZqQIE_Eg

aLec robBins
@alecrobbins

·

to my knowledge, justin's only real creative involvement with rick & morty since probably season 3 is that he recorded the voices from his own basement. i'm told he wasn't welcome in the writers room because of multiple covered-up internal WB investigations re: sexual misconduct.

Alec Robins is narrative director at SquanchGames.

If true, WB has been covering for Roiland for years.

The sex dragons ep was s4. 😬
And the piss guy villain was s6. 😬😬
 

Bengraven

Powered by Friendship™
Member
Oct 26, 2017
27,134
Florida
Considering how quickly AS, Hulu, and Squanch made these announcements, I wouldn't be surprised if they had these contingencies in place already. They knew who he is.

Honestly, that statement from the narrative director at Squanch Games where they say WB has been covering this up for years makes me kind of go:

"So you knew this and yet you worked with him on this game that just came out? how long did you know this for?"
 

SalvaPot

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
8,620
Honestly, that statement from the narrative director at Squanch Games where they say WB has been covering this up for years makes me kind of go:

"So you knew this and yet you worked with him on this game that just came out? how long did you know this for?"
Workers and people in general have a "keep your head down and mind your own business" attitude in general and honestly I don't blame them, that guy was not the police nor had hard evidence to take Justin down, and maybe quitting his job and putting his livelyhood at risk was not worth it.

So I doubt he "knew", heard of it, sure, had a strong suspicion, yes, maybe was present when something happened, maybe. But we always seem quick to judge people for "Not doing something if you knew", when we don't know the circunstances of said knowledge and who they might affect.
 

KingM

Member
Oct 28, 2017
4,506
[/QUOTE]
Honestly, that statement from the narrative director at Squanch Games where they say WB has been covering this up for years makes me kind of go:

"So you knew this and yet you worked with him on this game that just came out? how long did you know this for?"
No one wants to be the one who
A) forces people to be put into the spotlight for being harassed/assaulted
B) Be the main character for fanboy ire
C) have you're career/life ruined by a vengeful prick with power and money.

So it's hard to speak up.
 
Last edited:

Pwnz

Member
Oct 28, 2017
14,279
Places
Make Craig Ferguson Rick, as a former and severe alcoholic and a talented comedian he's a good fit. Voice acting remotely is an easy gig.
 

UrbanDandy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,580

View: https://twitter.com/alecrobbins/status/1618335768631734273?s=20&t=8jWmQo4WpBR_VXZqQIE_Eg

aLec robBins
@alecrobbins

·

to my knowledge, justin's only real creative involvement with rick & morty since probably season 3 is that he recorded the voices from his own basement. i'm told he wasn't welcome in the writers room because of multiple covered-up internal WB investigations re: sexual misconduct.

Alec Robins is narrative director at SquanchGames.

If true, WB has been covering for Roiland for years.

And of course, Mr. Twitter and likely friend of Roiland's (due to his cameo), Elon Musk is not making this better.
 

The Adder

Member
Oct 25, 2017
18,321
The sex dragons ep was s4. 😬
And the piss guy villain was s6. 😬😬
One of those was a bad episode, but I don't see anything 😬worthy about either of them.

The incest baby? That's a 😬worthy episode.


View: https://twitter.com/alecrobbins/status/1618335768631734273?s=20&t=8jWmQo4WpBR_VXZqQIE_Eg

aLec robBins
@alecrobbins

·

to my knowledge, justin's only real creative involvement with rick & morty since probably season 3 is that he recorded the voices from his own basement. i'm told he wasn't welcome in the writers room because of multiple covered-up internal WB investigations re: sexual misconduct.

Alec Robins is narrative director at SquanchGames.

If true, WB has been covering for Roiland for years.

Real reason they stopped doing Interdimensional Cable.
 

SpankyDoodle

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,082
Real reason they stopped doing Interdimensional Cable.
Tbf it also completely fucks the production pipeline to have to design and board everything after the improvised sequences are recorded, and I think they've said as much before, but yeah

Like typically it's script -> boards -> characters/props/bgs/etc -> record -> animatic -> animation (or sometimes in a crunch temp audio is used to make the animatic before a record) but with the Interdimensional Cable episodes, steps 2 and 3 couldn't be completed until after the records were done, and those are both really involved steps.
 

sandyph

Member
Oct 31, 2017
1,056
So, like… here's the thing.
I get why you wouldn't outright kill the show (innocent people get to keep their jobs, it makes a lot of money for AS, and likely single-handedly keeps them from getting the WB axe, etc), but this point, as it's becoming more and more obvious that people knew, and knew for YEARS… yeah fucking kill the show jesus.

so we found out that Roiland have been harassing's his co-worker at R&M for years at least and you think the best solution is to fire them all while Roiland will still get hundreds of thousands if not millions in residual from existing toys/shows/merchandise ?
 
Last edited:

Psittacus

Member
Oct 27, 2017
5,967
Workers and people in general have a "keep your head down and mind your own business" attitude in general and honestly I don't blame them, that guy was not the police nor had hard evidence to take Justin down, and maybe quitting his job and putting his livelyhood at risk was not worth it.
There's a reason these things tend to build up for years and then dramatically blow up. One person speaking up is easy to silence, a bunch of them are not.
 

OaklandKao

Member
Mar 21, 2022
2,918
Right, for clarification he's only been cut out of the reboot. I don't think I said/didn't mean to imply otherwise but good to specify for those who still like the show but don't want to give money to a child rapist

Also makes me wonder if he got anything from that Nicktoons Smash clone or if that happened after Nick did whatever they did to excise him from the franchise


Or, hear me out, keep the show going for the people who aren't abusive predators and kick the one who is the fuck off when you learn about it, not years later when it leaks that you've been covering it up. From what it sounds like in that tweet, the writers did what they had the power to do to keep him out, it was on the higher ups to do the right thing and remove him instead of hiding it.
No, the only reason he got money from the DVDs is because he agreed to do the art and commentaries.
 
Oct 29, 2017
2,619
so we found out that Roiland have been harassing's his co-worker at R&M for years at least and you think the best solution is to fire them all while Roiland will still get hundreds of thousands if not millions in residual from existing toys/shows/merchandise ?
Clearly not if you read the second half of my post you conveniently left off in your response
 

Richiek

Member
Nov 2, 2017
12,063
I think the implication is they're about Roiland.



They're friends and Roiland got him a cameo on the show apparently.

1000


The name of his character is "Elon Tusk". That's not even a clever pun.
 
Oct 27, 2017
42,948
Yeah, I know its not realistic, but I still think it should be done.
When the announcement broke, and they claimed the show would continue, I assumed that they're gonna run out the current contract and choose not to renew when it ends, which probably will be the best option (but, unless Justin's really bad with contracts he'll still technically get paid for all of it)
I don't think it should be and we honestly need to really rethink why this is always called for. Whether it's in shows or games or movies, the idea that the hundreds to thousands of people should be negatively affected because of the actions of a single or at most handful of higher ups, far removed from them or their knowledge, is a bit extreme. Especially when we also call out companies for frivolous mass layoffs. It just doesn't rub me right.

It's easy to say it's the morally right thing to do when none of us are affected or losing our jobs. It's another when you're in it and told "Hey some distant exec did some heinous shit, we're going to have to let all of you go"
 

Bengraven

Powered by Friendship™
Member
Oct 26, 2017
27,134
Florida
I feel like once the legal dust settles in a few years we'll get an episode of Harmontown where Dan will lay out his perspective. I'm kind of interested in knowing how much he knew, what his relationship with Roiland before and after the full allegations came out, what they did to protect women on the show afterwards especially considering Harmon's own past. And Dan Harmon is the kind of person who I think would be open about all this going by past Harmontowns where he has talked about his own flaws whether they are comically for unimpactful or seriously for the darker things.
 

BUNTING1243

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,716
I feel like once the legal dust settles in a few years we'll get an episode of Harmontown where Dan will lay out his perspective. I'm kind of interested in knowing how much he knew, what his relationship with Roiland before and after the full allegations came out, what they did to protect women on the show afterwards especially considering Harmon's own past. And Dan Harmon is the kind of person who I think would be open about all this going by past Harmontowns where he has talked about his own flaws whether they are comically for unimpactful or seriously for the darker things.
Isn't harmontown over?