It was a really tough call for me between A Link Between Worlds, The Last of Us and Super Mario 3D World. Three amazing but very different games.
When I did my Top 10 that year, I put ALBW at #1 in what was essentially a coin flip with The Last of Us, but if I had to do it again now I'd go with TLOU. ALBW really resonated with me at the time and I still feel very strongly about that game, but it hasn't stuck with me over the years in the same way that The Last of Us has.