I suspect that people simply didn't have the time to spend time with her that late in the game. Happened to me as well. Persona 5 Royal redeemed her in a way since time managmemt was alot easier.
Persona 5 character popularity vote result in Japan
- Thread starter Xenosaga
- Start date
Agreed. Could have not cared less on either characters. Akechi's story was the absolute low point in P5 and in P5R
I literally ignored every meet-ups etc. with Akechi which apparently resulted me missing some additional story beats and areas - zero regrets, because again, I just can't find any redeemable quality on the character.
...
Would be curious to know where Yoshizawa and Maruki would have landed if those have been included in the poll. After finishing Royal, Yoshizawa was easily my favorite and Maruki was close behind.
I feel like this is important to note. The results aren't going to be completely Japan centric as it was open to the entire world. As well, the group system they used to conduct the poll.
Last edited:
The voting was a weird group system. You could only vote for one character in each group. For instance, MC Ryuji and Ann were in the same group, and Akechi, Futaba and Haru were in another group. So you could vote for both the protagonist and Akechi, but not for two characters in the same group. That's why some of those results feel off.
Apparently the polling for was really dumb. From what I've read the poll was done like this
Characters were separated in 3 different polls so it wasn't a singular poll where you voted for your favorite.
- Joker/Ann/Ryuji
- Yusuke/Morgana/Makoto
- Futaba/Haru/Akechi
Explains why Joker is so high and why Ann and Ryuji are so low.
Characters were separated in 3 different polls so it wasn't a singular poll where you voted for your favorite.
- Joker/Ann/Ryuji
- Yusuke/Morgana/Makoto
- Futaba/Haru/Akechi
Explains why Joker is so high and why Ann and Ryuji are so low.
Why is protagonist even on the list
I think those are different fanbases.
Fuck all the Ryuji haters. He has some of the best character development in the game and is a much better "comic relief" character than in previous iterations. I really don't get why folks seem so hot on Makoto. Her sister is far more compelling.
Wow...Akechi is a serial killer and all of his "likeable" qualities were literally a facade he put on to get close to the phantom thieves.
He is a garbage character and people should get a side eye if they say they like him the most, unless its just for his looks, I guess.
He is a garbage character and people should get a side eye if they say they like him the most, unless its just for his looks, I guess.
Akechi at 3 really?
I hated that character with a passion lol.
Also surprised they would vote the non-character character as number 1.
I hated that character with a passion lol.
Also surprised they would vote the non-character character as number 1.
You know he's not real right
After royal he's deserving of top three. The type of character trope he is has always been ridiculously popular, I think era is the only place that is so against his character. I always assumed this was due to this place's aversion to anime tropes but I'm not sure.
Last edited:
I'd probably rank the characters like so. (I'm excluding Joker because obviously I'm going to like my self-insert character lol. And I'm excluding Royal and Strikers characters to keep it simple, even though I think they should be included.)
1) Makoto
Smart, cool and assertive. She brings some much needed maturity and logic to the party. Kind of crazy they don't make her the leader. I also love her fighting style and her motorcycle persona lol.
2) Futaba
I relate to Futaba in a lot of ways. She loves computers and technology, but she has social anxiety that makes it hard for her to speak with people or go out to places she wants to go to. I'm not a total shut-in and haven't suffered the same kind of trauma she has, but I can empathize with her. She's way smarter than me, though -- I'm no super hacker. Also, she had one of the best palaces and story. Also, Also, I like little sister characters.
3) Ann
For me, the best part of Persona 5 was the beginning of the game, when you're an outcast and you have a very small social network. It was refreshing compared to Persona 3 and 4. And I related to it a lot since I was also an outcast in high school and got into a lot of trouble. I transferred schools a lot and every time I did I felt more distant from everyone else. In my experience, the transfer kid does not become popular just because they're the new kid. I liked Ann because she saw through the bullshit and confided in me. Despite being a beautiful up and coming model, she did not hide behind a fake facade. She too was an outcast in ways, was deeply troubled, and needed help. I bonded with her early on and choose her for all of the special events/romance options throughout the course of the game.
4) Akechi
Akechi is really irritating, though it's by design. He's your rival; he captivates audiences with his intelligence, charm and strong sense of justice. He constantly turns public opinion against you, grounding the Thieves whenever things start going to their heads. As the story progresses, things continue to get very tense between you, leading up to several major twists. It's just a real shame that the game decided to spoil these twists for you by giving some very unsubtle hints/scenes leading up to them. I hate that shit. I didn't play vanilla Persona 5, but to my understanding his character is fleshed out a lot more in the Royal version. So I can understand why people would especially hate him if they only played Vanilla.
I don't have any great screenshots of Akechi. I didn't care much for him for most of my playthrough. Once he started to grow on me, I think the Share button had been disabled by that point. 🤷♂️
5) Ryuji
Ryuji was great at the start of the game. He was your first friend at your new school. You reluctantly bond with him because you're both outcasts and you've got no one else. Even though he's kind of annoying, he's a good guy that got done dirty by corrupt adults and now he wants to get back at them. (This is a recurring theme throughout the game that sadly loses steam as it goes on and literally almost every character has the same basic motivation, but it was cool at first.) He reminded me a lot of some friends I made in high school. People who I at first put up with only because they were all I had, but they grew on me, even if it was just a little bit. It's a shame he got kind of cast off to the side and reduced to a joke character.
6) Haru
Haru is a sweet girl, but to be honest I find her pretty boring. I like her costume and codename. I didn't really care about that much about the drama around her father's company and her position as heirass. I'm glad she got free from the creep fiance, though. Also, I deeply respect her love of coffee and cafe culture. I found it pretty weird that she was still okay with her persona powers and with hanging with the phantom thieves, even though her dad dies after her first mission.
7) Yusuke
I don't like Yusuke that much. His eccentric, starving artist bit gets old very fast. And don't even get me started on the creepy stuff with Ann. But I like his character design and sword moves. It's also interesting that he attends a different school, and his backstory was admittedly good.
8) Morgana
I hate Morgana so much. The way he always creeps on Ann. The way he always bullies Ryuji. But the final straw was all that drama bullshit that started around the beach vacation/Haru arc. Also, I wish I could erase his human form my memory.
THANK YOU FOR COMING TO MY TED TALK! ♥
1) Makoto
Smart, cool and assertive. She brings some much needed maturity and logic to the party. Kind of crazy they don't make her the leader. I also love her fighting style and her motorcycle persona lol.
2) Futaba
I relate to Futaba in a lot of ways. She loves computers and technology, but she has social anxiety that makes it hard for her to speak with people or go out to places she wants to go to. I'm not a total shut-in and haven't suffered the same kind of trauma she has, but I can empathize with her. She's way smarter than me, though -- I'm no super hacker. Also, she had one of the best palaces and story. Also, Also, I like little sister characters.
3) Ann
For me, the best part of Persona 5 was the beginning of the game, when you're an outcast and you have a very small social network. It was refreshing compared to Persona 3 and 4. And I related to it a lot since I was also an outcast in high school and got into a lot of trouble. I transferred schools a lot and every time I did I felt more distant from everyone else. In my experience, the transfer kid does not become popular just because they're the new kid. I liked Ann because she saw through the bullshit and confided in me. Despite being a beautiful up and coming model, she did not hide behind a fake facade. She too was an outcast in ways, was deeply troubled, and needed help. I bonded with her early on and choose her for all of the special events/romance options throughout the course of the game.
4) Akechi
Akechi is really irritating, though it's by design. He's your rival; he captivates audiences with his intelligence, charm and strong sense of justice. He constantly turns public opinion against you, grounding the Thieves whenever things start going to their heads. As the story progresses, things continue to get very tense between you, leading up to several major twists. It's just a real shame that the game decided to spoil these twists for you by giving some very unsubtle hints/scenes leading up to them. I hate that shit. I didn't play vanilla Persona 5, but to my understanding his character is fleshed out a lot more in the Royal version. So I can understand why people would especially hate him if they only played Vanilla.
I don't have any great screenshots of Akechi. I didn't care much for him for most of my playthrough. Once he started to grow on me, I think the Share button had been disabled by that point. 🤷♂️
5) Ryuji
Ryuji was great at the start of the game. He was your first friend at your new school. You reluctantly bond with him because you're both outcasts and you've got no one else. Even though he's kind of annoying, he's a good guy that got done dirty by corrupt adults and now he wants to get back at them. (This is a recurring theme throughout the game that sadly loses steam as it goes on and literally almost every character has the same basic motivation, but it was cool at first.) He reminded me a lot of some friends I made in high school. People who I at first put up with only because they were all I had, but they grew on me, even if it was just a little bit. It's a shame he got kind of cast off to the side and reduced to a joke character.
6) Haru
Haru is a sweet girl, but to be honest I find her pretty boring. I like her costume and codename. I didn't really care about that much about the drama around her father's company and her position as heirass. I'm glad she got free from the creep fiance, though. Also, I deeply respect her love of coffee and cafe culture. I found it pretty weird that she was still okay with her persona powers and with hanging with the phantom thieves, even though her dad dies after her first mission.
7) Yusuke
I don't like Yusuke that much. His eccentric, starving artist bit gets old very fast. And don't even get me started on the creepy stuff with Ann. But I like his character design and sword moves. It's also interesting that he attends a different school, and his backstory was admittedly good.
8) Morgana
I hate Morgana so much. The way he always creeps on Ann. The way he always bullies Ryuji. But the final straw was all that drama bullshit that started around the beach vacation/Haru arc. Also, I wish I could erase his human form my memory.
THANK YOU FOR COMING TO MY TED TALK! ♥
Yes? Not sure what in my post you think would be different if I believed he was real. Akechi is trash and a psychopath.
Because of your side-eye comment. People love villainous characters all the time, people especially love the exact type of villainous rival trope that Akechi represents, but that doesn't reflect on them because it's fiction.
Sure! People like characters like Dracula, or rivals in Pokemon, or many other characters that have actual presentable personalities beyond liking to murder for the sake of it.
People who empathize with/most like characters equivalent to silence of the lambs Hannibal Lector or Goro Akechi, over the rest of the characters should probably get the side eye. It's always possible there isn't a realization that the character they "like" isn't actually Goro Akechi, but his fake personality he puts on, or just like them because they think they're hot and don't want to say that, and that's probably okay too.
Everybody says Ryuji sucks but if he was your friend he'd be the first person there to pick you up when you're down and if you got jumped at school he'd rush in without hesitation and get his ass kicked too if it meant you got hit a few less times. Dude's a loud moron but he's ready to die for his friends.
They couldn't put the results in some kind of order? Seriously why are pictures all over the place?
I can never understand why these polls include the MC when he is generally a silent character in the games. Akechi being so high on the list I understand, but still even after playing Royal I never really liked him. He is too much of a edgelord for my tastes.
Never understood the appeal of Akechi as a character, especially as a villain. Main character is barely a character, so that's weird also.
I mean he never shut up and his big mouth constantly almost got them in trouble and actually did and he never owned up to anything. Everything outside his confidant stuff is terrible.
Seems about right. I know the poll is based on vanilla P5 but Royal Akechi is great and Makato has a nuclear motorcycle and is the FIST OF JUSTICE.,
wtf is this slander.
He is by far one of the best written characters in this game outside of Kasumi and Futaba.
All the phantom thieves constantly talking about how high their Phan-site ratings are and how they are "reforming society" and "look at us! we're the Phantom thieves woooooot!" and all this other high and mighty bullshit.
Atleast Akechi had a goal that made sense. Everything he does is to get back at his father who dumped him as a child and led him to grow up having a shitty life. That "facade" goes away once you get his confidant rank high enough and he straight up tells you "i hate you".
He is a great character because he is not there to service the player's ego by being your friend, he has a goal and if you get in the way of that, he will shoot your ass. That makes him feel more like a person and less like a videogame character whose life orbits around the player like so many other games.
The base game Akechi is a "meh" character, so I can understand why people hate him, I did too. The new content at the end of Royal is what made him awesome and makes him top 3 easily.
His goals were a little... self-indulgent and unnecessary if we are being honest
His royal version was a lot better than vanilla.