The idea of a stateless society itself is silly, illogical and unreasonable.
If we were smaller and less geographically isolated it might work but this isn't life.
I don't know enough about all the different anarchist thoughts to tell you why each is less appealing.
Well, statelessness is not the same thing as being without government. That's a crucial thing you gotta be clear on.
As for the different kinds of anarchist thoughts, the two main branches are libertarian socialism and individualist anarchism. There was a really, really Quite Good Venn Diagram posted here a few months back where instead of overlapping indiv. anarchists and libsoc circles are smooching. Because that more or less encompasses the relationship. Not overlap, nor separation, but working together in solidarity pretty much from the word jump. Most of the time, anyways. Individualists are typically philosophically based on the observation that societal constructs are effectively arbitrary. Stirner and his spooks represents the source for this mode of thinking. Libertarian socialists are, unsurprisingly, a part of the Socialist tradition proper. Proudhon and his mutualism are the source for this mode of thinking, with Bakunin representing the point where the "split" between anarchism and Marxism was most directly produced.
Individualist anarchists are the sort that inspire the "lifestyle anarchism" most people are likely to be familiar with. Yunno, the kind of "anarchist" that's gone enough to think Ted Kaczynski is a comrade, but I hesitate to call them lifestyle anarchists themselves.
Libertarian socialists typically encompass anything that thinks individual liberty and democracy is important but is harder left than democratic socialism, so they don't have as many people besmirching their good names.
As I've mentioned before, if Rojava isn't big enough for you to believe that such systems are workable, I'd point you to the CNT-FAI before it was betrayed. I still think it's possible, it's just not easy. And Bookchin's proposals are on another level entirely.