You seem to be under the impression that someone can't appreciate two separate experiences and not mix them together when making a game. If that concept is so foreign to you it might just be YOUR problem.
It is
Falk has worked not only worked on Mania, but Before The Sequel, After The Sequel, Unleashed Project, AND Spark The Electric Jester just to name a few titles...
WELP.
I mean... to be fair two of those are fan games and one isn't even a Sonic game.
My point is, other than Unleashed Project, all 3 of those are rightfully loved by people who love Classic Sonic, and for obvious reasons.
10 years Later, Unleashed is still a looker. The art direction ensured the game hasn't aged a day IMO.
Absolutely. I'd give all three of my left nuts to get another game in that setting with that soundtrack and atmosphere. If there were any justice in the world the movie would be in that style, but... there isn't.
Absolutely , they are different games altogether that only shares the name and some "zones" and general story, i played them both and 360/ps3 is the superior version easily.
Same here and many people today just have piss poor memories. They can make the argument that they haven't aged well(and I disagree, they've aged better than many PS1 games), butmost people loved it back at release and those who didn't were in the minority. People were gushing over both Adventure games.
Angel Island is in it, but only as a brief tutorial area for the new mode. The rest of the stages in it are recolored and have somewhat different level designs.
at least Angel Island zone is here in some capacity, and from the OST listing looks like there is a new pinball bonus levels.
I don't think anyone is arguing that they aren't good for what they are, just that a lot of the things that make them what they are are adverse to what Classic fans like about Classic Sonic and that we should get both kinds of games without cross-pollution. You got a lot of people crying that they should stop shoehorning Classic Sonic into Modern games as well. This takes pressure off both sides to be like the other.
To be fair, though, Falk worked on the music. He mixed and mastered the soundtrack.
