Watching the trailer I knew the art would be super divisive, hahah. And just like pretty much every other time something is divisive, I'm right in the middle. It does look unique... but it also looks plastic and somewhat lifeless. The problem with plastic is that it's cheap and weightless, and it's hard not to make that mental association when something looks like plastic.
(incidentally this was my issue with a lot of the visuals during the early render era. Donkey Kong Country palm trees looked like cheap plastic toys to me).