The Monsters Are Due on Maple Street (Mafia) |OT| Suspicion can destroy
- Thread starter Dr. Monkey
- Start date
OP
OP
Final Vote Count
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start - Day End
Zippedpinhead (6 votes)
Lone_Prodigy - #289 #721
weemadarthur - #768
Aeleus - #782
Lone_Prodigy - #790
Ynnek7 - #797
saenima - #803
Vincent Alexander - #842
flatearthpandas (4 votes)
EzekelRAGE - #390
Z-Beat - #428
Fantomas - #503 #736
CaptainNuevo - #681
WhySoDevious - #683
Ynnek7 - #739 #797
Ynnek7 (4 votes)
Z-Beat - #300 #313
Kopite - #410
Fireblend - #490 #529
Fireblend - #529
Lone_Prodigy - #721 #790
Fantomas - #736
Zippedpinhead - #758
EzekelRAGE (1 votes)
Stuart444 - #71 #295
flatearthpandas - #381 #843
Vincent Alexander - #806 #842
flatearthpandas - #843
WhySoDevious (0 votes)
CaptainNuevo - #231 #265
weemadarthur - #419 #768
Fireblend (0 votes)
Fantomas - #83 #503
EzekelRAGE - #102 #390
CaptainNuevo (0 votes)
Aeleus - #290 #782
WhySoDevious - #292 #683
Lone_Prodigy (0 votes)
weemadarthur - #135 #304
saenima (0 votes)
Fireblend - #68 #490
weemadarthur (0 votes)
saenima - #301 #708
Kopite (0 votes)
CaptainNuevo - #265 #681
Post Counts:
EzekelRAGE: 128 flatearthpandas: 102 Fantomas: 72 weemadarthur: 71 saenima: 68 Fireblend: 62 WhySoDevious: 51 Aeleus: 35 Kopite: 29 Vincent Alexander: 28 Ynnek7: 27 CaptainNuevo: 26 Z-Beat: 26 Lone_Prodigy: 20 Zippedpinhead: 19 Stuart444: 16
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start - Day End
Zippedpinhead (6 votes)
weemadarthur - #768
Aeleus - #782
Lone_Prodigy - #790
Ynnek7 - #797
saenima - #803
Vincent Alexander - #842
flatearthpandas (4 votes)
EzekelRAGE - #390
Z-Beat - #428
CaptainNuevo - #681
WhySoDevious - #683
Ynnek7 (4 votes)
Kopite - #410
Fireblend - #529
Fantomas - #736
Zippedpinhead - #758
EzekelRAGE (1 votes)
flatearthpandas - #843
WhySoDevious (0 votes)
Fireblend (0 votes)
CaptainNuevo (0 votes)
Lone_Prodigy (0 votes)
saenima (0 votes)
weemadarthur (0 votes)
Kopite (0 votes)
Post Counts:
EzekelRAGE: 128 flatearthpandas: 102 Fantomas: 72 weemadarthur: 71 saenima: 68 Fireblend: 62 WhySoDevious: 51 Aeleus: 35 Kopite: 29 Vincent Alexander: 28 Ynnek7: 27 CaptainNuevo: 26 Z-Beat: 26 Lone_Prodigy: 20 Zippedpinhead: 19 Stuart444: 16
OP
OP
The power is off. Phones are down. Nothing works, not the cars, the mowers, the radios. The street is abuzz with questions, but underneath an eerie silence reigns. One man splits off from the group; he'll go to the next street, to see if the crisis has spread, but here on Maple Street, the crisis has already become something else. Something worse. The monsters have come more quickly than ever before, and within moments, a body lies stretched out in the street.
Zippedpinhead has died!
NIGHT 1 BEGINS
Night 1 ends in:
Night actions are due two hours before day start.
Zippedpinhead has died!
NIGHT 1 BEGINS
Night 1 ends in:
Night actions are due two hours before day start.
OP
OP
OP
OP
D2 Begins
OP
OP
The sight of Nelly (aka Zippedpinhead) stretched on the ground seems to have brought everyone momentarily to their senses. The angry shouts subside. For a moment, it almost seems as though peace could return to Maple Street. For a moment, at least, and then power flickers on in one house, just one. "Hey!" Martin yells. "The power's on in Sarah's house!" Heads turn as everyone stares. "Why Sarah's house?
No one has died!
DAY 2 BEGINS
Keep up with votes:
https://vote.fireblend.com/106979/
No one has died!
DAY 2 BEGINS
Keep up with votes:
https://vote.fireblend.com/106979/
I think FEP is still scum. Don't let him not moving to Zipped or Ynn eod fool you. As scum you can play those games of "These are horrible mislynches", because they know they are mislynches. Especially him not moving to Ynn. The reasons for voting Ynn were decent for D1 imo. FEP admitting that all he did yesterday is question me doesn't look good to me either. Especially since all he did was go around in circles gaining nothing.
My guess is, he is scum and thinks my chat claim is fake to cover a more powerful role. Rather than waste a NK on me, he pushes for a mislynch.
=====
Looking more at VA -
Gut says panda, but "curiousity" has him wanting to lynch me.
I did a quick search and he rarely ever mentions FEP btw. (from me searching FEP and panda)
Vote wagons are FEP-3/Ynn-2/CN-2
Votes are FEP-5/Ynn-3
For fun I searched myself for using "perhaps", I never used it.
I searched for "could". I used it a few times but not in response to a question regarding my claim.
With the biggest "could" is me saying my partner could be a she.
That's very weak reasoning. Especially with FEP being the only vote on me.
Basically parking your vote.
20 minutes b4 eod
Votes at this time is technically Zipp-5/Ynn-4/FEP-4
But to VA it may have been a 3 way tie since Saen voted zip around a minute b4 the above post.
Votes me even though he outright townreads me, so I'm not in his scum lineup.
Still hasn't said a concrete thing about FEP.
5 minutes before EOD.
2 minutes before eod
He also said earlier he would vote FEP to break a tie.
Vote: Vincent Alexander
My guess is, he is scum and thinks my chat claim is fake to cover a more powerful role. Rather than waste a NK on me, he pushes for a mislynch.
=====
Looking more at VA -
So basically he townreads me, him wanting to see me investigated makes sense.
Is certain I am not scum, but may be protecting a scum neighbor. Added this to show he still town reads me.
First time he has ever said he wanted to lynch me.
Gut says panda, but "curiousity" has him wanting to lynch me.
I did a quick search and he rarely ever mentions FEP btw. (from me searching FEP and panda)
Vote wagons are FEP-3/Ynn-2/CN-2
He was already townreading me, so I guess this is him MAYBE townreading FEP?
Says he will vote Panda, hesitantly.
Votes are FEP-5/Ynn-3
Now his "gut" is telling him to vote me? His reasoning for voting for me is fluidity in answers? I've been pretty firm in my answers imo.
For fun I searched myself for using "perhaps", I never used it.
I searched for "could". I used it a few times but not in response to a question regarding my claim.
With the biggest "could" is me saying my partner could be a she.
That's very weak reasoning. Especially with FEP being the only vote on me.
Basically parking your vote.
20 minutes b4 eod
Votes at this time is technically Zipp-5/Ynn-4/FEP-4
But to VA it may have been a 3 way tie since Saen voted zip around a minute b4 the above post.
Doesn't want to vote Zipp due to feeling the zipped train is odd. Understandable.
Again he doesn't want vote Zipped, since he isn't in his scum lineup.
Votes me even though he outright townreads me, so I'm not in his scum lineup.
Still hasn't said a concrete thing about FEP.
5 minutes before EOD.
Votes Zipp. Which contradicts what he said earlier.
2 minutes before eod
This seems like him trying to excuse his vote for Zipped. Hiding behind not wanting to cause a tie. Also basically says that Zipp was low activity anyway so no real loss.That is very weak reasoning, especially in a role madeness game. Also if he didn't want to cause a tie, why wait til the last minute to move your vote to a wagon?
He also said earlier he would vote FEP to break a tie.
Vote: Vincent Alexander
OP
OP
Yay no deaths!
I swear I thought the day was ending one hour later than it did, btw >_> not that I could've done anything anyway since I was in a meeting, but that end did take me by surprise lol.
That was a weird EoD btw. What was that last minute swerve?
I swear I thought the day was ending one hour later than it did, btw >_> not that I could've done anything anyway since I was in a meeting, but that end did take me by surprise lol.
That was a weird EoD btw. What was that last minute swerve?
Unless both are scum what does a scum weemad gain from this? She's just throwing her vote away no way she'd have known that it would lead to throwing Zipped out of a window, surely her's is the least suspect.
You don't regret it because we now have more info, or don't regret it because you're fully convinced the other 2 alternatives were town and think Zipped was the better townie to lynch? Generally I wouldn't expect town to not be regretful about a mislynch :P
I was in Wee's position in the previous game.
I can see her not being responsible for the train that formed, just as I wasn't in that game.
You, though... parked a vote on Capt for most of the day... then gave steam to the Zipped train.
Ynnek's vote is also worth a look.
Hello!
So, I mulled over whether or not to do this, but fuck it, it will help you all to see where I am coming from here.
I am Zeke's Neighbor, yeah.
This is why I was suspicious of people trying to get info from Zeke, especially regarding who his partner was, or trying to throw shade at them for not claiming.
If Zeke was Scum, then they already know I'm his partner, so what's with all this fishing? It looked highly suspect to me.
He said that if he were in my spot, he would not claim here, but I'm doing at anyways, so this is not a Zeke approved move from me.
I'll get my reads out here next.
So, I mulled over whether or not to do this, but fuck it, it will help you all to see where I am coming from here.
I am Zeke's Neighbor, yeah.
This is why I was suspicious of people trying to get info from Zeke, especially regarding who his partner was, or trying to throw shade at them for not claiming.
If Zeke was Scum, then they already know I'm his partner, so what's with all this fishing? It looked highly suspect to me.
He said that if he were in my spot, he would not claim here, but I'm doing at anyways, so this is not a Zeke approved move from me.
I'll get my reads out here next.
You are discouraging night discussion, and then encouraging it in the next line?
Statistically yeah we were probably hitting town, and Zipped had the lowest post count, but dying on D1 without an opportunity to defend yourself sucks to the nth degree. At least have some empathy for the dead.
I suspect all trains may have been town, and scum was not moving. Therefore my main suspects at this precise time are capitan todd and febe my bae.
If VA is scum, it also reflects on FEP. Since VA didnt want to vote FEP, when he had the opportunity to do so.
VA came out looking scummy eod as well with contradictions on voting zip.
And your crumb was when you used the precise mafia term in a really weird way?
You were my second choice for his partner, but you WERE second.
Reading my role and zipped's role makes me believe this is themed around cooperation and that all action-results will be needed to piece together the stuff, rather than there being any particular single item that will be unequivocally helpful.
So please crumb those results, townfolk, while I'm saying we should mass claim, we'll need to look over your posts posthumously to see what you got when you were quick.
So please crumb those results, townfolk, while I'm saying we should mass claim, we'll need to look over your posts posthumously to see what you got when you were quick.
Boy if ever there was a time for a ninja edit that woulda been it.
If only the game runners weren't mods.
Lol.
If only the game runners weren't mods.
Lol.
So the fishing is coming from scum, yeah? Where does Zeke fall into this? Is he also scum and told his scum buddies to do some noisy fishing for easy participation points? Or are you the scum, defending Zeke for town cred?
Yet your vote yesterday did not mirror that perspective, as you switched off FEP onto Ynnek.
Hopefully. Depending on how much madness is in this game, we could still end up with delayed kills or something like that.
Still, a good start to the day!
Town Leans:
Zeke
Weemadarthur
Nullish Thoughts:
Fireblend
Kopite
Z-Beat
WSD
Aeleus
CaptainNuevo
LP
Scummy Thoughts:
Flatearthpandas
Ynnek7
Vincent Alexander
Saenima
The Null Zone is large, I realize this, but I've had some back and forth thoughts about a lot of people.
Scummy section is definitely people who were asking questions of Zeke that I felt were not very good to be asking. Just felt like wanting as much info about his role and/or his partner as possible, and since I knew he was not lying about his role, they all seem pretty suspect to me.
I'll put a vote on FEPs to start things here.
Vote: flatearthpandas
Zeke
Weemadarthur
Nullish Thoughts:
Fireblend
Kopite
Z-Beat
WSD
Aeleus
CaptainNuevo
LP
Scummy Thoughts:
Flatearthpandas
Ynnek7
Vincent Alexander
Saenima
The Null Zone is large, I realize this, but I've had some back and forth thoughts about a lot of people.
Scummy section is definitely people who were asking questions of Zeke that I felt were not very good to be asking. Just felt like wanting as much info about his role and/or his partner as possible, and since I knew he was not lying about his role, they all seem pretty suspect to me.
I'll put a vote on FEPs to start things here.
Vote: flatearthpandas
Not only that but through my previous conversations with L_P I knew he'd switch back to Zipped if it picked up steam, so I knew it would become a valid train, you should definitely note that down.
------------------------
Yeah regret is probably the wrong word to use, I think my vote on Zipped was the best play I could have made at that point (I found the Ynnek vote incredibly lazy and didn't like the voters on FEP) but I admit it gave us less info than throwing out FEP and it's a shitty move to target someone who wasn't present (though I don't think Zipped had let us known he wouldn't be around), sorry about that Zipped, didn't mean to be an arse, I really like muppets: most wanted.
Also to adress the point about night discussion, town gains nothing from theory crafting reasons for no kill right now, but thoughts relating to whose scum (such as Zeke's read on Vincent) is completely different.
I'm Town reading Zeke, and I know I'm Town.
I switched off FEP onto Ynnek because I did think there was a chance he was Town there still, discussions Zeke and I were having in our chat being part of that.
I still think both Ynnek and FEP could be Scum.
I agree with weemad that the other wagons could be town and scum just chilled while one or two of them gleefully jumped between wagons (I mean, the whole Zipped wagon started from scratch).
Aeleus, Ynnek, saenima, and Vincent? Yeah I can see it.
Aeleus, Ynnek, saenima, and Vincent? Yeah I can see it.
No one dying is kinda fitting considering the theme.
So you're saying we should mass claim?
So you're saying we should mass claim?
Yep. Not happy with the Zipped vote. If you're scum, it's wise to come after me because you and Panda still have my attention:
Here is the language you use that gave me pause.
All the indifferent shrugging:
Or in response to a line of reasoning why your Neighbor might or might not come out, you state the below, which isn't a strong stance at all:
And if you are town, posts like the below don't help the town at all:
And finally, when stating that you and Panda could be townies just going at it while scum sit back and watch:
It's the language you're using. The word choices. The early shrugs. "...could be scum..." with no concrete, "by the by, I'm not scum." It makes me go hrmm.
I still think it was a good move for town to ask Zeke those questions. I absolutely wanted to know who his neighbor is because if one of you die, and your role isn't neighbor, that makes the other look purty darn suspicious.
Lol
__________
With that claim, I can now also say that I spent a good chunk of day one believing WhySoDevious was zeke's partner, based on opening post of mr rogers peeping in windows and saying howdy neighbor.
But every time I questioned WSD, he gave off "i know nothing about chats especially zeke's" vibes, which left me wondering if he was being disingenuous. So I got closer and closer to opening linking them in my posts, only that didn't irritate zeke at all, so I thought, hey maybe I got the wrong end of that stick.
Basically it left me NOT voting in the realm of zeke, fanto [my 2nd pick of neighborino] and wsd because I seemed off base and wasn't reasoning properly.
Ima have to reread wsd but i'm not really going for "ignorance means not scum", because the wiki exists, and other people have gone and researched things. But without thinking i have a clue where his puzzle piece fits in the jigsaw, i'll try to get a better handle on him.
Fanto thinks anyone fishing for Zeke's partner is scum.
If Zeke is scum, Fanto thinks his scum buddies wouldn't fish because they already know Fanto is the neighbour.
But Fanto thinks Zeke is town.
So he finds the fishing highly suspect.
Despite that, I think that scum Zeke could just tell his scum buddies to fish for participation points. Or, Fanto is the scum (since he suspected the fishing and then switched off FEP). He then claims and comes to the aid of town Zeke, because double neighbour town is a thing.
It is if that's what Dr. Monkey decided to do with her game, so it's pointless to speculate on whether Neighbors have to be a certain way.
The number of players at the beginning.
you are reading the shrugging wrong. Even in one of the posts you quoted I stated its a playful shrug.
I don't know my neighbor's alignment. So yes it's possible they could be scum. I can't definitively say whether or not they are town.
Uh, yea it is possible. As I had my vote on FEP, obviously I didnt think so.
If we are talking about aggressive posts, FEP wins that hands down. And as I stated, I knew what path he was going down and knew it made no sense in my situation.
So your like 0/4 currently on your rebuttal.
What? When did Panda have your attention AT ALL.
And you townread me ALOT.
And if FEP was on your radar, why didn tyou vote him earlier?
Thank you both!
At least everyone participated then. I hate missing votes.
Do you want to comment on your neighbor's identity at this time?