Someone should just make a spoiler thread at this point. All this spoiler tagging is dizzying. The game has clearly leaked so....
Unless he is lying so we will be surprised when she actually does die.
Music to my ears. I hope we have a decent amount of new enemies in this game. I really enjoy the gameplay in the first one. The characters and story are definitely what elevate it to masterpiece status, but they sure weren't the main reason why I replayed it more time than I can remember. Only good gameplay does that.Channel down. Couple of other comments he made.
Game will make you cry multiple times. There will still be a lot of infected fights, for people worried it would be mainly humans.
Yeah, I think the jury is still out onEllie being killed at the end. I would be incredibly disappointed if the game just copy-pasted the scenario from the end of the first game, just with roles reversed (Abby vs Ellie, Doctor vs. Joel). I think making the story end with Abby sparing Ellie and breaking the cycle would be a much stronger ending, unless they're sequel-baiting for The Last of Us Part III where Dinah is finally the one who breaks the cycle or something like that.
Frankly, I find the cycle of violence angle to be wholly unconvincing in the world of TLOU. The first game literally spent its entirety showcasing that in its world, violence was how people survived and that the world could be cruel and uncaring at times with how it forced people to confront the darkest parts of humanity to attain that goal. It positioned Ellie as the child forced to grow up in terrible circumstances and explored the real emotional toll it took on her and her life, but it also almost always put her in the position of being right and that Joel and Ellie generally did everything they did to survive the harsh world where people wanted them dead all the time for this reason or that. It also made distinct moral judgments in how a character like David and his band were absolutely awful and represented humanity too far gone more or less. Now, Joel does end up deciding to fight back against the Fireflies at the end, but they were always shown to be morally ambiguous and holier than thou types at best. That leads to the surgeon trying to defend his work, and even if Joel didn't need to kill him outright, he clearly intended to fight back against an extremely unstable Joel. Joel's act was meant to be ambiguous and selfish, even looked upon as wrong to a degree in choosing to save Ellie over losing her (though there was always a chance that her death would have meant absolutely nothing as the audio tapes implied past operations had done nothing). But the surgeon wasn't exactly just a victim in this whole incident either.
Flash forward to TLOU Part II, and apparently the conclusion is supposed to be based around the theme of "Violence leads to violence and the cycle is bad." Except the entire first game spent its run convincing the player and making the point that, in order to survive in the world of TLOU, violence was necessary and it was about retaining your humanity as best you could in the face of the violence. Couple that with the whole Ludonarrative dissonance of spending an entire game fighting your way through enemies and killing them, only for the game to slap you on the wrist and say that cycles of violence are bad completely guts the point the game is trying to make. Unless you can do a pacifist run or non-lethal combat with say Abby, it's not offering an alternative or giving the player gameplay that works in connection with the story. It's just a nihilistic, humanity is prone to violence and will always suffer this same cycle. Which, as an analysis of humanity in an apocalypse is... fine? But not compelling, nor does it explore anything that every single other piece of post-apocalyptic media doesn't hammer home endlessly. TLOU's strength was the core characters and their relationship, not really its world which was pretty standard, and TLOU Part II's leaked plot details seem to focus on that already much less interesting world as its overall arc, which just sounds incredibly disappointing.
If any of those spoilers are true, I really dislike them.
The idea of Abby being the surgeon's daughter then killing Joel and potentially Ellie is so contrived. Why him? Why not a person from David's camp, for example?He's seen talking to a woman about evacuating the children. Or maybe someone related to Marlene more directly? The idea of a "circle of violence" doesn't make much sense, considering the state of the world. It's killed or be killed, and it's not like Ellie and Joel went out of their way to kill innocent people. If ND wanted to justify Abby's narrative as a purely revenge story, sure. But don't try to pass it as some sort of brainy metacommentary about the state of the world, either the real one or the one in the game.
As far as character switch halfway through the game is concerned, it is lol. The level list posted a few pages back confirms it. Kinda didn't expect this but it's welcomed.
Wait, what? Who?
Wouldn't it make more sense for the ending to consist ofOhhh-kay, that's a lot to take in. Some of it I find potentially really interesting, some parts I'm more wary of.
The reveal of the mysterious woman being the surgeon's daughter from Part 1 actually made me laugh out loud, so, yeah. I'm sure it'll be implemented better than it sounds, though. Curious to how she found Joel and Ellie, but if she's linked to the Fireflies, I presume it would be somewhat commonly known that Tommy and Joel were brothers, Tommy left the Fireflies, so if you find Tommy, you might find Joel, too.
Judging by the scene with Ellie and Dinah talking, Joel's dead, along with Jesse. I was hoping Joel would stay around for longer, but at least from one of the leaked clips Joel and Ellie did at least discuss the events of the ending of the first game, which was something I was worried wouldn't happen. I know other users loathe Joel, but between the writing and Baker's performance, Joel was always such a fascinating character for me, especially with his choice at the end of the first game. I'll genuinely miss him, replaying TLoU got me through some tough times and helped me process losing loved ones, so Joel, Ellie and all they've been through and lost have always meant a lot to me.
From The Godfather Part II references, I assumed Abby would be Ellie's mother, Anna, so I was caught there, lol. Having a new character (Abby) kill a main pre-existing character (Joel), and then playing as them in turn is something that is unique to video games as a medium, which I find really interesting. Depending on the player's opinion of Joel, one might be really happy to play as Abby, others might be considerably less so. An Abby vs. Ellie final boss fight could be interesting, too, depending on the outcome -- I'd be considerably unimpressed with Ellie dying, as discussed further below.
I'm curious how the villains fit into all of this, because I thought Abby's mission would be going after them.
Fantastic post, I really, really hope your suggestion is how the game ultimately ends, I'd be genuinely quite content with that. Bittersweet, but satisfying.
100% agree, Abby sparing Ellie at the end would make for a much stronger ending -- otherwise the commentary on the cycle of violence falls incredibly flat for me, because the cycle just continues, no one learned anything, it's all pointless. I think it would genuinely put me off ever replaying the first game, because it what was it all for? Abby or Ellie choosing to make a different choice at least shows growth, even if it's bittersweet. I don't know if there would be a TLoU3, but Ellie finding herself in Joel's position as a parent would be fitting considering the direction of the first game.
From one of the clips I saw, it does seem like Dinah does wants the cycle to stop and to take care of her child, but because she's not a long-term playable character, it doesn't have that same impact for me personally as Abby or Ellie choosing to break the cycle.
Both posts have really great points.
I'm also a bit ehhhhh in excessively delving into the cycle of violence as a theme in a post-apocalyptic world. On the one hand, I can see that it's important to retain humanity/compassion/empathy when society collapses and seeing if it's possible to rebuild a new society from the ashes, but on the other hand... post-apocalyptic world with fungal zombies. I'm not judging the characters on their moral choices the same way as I would in the world of The Godfather, for example.
I'd forgotten about that game, you're right, lol.
more specifically, i want the part about taking control of her after she kills joel to be true
From the dude who uploaded that new video with the infected on the car
"The game is coming out much sooner then people think. The quality of the game is close to perfection. can't even describe how good it is"
"They are much smarter! Atleast 10 times more. The first game's AI is a complete joke comparing to the second one "
I've said for weeks TLOU 2 still release a June 26th and Ghosts will come out late summer/fall.
Expect announcement from Sony/ND by May 1st.
Having a new character (Abby) kill a main pre-existing character (Joel), and then playing as them in turn is something that is unique to video games as a medium
Not really.Question for those who watched the story spoiler stuff.
Are the leaked story parts suggesting something that is going to trigger the alt-right crowd? There already are some people complaining about some rumored stuff. I personally don't care about that kind of stuff myself, but I am wondering if I am going to get more of the anti-SJW Last of Us videos cropping up in my Youtube feeds...I hate Youtube's algorithms. Vague answers appreciated.
Not any worth watching. It's just "walk and talk" gameplay. Which isn't bad, but it's still spoiling story points for no real benefit, as you don't get to see the mechanics in action or anything.Aw.
Any spoiler free gameplay though?
I don't feel like browsing back a dozen+ pages of SPOILER: SPOILER SPOILER! OMG SPOILER!
Apparently she is the daughter of one of the surgeons that Joel killed at the end of the previous game:
Not any worth watching. It's just "walk and talk" gameplay. Which isn't bad, but it's still spoiling story points for no real benefit, as you don't get to see the mechanics in action or anything.
Leaker said it is coming out way sooner than people expect.
Amazon had a leak date of June 26th.
Playstation Canada moved GoT release to an August 1st placeholder.
It's happening.
Game will go gold in the next 3 weeks, and Sony will have 5 to 6 weeks to get copies pressed and distributed by the 26th of June.
Wouldn't it make more sense for the ending to consist ofEllie sparing Abby's life? Abby did Ellie wrong by killing Joel (obviously Abby had valid reasons for seeking revenge.) Ellie could continue the cycle by killing Abby or choose to end it. Abby defeating Ellie is just a continuation of her initial revenge scheme. If that makes any sense.
Not really. NieR: Automata does a similar thing in Route C though I wouldn't call the character in question "pre-existing" considering it's their debut game.
Sorry, didn't explain myself well! Other games have indeed done similar before, but I always find it to be such an interesting concept, because it's something you can't do in any other medium as effectively due to player interactivity. NieR: Automata is also a little different in that A2 was mercy killing 2B, so it didn't hurt as much for me personally, whereas Abby killing Joel out of revenge and then having to play as her would be a gut punch.
Same, that's all I care aboutIt's going to eat me alive notknowing for sure if Ellie dies or not.
For me she's the core of the series.
Oh it will, people can't help themselves, they need everyone to know they have more information and will wink wink at how much they know.Hopefully the review thread here when it comes won't get plagued by spoilers.
How would he be the only one that uploaded that then? Like only him got those videos from somewhere else and then they were scrubbed from the internet?Shit, so are we sure this YouTube leaker posting is the originator of these leaks? If so, we would trust his word that
Or could he have ripped the videos from elsewhere/someone else leaked it earlier in the day and he just reuploaded?Ellie does not die, and the game is 25+ hours to beat
I've lost track of if the leaks are coming from different sources or not
Why do you say that? Yes, ND is a big/important studio for Sony and TLOU is an important IP, but it's not like the game will make or break them. Sony has had hit after hit for the past few years, TLOU 2 is just one more big game in a string of big games
Good lord. Wish i hadn't read these spoilers.I won't buy the game. I can't even imagine how angry I'd be if I played this and then found out I was forced to play as this character who brutally killed joel. Absolutely fucking repulsive. I get the intent. Still find it to be a shameless and repugnant idea