Doggy Style Mafia |OT| Si no se divierten, los golpeo con mi guitarra!
- Thread starter Reki
- Start date
Flavor tells me Stan is town (Town Creative Director should only be able to command town), while game mechanics are telling me Stan is scum (I dont think town needs a tracker backup and Stan might as well have scum tracking powers that fit to Genos three people).
well clearly the flavor of this game is completely straightforward and trustworthy.
(Reki how the helld you get that to imbed witout the overlay?)
I'd still go for one of Stan or Kopite today personally, those are the flips I'm most interested in seeing still as there are a lot of question marks for me surrounding their role claims, it just feels like at least one of them is a fake claim.
I'm not sure how you can put Kopite and Aeleus in the same category when Aeleus' power has been pretty much confirmed, while Kopite is going on good faith for his role name. Unless Kopite visited you and that made you learn his role name? Realistically, why would he visit a bus driver after you claimed? It should have been either N1 or N2, otherwise that's somewhat odd, and he already said he visited Aeleus N2 (I believe). Would Kopite have used his PR on coolest N1? Probably not.
Ok, but we're talking about a Lightning Rod here. A Lightning Rod is really not useful for Scum, it is a pro-Town night action in almost all cases.
/shrugs
Just keeping options open. Not like I said they are a serious candidate for today or anything lol.
I've only used my power once, on Muffin N2 which was then redirected to Aeleus.
You can't just game solve solely through mass claiming and then trying to weed out claims just because they can't really be proven. That's what Town did for Maple Street and then got screwed when it was too late to do anything. Can I ask why you aren't interested in voting Muffin instead? My role has actual value for town.
This...what value does your role have on its own? Without Muffin (tracker) or Stan (supposed backup tracker), does anyone else really need a strengthener besides Stu?
Do you think Muffin is a scum tracker?
I'm not Town lol.
Muffin is a Tracker and we have confirmation from Chugg's PM that Scum have a Ninja, so therefore I consider Muffin to be the reason why they have a Ninja.
And again, your role is what you say it is, we don't know what it does for sure other than tell your target your flavor name, which is not of much value!
Lmao, the role that is equally used for both scum/town is confirmed town. Meanwhile, you think Aeleus could still be scum after pulling off a N2 lightning rod when Town had a confirmed tracker.
Ok so while we're on flavour I did some digging, in the spoiler text there'll be some fairly large pictures showing the dogs/cats of 31 minutos but I'll give a TLDL
The big takeaways from this for me are
A) There are only 3 cats in the show (probably) this means if there's 4 scum, one isn't a cat.
B) As said before my flavour mentions me having 3 fantastic friends, turns out one of them is a cat 'bigote' so just because he's my friend and mentioned in my role PM doesn't mean Kopite is a good dog.
From this I'll lessen the amount of good dog points I'm giving Kopite but he's still a better dog than Malus or Stan IMO
The big takeaways from this for me are
A) There are only 3 cats in the show (probably) this means if there's 4 scum, one isn't a cat.
B) As said before my flavour mentions me having 3 fantastic friends, turns out one of them is a cat 'bigote' so just because he's my friend and mentioned in my role PM doesn't mean Kopite is a good dog.
From this I'll lessen the amount of good dog points I'm giving Kopite but he's still a better dog than Malus or Stan IMO
I don't remember that, but I did get red checked lol which lead to the claim. Would've been a travesty if I didn't get lunched then
The big takeaway for me is
A) One of the dogs is named James Bond.
That is all lol.
Hey your claim made me panic enough to get lunched the next day :P
The way I see it, it is almost impossible for Aeleus to be scum. The night they claimed to have used their power the doggyguard was killed, so a night kill was indeed issued. If they were a Scum lightning rod, that would have been a huge risk to take unless they knew exactly that the doggyguard would use his command, because why else would they issue a kill at all. If the lightning rod was a fake claim, they would have to be sure that no other role can confirm who was really their target. But we know from Kopite, that he targeted somebody else but Aeleus revealed his flavor name. Additionally we have Muffin who got no movement from Verelios, who claimed he had to use his love every night. So unless all those players are in on it, there is no way Aeleus is Scum.
Confirmed town because Scum tried to off him and instead Geno got killed. If Geno was targeted instead, Muffin would have died.
Since I know I'm town and I know my power, obviously unless we had some third party doing the killing, Muffin is basically confirmed as far as I'm concerned.
Who was Polter then? I don't see a Reddie there.Ok so while we're on flavour I did some digging, in the spoiler text there'll be some fairly large pictures showing the dogs/cats of 31 minutos but I'll give a TLDL
The big takeaways from this for me are
A) There are only 3 cats in the show (probably) this means if there's 4 scum, one isn't a cat.
B) As said before my flavour mentions me having 3 fantastic friends, turns out one of them is a cat 'bigote' so just because he's my friend and mentioned in my role PM doesn't mean Kopite is a good dog.
From this I'll lessen the amount of good dog points I'm giving Kopite but he's still a better dog than Malus or Stan IMO
Going by pictures he's cabecita, must be another name for reddie)
Yeah but if they kill you (the last scum/recruited cult) I can recruit and if they kill me you can kill so we get majority tomorrow either way
First off we go back to polter's big moment on Day 1
This is more interesting as it seems that both he and the sample PM share the role Extra though I'm not quite sure how it effects this post, setting up a breadcrumb?
Regardless many players took this as a way to jump into the game:
Oreo took the comment at face value
Rac/malus, CS/Stu, Fanto, Kopite and Stan (though admittedly he was in a weird mood) initially ignore the post but Vere is the first one to attack it.
Chuggernaut ignore the comment but after a push from Kawl and Fanto (the latter I assume was just sheeping) he joins in.
Stan attacks Fran's defense of Polter but doesn't really comment much on polter themselves
Oreo defends polter
(not quoting but CS/Stu continues to ignore situation)
Here's something fun: Polter replies to the push and quotes vere, chuggs and Fran but ignores Kawl and Fanto both of who posted before chuggs. This is probably so that it's clear to us that Polter and Chuggs aren't pals.
Oreo continues to defend Polter (worth noting he's not the only one, LP defends him and Nin votes one of his voters for coasting)
Chuggs backs off as Meatwad becomes prime target (but still gives a way back to the wagon), later continues to look into meatwad and uses the excuse of a pressure vote to switch off polter onto me :(
Hey Blargonaut you made that really good read list on D1, you should make another.
That seems to be the end of it by where I'm at (post 382) but for full disclosure I know I eventually come in and defend polter (I think even town read him for some stuff :/)
Conclusions:
CS/Stu + Stan + Rac/Malus ignorance of the topic is not a good look (though not particularly suspect for CS)
I think Vere's push on Polter is legit and why chuggs bussed him, I also feel that Polter wouldn't have enough guts to quote two scum mates in his reply. Therefore I think both he and Blarg are town.
Oreo being the only alive defender of polter is interesting because I'm not sure if his scum mates would have defended him given how quickly day 1 lunches can get set in stone, I feel that it's more likely scum ignored it but not enough for him not to be a suspect.
This is more interesting as it seems that both he and the sample PM share the role Extra though I'm not quite sure how it effects this post, setting up a breadcrumb?
Regardless many players took this as a way to jump into the game:
Oreo took the comment at face value
Rac/malus, CS/Stu, Fanto, Kopite and Stan (though admittedly he was in a weird mood) initially ignore the post but Vere is the first one to attack it.
Chuggernaut ignore the comment but after a push from Kawl and Fanto (the latter I assume was just sheeping) he joins in.
Stan attacks Fran's defense of Polter but doesn't really comment much on polter themselves
Oreo defends polter
(not quoting but CS/Stu continues to ignore situation)
Here's something fun: Polter replies to the push and quotes vere, chuggs and Fran but ignores Kawl and Fanto both of who posted before chuggs. This is probably so that it's clear to us that Polter and Chuggs aren't pals.
Oreo continues to defend Polter (worth noting he's not the only one, LP defends him and Nin votes one of his voters for coasting)
Chuggs backs off as Meatwad becomes prime target (but still gives a way back to the wagon), later continues to look into meatwad and uses the excuse of a pressure vote to switch off polter onto me :(
Hey Blargonaut you made that really good read list on D1, you should make another.
That seems to be the end of it by where I'm at (post 382) but for full disclosure I know I eventually come in and defend polter (I think even town read him for some stuff :/)
Conclusions:
CS/Stu + Stan + Rac/Malus ignorance of the topic is not a good look (though not particularly suspect for CS)
I think Vere's push on Polter is legit and why chuggs bussed him, I also feel that Polter wouldn't have enough guts to quote two scum mates in his reply. Therefore I think both he and Blarg are town.
Oreo being the only alive defender of polter is interesting because I'm not sure if his scum mates would have defended him given how quickly day 1 lunches can get set in stone, I feel that it's more likely scum ignored it but not enough for him not to be a suspect.
Sorry, I'm an idiot, for some reason I thought you meant Malus, not Muffin. Yes I agree on Muffin being pretty much confirmed town
Message to future scum: I have breadcrumbed in every game I've played par 1, I'm sure you can figure my role out if you look closely enough
(this was a weak example but I was in a rush to get into the game)
==== DAY 4 VOTES ====
Day Start
Blargonaut (4 votes)
Fanto - #1,754 #1,838
Stantastic - #1,756
oreomunsta - #1,816 #1,817
oreomunsta - #1,817 (Double) #1,818
oreomunsta - #1,818 (Triple)
malus (2 votes)
Aeleus - #1,835
Kopite - #1,898
Kopite (2 votes)
Fanto - #1,885
Stuart444 - #1,911
Stuart444 (1 votes)
malus - #1,892
Stantastic (1 votes)
Fanto - #1,838 #1,885
Muffin - #1,849
Not voting: Blargonaut, Verelios
Post Counts:
Verelios: 32 Fanto: 31 Blargonaut: 24 Muffin: 23 Kopite: 20 oreomunsta: 19 Stuart444: 18 Aeleus: 13 malus: 12 Stantastic: 9
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
Blargonaut (4 votes)
Stantastic - #1,756
oreomunsta - #1,818 (Triple)
malus (2 votes)
Aeleus - #1,835
Kopite - #1,898
Kopite (2 votes)
Fanto - #1,885
Stuart444 - #1,911
Stuart444 (1 votes)
malus - #1,892
Stantastic (1 votes)
Muffin - #1,849
Not voting: Blargonaut, Verelios
Post Counts:
Verelios: 32 Fanto: 31 Blargonaut: 24 Muffin: 23 Kopite: 20 oreomunsta: 19 Stuart444: 18 Aeleus: 13 malus: 12 Stantastic: 9
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
I think he was definitely setting up a vanilla claim, also managed to completely avoid the question by taking it at the simplest perspective possible.
Shame that chuggs was offed so soon, really looked like he was getting into it towards the end. Died before his time.
And I still love this post.
That's Day 1 done
Conclusion:
I don't think Fran was killed for any stance he took, though he did scum read oreo. Seems more likely they just wanted to kill a strong active town who probably had no protection.
Lots of people generally say in spec "they could solve it if they only read from the beginning" this confirms that I at least, cannot.
Conclusion:
I don't think Fran was killed for any stance he took, though he did scum read oreo. Seems more likely they just wanted to kill a strong active town who probably had no protection.
Lots of people generally say in spec "they could solve it if they only read from the beginning" this confirms that I at least, cannot.
All I'm seeing is that I'm a confirmed doggo lolOk so while we're on flavour I did some digging, in the spoiler text there'll be some fairly large pictures showing the dogs/cats of 31 minutos but I'll give a TLDL
The big takeaways from this for me are
A) There are only 3 cats in the show (probably) this means if there's 4 scum, one isn't a cat.
B) As said before my flavour mentions me having 3 fantastic friends, turns out one of them is a cat 'bigote' so just because he's my friend and mentioned in my role PM doesn't mean Kopite is a good dog.
From this I'll lessen the amount of good dog points I'm giving Kopite but he's still a better dog than Malus or Stan IMO
OP
OP
==== DAY 4 VOTES ====
Day Start
Blargonaut (4 votes)
Fanto - #1,754 #1,838
Stantastic - #1,756
oreomunsta - #1,816 #1,817
oreomunsta - #1,817 (Double) #1,818
oreomunsta - #1,818 (Triple)
malus (2 votes)
Aeleus - #1,835
Kopite - #1,898
Kopite (2 votes)
Fanto - #1,885
Stuart444 - #1,911
Stuart444 (1 votes)
malus - #1,892
Stantastic (1 votes)
Fanto - #1,838 #1,885
Muffin - #1,849
Not voting: Blargonaut, Verelios
Post Counts:
Verelios: 32 Fanto: 31 Blargonaut: 24 Muffin: 23 Kopite: 21 oreomunsta: 19 Stuart444: 18 Aeleus: 17 malus: 12 Stantastic: 9
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
Blargonaut (4 votes)
Stantastic - #1,756
oreomunsta - #1,818 (Triple)
malus (2 votes)
Aeleus - #1,835
Kopite - #1,898
Kopite (2 votes)
Fanto - #1,885
Stuart444 - #1,911
Stuart444 (1 votes)
malus - #1,892
Stantastic (1 votes)
Muffin - #1,849
Not voting: Blargonaut, Verelios
Post Counts:
Verelios: 32 Fanto: 31 Blargonaut: 24 Muffin: 23 Kopite: 21 oreomunsta: 19 Stuart444: 18 Aeleus: 17 malus: 12 Stantastic: 9
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
But, you brought up Muffin here before talking to Stu.
You had them mixed up since then?
Shit yeah I did, the M's got me bamboozled. To be clear I think Muffin is pretty much-confirmed town, and malus is who I'd be voting out today as I think they'd be the role we can afford to lose the most.
Not sure how I can contribute to end of day right now :<
Looks like we're still lynching blarg due to my vote bloat. I'm still alright with pursuing that, despite the potential lovers blowback if the claims end up being true
Looks like we're still lynching blarg due to my vote bloat. I'm still alright with pursuing that, despite the potential lovers blowback if the claims end up being true
I don't think we can vote Blarg now that he's coupled up with Vere. I don't know if you can unvote, but even if you don't I'm going to assume there should be enough votes on another train
That's if you believe the lovers claims, I suppose. And nah, I can't move my votes, I don't think. My role description says that once my saved votes are spent, they cannot be refunded, so I take that to mean they're set
Pretty sure you can still move your vote, you will just lose your two extra ones.
What do you think of my read on vere (it's the big post you probably reasonably skimmed)
I'm Stan or Kopite.
Looks like we're voting for Stan then?
Vote: Stantastic
It's a good inspection (and boy do I still feel the egg on my face for defending Polt lol), but your conclusion kinda delves into WIFOMy territory where you feel that you can absolve Vere and therefore Blarg just because of an instance of Polt picking who to quote