-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Game of Thrones Mafia - We're All Bastards Here
- Thread starter Natiko
- Start date
Being confirmed doesn't mean that you are smarter than the rest of us.
Nin is obviously scum and you don't care!
It's because you didn't read my posts properly! And all I was so willing to lynch Blarg and you just ignored it. I was so onboard killing Blarg Day 1 too Monkey, and you deflected off him. How can you keep insisting I didn't do enough to lynch Blarg, when I've done so much more than you
Yes I didn't vote Blarg the day I fell asleep, i fell asleep the next day phase too btw. But wouldn't scum just vote GoG? The easy vote and you save your scum buddy? If I was scum why didn't I just do that instead of not voting? It sure as hell wasn't because I expected you to come at me with these questions later.
No.
But maybe they are. Monkey is 100% mafia though. Just look at this EoD
I did not call you scum. All I did was question you. That's my job. All I wanted was for you to engage and explain that exact thing - your thought process. Not "I fell asleep." That doesn't give me reads. It doesn't give anyone reads, even if it's true.
As if the entire mafia team would actually band together in this situation. Just agreeing with Faddy and taking a swingy "confirmed town" from Faddy would be worth the bus for them imo even if Monkey was scum. I don't think she is though, and I think et is the best vote today
Flavor coming...I promise.
Dr. Monkey has died!
==== DAY 7 VOTES ==== Day Start
dr. monkey (6 votes)
nin - #4709 #4849
kopite - #4867
faddy - #4868
nin - #4870 #4946
giant panda - #4930
nin - #4960
fantomas - #4992
extreme tactician - #4996
extreme tactician (4 votes)
faddy - #4759 #4868
nin - #4850 #4870
fantomas - #4926 #4992
meatwad - #4932
flatearthpandas - #4933
dr. monkey - #4942
nin - #4946 #4960
include - #4963
kopite - #4801 #4802
meatwad (0 votes)
flatearthpandas - #4731 #4756
giant panda - #4754 #4930
kopite - #4802 #4867
nin (0 votes)
include - #4790 #4963
fantomas - #4836 #4926
dr. monkey - #4887 #4939
dr. monkey - #4939 #4942
Post Counts: dr. monkey: 65 faddy: 51 flatearthpandas: 48 nin: 38 fantomas: 31 kopite: 22 meatwad: 17 giant panda: 16 include: 12 extreme tactician: 11 pirate bae: 5 natiko: 1[/quote]
Dr. Monkey has died!
==== DAY 7 VOTES ==== Day Start
dr. monkey (6 votes)
kopite - #4867
faddy - #4868
giant panda - #4930
nin - #4960
fantomas - #4992
extreme tactician - #4996
extreme tactician (4 votes)
meatwad - #4932
flatearthpandas - #4933
dr. monkey - #4942
include - #4963
meatwad (0 votes)
nin (0 votes)
Post Counts: dr. monkey: 65 faddy: 51 flatearthpandas: 48 nin: 38 fantomas: 31 kopite: 22 meatwad: 17 giant panda: 16 include: 12 extreme tactician: 11 pirate bae: 5 natiko: 1[/quote]
OP
OP
Robb
Robb stood with one is his new and unexpected allies, Aeron Greyjoy.
"How do you do it? How do you remain so resolute even as everything around us goes wrong?" Robb questioned. The death of Jon still weighed heavily on him.
"Simple, my faith. I know the Drowned God watches over me, over the Iron Islands. No matter what might happen, we will stand strong."
Robb's brow furrowed. He just couldn't find that level of conviction within him anymore.
"Do not fret so much Stark. Remember, what is dead may never die.."
"but rises up harder and stronger. Yeah, I've heard the mantra plenty. I just.. I feel lost currently. Don't you ever waiver in your beliefs Aeron?" Robb questioned.
"No, never."
"Oh, well I mea-"
"No. I have never been wrong."
"Well, okay Ae-"
"Did you hear me young Stark? I am right."
Robb nodded, not really coming up with any way to continue the discussion with Aeron. He certainly had no way of questioning Aeron's belief further, let alone disproving it. As he turned and walked away the sound of waves crashing masked the cries of help from Aeron.
Faddy has died
Day 8 Begins
—
Remaining Players:
Trigger
Fantomas
Kopite
Extreme Tactician
Meatwad
flatearthpandas
Giant Panda
Include
nin
Majority is 5
—
VOTE TOOL:
https://vote.fireblend.com/game-of-thrones-mafia-were-all-bastards-here.61616/
Day Ends In:
aka Thursday, September 13th at 7:00 PM EDT (UTC -04:00)
Robb stood with one is his new and unexpected allies, Aeron Greyjoy.
"How do you do it? How do you remain so resolute even as everything around us goes wrong?" Robb questioned. The death of Jon still weighed heavily on him.
"Simple, my faith. I know the Drowned God watches over me, over the Iron Islands. No matter what might happen, we will stand strong."
Robb's brow furrowed. He just couldn't find that level of conviction within him anymore.
"Do not fret so much Stark. Remember, what is dead may never die.."
"but rises up harder and stronger. Yeah, I've heard the mantra plenty. I just.. I feel lost currently. Don't you ever waiver in your beliefs Aeron?" Robb questioned.
"No, never."
"Oh, well I mea-"
"No. I have never been wrong."
"Well, okay Ae-"
"Did you hear me young Stark? I am right."
Robb nodded, not really coming up with any way to continue the discussion with Aeron. He certainly had no way of questioning Aeron's belief further, let alone disproving it. As he turned and walked away the sound of waves crashing masked the cries of help from Aeron.
Faddy has died
—
Day 8 Begins
—
Remaining Players:
Trigger
Fantomas
Kopite
Extreme Tactician
Meatwad
flatearthpandas
Giant Panda
Include
nin
Majority is 5
—
VOTE TOOL:
https://vote.fireblend.com/game-of-thrones-mafia-were-all-bastards-here.61616/
Day Ends In:
aka Thursday, September 13th at 7:00 PM EDT (UTC -04:00)
Last edited:
Fuck, Faddy's down. RIP.
I want to get a revised read list going right now.
Town
Giant Panda
Kopite
Probably Town
Include
Trigger
Extreme Tactician
Scum
Meatwad
Flatearthpandas
Nin (probably recruited)
This is how I'm feeling right now after the Monkey flip.
I want to get a revised read list going right now.
Town
Giant Panda
Kopite
Probably Town
Include
Trigger
Extreme Tactician
Scum
Meatwad
Flatearthpandas
Nin (probably recruited)
This is how I'm feeling right now after the Monkey flip.
I think Nin could have been Monkey's bus target, but the Girlofgotham neutral flip threw a wrench in their plan and Blarg ended up getting lynched D6 because of it, and with Monkey being against the Blarg lynch D5 she couldn't claim it D6 as her own, so she wanted to continue her bus on Nin to win some town cred by handing us a scum member on a silver platter.
I would recommend Meatwad and FEPs lynches before Nin though, because I think Nin might have been recruited so he wouldn't have a power role to use whereas the other two could.
Even after yesterdays flip you think that I am scum ? Disgusting to say the least but damn did I have a lot of fun yesterday.
I will take a look at those who voted Extreme Tactician, even Fantomas ( who was in the end the tie breaker) could have been a town cred move from
I will take a look at those who voted Extreme Tactician, even Fantomas ( who was in the end the tie breaker) could have been a town cred move from
Ahem.
So my first reaction is that Monkey's death was pure luck.
Why? If Fantomas hadn't voted for her at the last moment it would have been a tie. My own vote counted despite being past the end of day, but Monkey already had the majority. So that's how Monkey died.
The thing is, I agreed with her thoughts. And I still do. Nobody tried to have a discussion with her, and simply made an echo chamber when conversing with her. So yay, she's dead.
So my first reaction is that Monkey's death was pure luck.
Why? If Fantomas hadn't voted for her at the last moment it would have been a tie. My own vote counted despite being past the end of day, but Monkey already had the majority. So that's how Monkey died.
The thing is, I agreed with her thoughts. And I still do. Nobody tried to have a discussion with her, and simply made an echo chamber when conversing with her. So yay, she's dead.
It's possible still, though like I said, I think you are the least likely and if you are you were probably recruited N1 or N2 as a Vanilla Town player.
Meatwad is where I would want to vote today, though FEPs would be the ballsier one.
Even after yesterdays flip you think that I am scum ? Disgusting to say the least but damn did I have a lot of fun yesterday.
I will take a look at those who voted Extreme Tactician, even Fantomas ( who was in the end the tie breaker) could have been a town cred move from scum.
Giant Panda
FEP
Kopite
You are on my town circle list
I will take a look at those who voted Extreme Tactician, even Fantomas ( who was in the end the tie breaker) could have been a town cred move from scum.
Giant Panda
FEP
Kopite
You are on my town circle list
Fair enough, what about the extreme Tactician votes. Even you said yourself that those who jumped on the wagon were fishy.
Exciting day end.
Kits/ET were faddy's main targets for most of the game. It's great that monkey flipped scum but we still need that et flip or some reason to believe absolutely he's town. His flip directly influences reads on a lot of people from d1 as well as d7, most importantly fantomas, include, and nin. If ET is scum, we can lay off shading every single person not on monkey.
I am about 95% sure trigger is scum as well.
Kits/ET were faddy's main targets for most of the game. It's great that monkey flipped scum but we still need that et flip or some reason to believe absolutely he's town. His flip directly influences reads on a lot of people from d1 as well as d7, most importantly fantomas, include, and nin. If ET is scum, we can lay off shading every single person not on monkey.
I am about 95% sure trigger is scum as well.
True, it's more like a hunch or a message coming from my gut. The way he went after players just gave me this reassuring feeling.
Dont sorry this can change in the course of the game.
Ríp Faddy
You were my true mvp.
A message to scum
Dont you dare mess with nin
As you can se this can lead to your death
Rest in peace Faddy, you done good.
Footage of Faddy leading the lynch on Dr. Monkey:
To me it looks like Dr. Monkey might have still had that extra kill. I'm guessing there were 4 scum left. Had we lynched town, 4/10 players left would be scum. If scum then kills 2 more town that night, 4/8 in the morning, scum wins. So in that case Mafia would have been willing to go all out on the lynch. Had Nin not flipped before Include voted, ET would have died, and that tactic would have worked. This only assumes that ET is town. The most difficult situation is if ET is also scum.
Still, I am working under the assumption that there are probably 3 scum left and they were probably voting ET.
Town
Kopite
Fantomas
Lean Town
Nin
Extreme Tactician
Lean Scum
Include
Scum
FEPs
Meatwad
Unknown
Trigger
Vote: Meatwad
Footage of Faddy leading the lynch on Dr. Monkey:
To me it looks like they might have. You, Meatwad, and Include.
To me it looks like Dr. Monkey might have still had that extra kill. I'm guessing there were 4 scum left. Had we lynched town, 4/10 players left would be scum. If scum then kills 2 more town that night, 4/8 in the morning, scum wins. So in that case Mafia would have been willing to go all out on the lynch. Had Nin not flipped before Include voted, ET would have died, and that tactic would have worked. This only assumes that ET is town. The most difficult situation is if ET is also scum.
Still, I am working under the assumption that there are probably 3 scum left and they were probably voting ET.
Town
Kopite
Fantomas
Lean Town
Nin
Extreme Tactician
Lean Scum
Include
Scum
FEPs
Meatwad
Unknown
Trigger
Vote: Meatwad
They are. Here's my thought process in the final minutes of D7:
I voted for ET as the compromise vote because I really didn't want to believe that Dr. Monkey was scum, even though the signs were pointing there.
Next up GP votes on Monkey.
Then we get a flood of scummy votes on ET from Meatwad, FEPs, Dr. Monkey, and Nin. None of whom I was particularly feeling good about as town anymore, hence why I was saying I didn't like the votes on ET anymore.
Then GP and Faddy make these posts:
I then hit reply on my post with my vote for Dr. Monkey with 1 minute left on the clock. And jesus fuck am I glad that I did because she was scum as hell. That claim was fake and I sniffed it out as fake right away. Fuck. I shouldn't have been so doubtful about her scumminess because it really did all add up eventually.
Before we get too crazy on meatwad, someone remind me who spent a bunch of time building the case against him
Or heck if Trigger is town they might have been willing to gamble that he wouldn't show up and they could tie a vote 4 to 4, and then kill someone that night.
Apollo posted a scum read on him on D5, I picked it up on D6, Monkey did some stuff on D7 but she wasn't side-eyeing him nearly as much as the rest of us, she was trying to put others in a scummier light than him.
And yeah, I think most if not the whole remaining scum team were on the ET vote. Dr. Monkey was clearly a highly valued asset of their's, not only for her play but her power role as well. They did not want to lose her, they weren't going to bus her, not with the ET vote there, and honestly I think ET is town because of that alone now.
On the contrary, if monkey was so powerful, i think they would have bussed et to protect her if push came to shove.
My main read on et is kits' outspokenness. I never felt that strongly though because I'd seen it as scum as well.
And it would be extremely bad play if scum is stacked. Not to say it's impossible but i'd want the flip still. That's potential a game over strategy when monkey gets lynched whereas having anyone on that lynch potentially allows scum to sit back while town goes into a frenzy of mislynches
Dont be fooled though.
Only Because the heart is at its right place does not mean it cannot be a scum heart
Rest in peace Faddy, you done good.
Footage of Faddy leading the lynch on Dr. Monkey:
To me it looks like they might have. You, Meatwad, and Include.
To me it looks like Dr. Monkey might have still had that extra kill. I'm guessing there were 4 scum left. Had we lynched town, 4/10 players left would be scum. If scum then kills 2 more town that night, 4/8 in the morning, scum wins. So in that case Mafia would have been willing to go all out on the lynch. Had Nin not flipped before Include voted, ET would have died, and that tactic would have worked. This only assumes that ET is town. The most difficult situation is if ET is also scum.
Still, I am working under the assumption that there are probably 3 scum left and they were probably voting ET.
Town
Kopite
Fantomas
Lean Town
Nin
Extreme Tactician
Lean Scum
Include
Scum
FEPs
Meatwad
Unknown
Trigger
Vote: Meatwad
Wasting no time rushing into a loss I see. Why don't you lynch ET instead, He's scummier than me
I do remember Apollo and monkey, and i don't know i agree with the but. But I overslept and had to skim a bunch before end of day and still have to go through it more carefully. You have your attack on him handy? I don't remember that one
Yeah, you asked me for it yesterday because I said I was going to do it. It's mostly about his D5 play.
There were some follow ups after too if you want to follow from that post on for a bit.
I'm heading away now for a couple hours, but I'll be checking in on my phone.