Dororo 1
After Amazon finally decided their international audience would probably appreciate some subtitles, I sat down to watch the premier. I know there was a lot of talk lately about notable animators leaving the project, making many speculate as to the quality of the end product after some early PVs got people talking. I'm glad that much of the anxiety over Dororo seems to have quelled somewhat after this episode. While a bit thin in terms of notable content and feeling somewhat lopsided in terms of backstory to introductory arc, this still felt like a quality look at what Dororo is planning to be, and what it might be capable of over the course of its run. From the lovingly detailed and classically styled background art to the tasteful and impactful use of gore to the quality animation and editing during the final action sequence, this doesn't really betray its roots as an classical manga. With how much they tried to pack into this first episode as well as its abrupt ending, I can't say I'm entirely sold yet but this has proved more interesting than I was giving it credit for initially. Here's hoping they manage to fine-tune the pacing a bit in the next episode.
Baki 1-13
So, out of the three shows I wanted to watch before voting, this seemed like the easiest one to binge watch over the course of a day. Baki is actually a continuation of the manga's adaptation, focusing on an arc set after Baki won a major underground martial arts tournament where five "Super Max" prisoners from around the world all break out of prison and head for Japan to challenge the new champion. With a premise that unbelievably stupid, how could I not be excited to check this out? And did it live up to my expectations?
First and foremost, I want to talk about what's good here. Baki is a show that revels in levels of hilarious testosterone the macho movies of the '80s could only dream of reaching. Both the mediums of manga and anime have allowed creator Keisuke Itagaki to push beyond the normal limits of the human form, creating characters with ridiculous proportions to match their personalities. And despite everyone looking like some 'roid-ed up junkie, everyone has distinctive enough designs that even without knowing the extended cast like I would assume you were supposed to coming off of the manga or the previous adaptation. Baki also knows when to throw something bizarrely unexpected your way. I imagine a lot of the reason this arc exists is because after the tournament arc, Itagaki was looking for a way to cut loose from the more traditional sports setup and implement some real surprises with fighters that didn't play by the rules and were aiming for the kill. The show manages to leverage that concept rather well with some truly dumbfounding moments as the fighters constantly try to one up one another as they beat the life out of one another. But this is also where Baki kind of fell apart for me when the freshness wore off.
This "Prisoners" arc might be what the manga needed at the time to spice things up a bit, but watching it without any other real exposure to Baki, I can't help but see the mechanisms behind-the-scenes manipulating things too often. To compare the show with JoJo for a bit, the fights in both series are equally chess-like, with opponents pulling secret techniques or other unexpected advantages out and the others having to react in turn. The difference between them is that JoJo often knows when a fight between said opponents has reached its climax and deals with them before returning and then introducing a new one. In this season of Baki, only two of the five prisoners ends up getting any focus, one of them for a whopping five to six episode: almost half the length of this "season." And frankly, he was not interesting enough to warrant that focus. Every fight he had over the course of that time had roughly the same structure: meets opponent(s), initial fight, changes things up, opponent changes things up, then he manages to pull out a win until eventually he doesn't. And this goes on for almost half of the episodes I watched. And many of these things, even if they were surprising, had clockwork timing that meant I didn't have any kind of suspense when I could guess when Itagaki was going to do something. It doesn't help that for what basically amounts to a death tournament arc, Baki is very toothless. Even with the horrific levels of violence people inflict on one another here, the death count of anyone who's not simply window dressing is unbelievably low. I imagine it's because all these people involved are supposed to be characters you already know and care about, but these prisoners don't feel as lethal as they should because the lethal violence they live by doesn't actually cause much lasting harm.
And lastly, I need to address the show's visuals, because they are all over the place. There's moments when Baki looks great. Whether it's a fabulously framed animation or a close-up of a character's key frame, sometimes the show looks excellent. But in that same scene, it can look horribly cheap, not to mention I've seen fight scenes that bounce back and forth between pulled-back 3D CG models and close-up 2D models and it looks really weird. The CG isn't terrible, but it's so jarring when it cuts back and forth. I also have to admit, I kind of hate the show's color palette. Everything has this washed out muddy look, like the screen is often saturated in too many grays and browns. Combined with a lot of fights taking place at night in areas with limited lighting, and the show can sometimes feel like its obfuscating the action more than necessary, another thing JoJo avoids with its modular color palette.
In the end, I did enjoy Baki despite its shortcomings, but I feel it would not be best suited to binge watching. Spend too much time watching at once and you'll end up seeing behind the curtain a bit too much, not to mention that a show like this that should be all about the action doesn't really have the quality often enough to keep it enjoyable throughout. I'll still watch the rest because when the show clicks and is at its most absurd, it can be very entertaining. But YMMV as its a bumpy and uneven road through this arc, which is a shame given how amazing the premise is.