I KNEW IT.
I'm really impressed with how the reveal has been handled. It's the best kind of twist, really, in that it opens up a whole new raft of potential storylines and interactions going forwards. As well as opening up interesting new ways to interact with antagonists (how will Jasper react when she finds out that Steven is, in her eyes, Pink Diamond? Will Bismuth's disgust at the Gem elites survive the knowledge that Pink led the rebellion? How do you communicate this to the other Diamonds, and how does each react?), the ramifications for the Crystal Gems are huge too;
- It's a proper existential crisis for Garnet- one of the biggest things that enabled her to embrace who she is was Rose's support. The knowledge that Rose was never who she said she was, plus the fact that she was one of the figureheads who was underpinning the whole corrupt system that Garnet was escaping, is going to be huge- we can see as much in the trailer for the next episodes.
- Pearl's pain and torment about Rose's death just seems all the more acute in the aftermath of this. It's not just a lost love (although it's still that as well)- Pearl lost the person that she was made for, and for who she sacrificed everything. There have been allusions that Pearl was not just a true believer in the liberation of Earth, and was more on-board for Rose's sake than anything (Space Race comes to mind)- to go through all of that, to give up your entire life, and for the person that you did it all for to dip out for a guy she'd just met is awful for her. Her attitude in Rose's Scabbard makes even more sense now- she was literally the only person that Rose trusted with her greatest secret, after all. This also raises HUGE questions about the power imbalance in the relationship between Rose and Pearl, and how much Rose actually saw her as an equal. We're nowhere near done with this, I'd guess.
- Peridot's rebelled against her Diamond, and tried to move past her Homeworld conditioning, but we still regularly see that it's a huge part of how she sees things- how on Earth is she going to react when she finds out that Steven is descended from Pink Diamond?
- Lapis has a profound and crippling terror of the Diamonds, and real trauma that's directly connected to the actions of both sides of the war. If she learns that Rose was Pink Diamond, that could either open up the door to her beginning to actually deal with her feelings or to become flat-out antagonistic again.
It's a development to rival Jailbreak or Earthlings- the next few years of stories are going to come directly out of this one.
I didn't dislike it and I'm glad we finally got the answer. Buuuuuuut, I expected it to be more of a slow-burn than a single episode nuke.
They've been building up to it for a while, between Zircon's observation that only a Diamond could have orchestrated Pink's shattering, to Pearl's obvious inability to talk about the circumstances of it, to the vision of Pink on the Jungle Moon, to the years of hinting that Rose and Steven have abilities that it would make absolutely no sense for a standard Quartz to have. The reveal came over the course of an episode, but it was seeded for an incredibly long time.
The slow burn will come as everyone else reacts to it, and the ongoing ramifications of Steven revealing it play out- as I said, there's enough episodes that will come directly from this episode to fuel multiple seasons, in the same way that Jailbreak fuelled seasons 2 and 3, and Earthlings set up 4 and most of 5.