Everyday, a religion is declared in the day start post, along with a riddle. Whoever accomplishes the objective of the riddle will receive a prize via PM. Only people of the declared religion are eligible.
Game of Thrones Mafia - We're All Bastards Here
- Thread starter Natiko
- Start date
Everyday, a religion is declared in the day start post, along with a riddle. Whoever accomplishes the objective of the riddle will receive a prize via PM. Only people of the declared religion are eligible.
I love activity. The game needs it. But we don't have time right now to recap you. You can't be "filled in" quickly enough into a worthwhile unbiased opinion. We literally don't have time. Just no vote, shut the fuck up, read the thread tomorrow, and participate then because as much as I'd love you lynched immediately it's not happening so the rest of us have decisions.
You can miss me with this shit dawg. I'll play the game however the hell I want.
Oh and dude, seeing how people interact with a fresh person who asks for assistance can be a data point in and of itself. You can bet your ass I'll be voting today
Meatwad is about as decent of a target as you can get with who's left.
There are numerous things that have been brought up throughout the course of the thread and he's been a consistent scum read on a lot of people's lists. He's been flying under the radar for a long time, only really shows up when he needs to, and doesn't offer many of his own opinions in the thread. I don't know if any of those things immediately point to scum, but his votes have been worthy of suspicion as well and it all adds up to a good target if you ask me, and apparently GP and Kopite agree as well.
There are numerous things that have been brought up throughout the course of the thread and he's been a consistent scum read on a lot of people's lists. He's been flying under the radar for a long time, only really shows up when he needs to, and doesn't offer many of his own opinions in the thread. I don't know if any of those things immediately point to scum, but his votes have been worthy of suspicion as well and it all adds up to a good target if you ask me, and apparently GP and Kopite agree as well.
Word, thanks. Apologies.
Of course do what you want. But surely you understand, we have one hour left now. Do you think you can legitimately help us now? Or are you in our way? You aren't getting lynched. If you're town, do what's best for us. We are conflicted and we don't have time.
My case on Meatwad is what has largely already been said by others. Meatwad made a comment about neutral survivor (Blarg's claim) not really being scum. Meatwad claimed to have scum read Blarg and GoG and just happened to have (tried to) voted GoG on day 5.
In fact the only real reference to Blarg that Meatwad made on Day 5 is defending himself saying that he wasn't actually defending Blarg:
Here's his only substantial scum hunting posts on Day 5. He narrowed down on FEPs and I, no mention of scum Blarg:
The fact that he tried to vote twice within a few minutes added to the appearance of a sense of urgency to save his scum buddy.
Then two poor choices of words.
Normally I wouldn't be bothered by this but I am considering Meatwad's other slip-up about scum being closer to winning. Notice how he refers to town as if he's not a part of it here. He didn't say "Melon was a liar that deceived US into lynching town."
Then of course, yesterday Meatwad had another late vote when the other option is a confirmed scum.
TLDR
Voted for the competing lynch over our two scum lynches, defended Blarg (one of our scum lycnhes), then claimed to be actually scum reading Blarg when there is no evidence of him doing so. Has had some question post wording.
In fact the only real reference to Blarg that Meatwad made on Day 5 is defending himself saying that he wasn't actually defending Blarg:
Here's his only substantial scum hunting posts on Day 5. He narrowed down on FEPs and I, no mention of scum Blarg:
The fact that he tried to vote twice within a few minutes added to the appearance of a sense of urgency to save his scum buddy.
Then two poor choices of words.
Didn't think it out enough or scum slip?
Normally I wouldn't be bothered by this but I am considering Meatwad's other slip-up about scum being closer to winning. Notice how he refers to town as if he's not a part of it here. He didn't say "Melon was a liar that deceived US into lynching town."
Then of course, yesterday Meatwad had another late vote when the other option is a confirmed scum.
TLDR
Voted for the competing lynch over our two scum lynches, defended Blarg (one of our scum lycnhes), then claimed to be actually scum reading Blarg when there is no evidence of him doing so. Has had some question post wording.
Honestly a little bit yea. FEP is annoying but I town read that reaction more than yours.
But mostly it's the we three town schtick and the fact that I don't find your claim alignment indicative at all
Has anyone told me I'm wrong though? If someone else can confirm that this is the common read of the game right now, would you feel better?
Fantomas's weird ability is concerning, but he had a vote on Blarg when Blarg was in danger, and then was the decisive vote for Monkey.
No its not about being misleading. It's about trying to be helpful and all that.
Fantomas's weird ability is concerning, but he had a vote on Blarg when Blarg was in danger, and then was the decisive vote for Monkey.
Sorry about the double post, I got a gateway error the first time I tried posting it, so I thought I had to post it again.
Could very easily be bussing. Especially if scum were in a solid position at the time and felt they were likely to lose some members one way or another sooner rather than later.
Although back to back is a little more convincing.
Like, I welcome the suspicion for sure, but I was honestly just trying to catch you up. I felt like FEPs wasn't going to answer you because he's been waiting to have someone other than a ghost to fight against in your spot all day, so I went for it.
Back to back to back technically, I was on Blarg D5 after me and Faddy called him on his bullshit and then D6 I finished off the turbo on him.
Nah double dipping on blarg doesn't get you any extra credit.
GP I wish I had time to give that it's due right now but I sat around jerking off in discord about toilets for hours waiting for this read, stayed up all night, but I don't have time for a proper response so you're going to get a quick one.
Blarg GOG null for me. But were scum. GOG was the one caught by town.
After same as Fantomas, but different take. Format copied for damn sure, different takes. Your take though, no blarg. But it's a vote analysis. He's focusing on Exo. Whatever, he's trying. Completely ignoring the actual scum though, which is a point.
Honestly, I think urgency legit fucks up votes. In Dark Souls, I talked so much shit (as town) when I was on the block that I threatened and could have actuated a tie to keep myself alive... but fucked up my tags and ended up getting lynched on the technicality. At the same time, two chances. But I just don't give people credit for multiple fuckup gamits. Not in this game.
The slip. Honestly, run with it. We vs. they is not really terminology, it's actual psychology. I have no problem here and he wilded out when I called him out.
Last bit, more semantics.... but I'm not bothered so much by that. I like semantics. I can definitely vouch that things slide but no need for me to go to defense here.
Blarg GOG null for me. But were scum. GOG was the one caught by town.
After same as Fantomas, but different take. Format copied for damn sure, different takes. Your take though, no blarg. But it's a vote analysis. He's focusing on Exo. Whatever, he's trying. Completely ignoring the actual scum though, which is a point.
Honestly, I think urgency legit fucks up votes. In Dark Souls, I talked so much shit (as town) when I was on the block that I threatened and could have actuated a tie to keep myself alive... but fucked up my tags and ended up getting lynched on the technicality. At the same time, two chances. But I just don't give people credit for multiple fuckup gamits. Not in this game.
The slip. Honestly, run with it. We vs. they is not really terminology, it's actual psychology. I have no problem here and he wilded out when I called him out.
Last bit, more semantics.... but I'm not bothered so much by that. I like semantics. I can definitely vouch that things slide but no need for me to go to defense here.
Fair enough, I do hope you read through the thread at some point though.
Kawl, you really hoping to get Fan lynched with 35 minutes left? I'd say read d7 and then I'd want to talk about it.
Fan, you suddenly want to lynch this spot?
Fan, you suddenly want to lynch this spot?
Not today, his entrance to the thread is weird though. I wanted to get someone caught up, but I guess I'm scum now.
No, I'm saying don't waste time with late minute distractions. Kawl shouldn't be in the game and the best he can do as town is distract us at sub in 2 hours before lynch without having read the thread. His reads are useful later, he gave first impressions one way or the other, we can deal with others now. But now actual players need to actual lynch.
Fuck, confirmed piled on bullshit lynch. Are none of you around to listen?
It is a good strat in that a counter is pretty hard to organize. Town are wrong, let's convince scum to vote scum....
It is a good strat in that a counter is pretty hard to organize. Town are wrong, let's convince scum to vote scum....
Uh, I think I'll vote for Meatwad. Even though Kopite does have an interesting post, Include can't defend herself. It would be unfair to kill her. Meatwad has come and go, and has no defense for not posting a lot about what's going on.
VOTE: Meatwad
VOTE: Meatwad
If needed, I will extend the day an additional fifteen minutes or so to compensate for the Nintendo Direct traffic.
==== DAY 8 VOTES ==== Day Start
meatwad (4 votes)
giant panda - #5016
fantomas - #5053 #5123
kopite - #5208 fantomas - #5218
Extreme Tactician
kawl (1 votes)
flatearthpandas - #5205
extreme tactician (2 votes)
meatwad - #5061
fantomas - #5123 #5124
Flatearthpandas
include (1 votes)
kopite - #5138 #5208
include - #5168
trigger (0 votes)
flatearthpandas - #5038 #5199
Fantomas (2 vote)
Kawl
Nin
Post Counts: flatearthpandas: 73 fantomas: 71 nin: 41 kopite: 28 kawl: 18 extreme tactician: 16 meatwad: 13 giant panda: 11 natiko: 3 include: 2 pirate bae: 1
—
VOTE TOOL:
https://vote.fireblend.com/game-of-thrones-mafia-were-all-bastards-here.61616/
Day Ends In:
aka Thursday, September 13th at 7:00 PM EDT (UTC -04:00)[/QUOTE]
meatwad (4 votes)
giant panda - #5016
kopite - #5208 fantomas - #5218
Extreme Tactician
kawl (1 votes)
flatearthpandas - #5205
extreme tactician (2 votes)
meatwad - #5061
Flatearthpandas
include (1 votes)
include - #5168
trigger (0 votes)
Fantomas (2 vote)
Kawl
Nin
Post Counts: flatearthpandas: 73 fantomas: 71 nin: 41 kopite: 28 kawl: 18 extreme tactician: 16 meatwad: 13 giant panda: 11 natiko: 3 include: 2 pirate bae: 1
—
VOTE TOOL:
https://vote.fireblend.com/game-of-thrones-mafia-were-all-bastards-here.61616/
Day Ends In:
aka Thursday, September 13th at 7:00 PM EDT (UTC -04:00)[/QUOTE]
