DAY 1
...then why not vote for him if you think he's really part of a cult?
has anyone gotten a good read on Sparks' play? even seeing him as both town and scum i...don't see the difference? i really can't tell what's his normal weird and what isn't.
Terrabyte20xx shitposting aside Sparks has this...chaotic nature to him that never really stops. He'll be doing this same thing on Day 4 so that's why i'm asking if other people have noticed a pattern or anything in regards to his past plays. he's a blindspot for me
Well, I was going to say that this could be a brave bus or an obvious pocket, but I guess it doesn't really matter anymore.
I have to agree about faddy, but the fact that he misread something is NAI in my opinion. People misread shit all the time.
Sorian v Faddy is interesting, feels like town v town if I had to go with my gut
Fanto has contributed a whole lot of nothing so far, same as a few others. Wish I could see more of terra tho, the posts he did make were good and I'm
Did some complaining about Fanto, but no pressure or questioning.
It could also be mafia vs town
Or mafia vs mafia
Just fyi
But what does it feel like to you?
But decides to question nin, which makes me think they're not on the same team.
Hot take: Bae actually rolled Town this time.
Unvote
Trying to score townie points with me?
I see you
That's not a hot take.
It's lazy.
You did not even stay with that vote long enough to make it even remotely dangerous.
Nin says it all here. Lazy voting. No pressure = no reason to change your votes. Idky Fanto changed so easily. Nothing was learned.
What about Sawneeks? Anyone have thoughts on her?
I felt like she was one of the first ones to make some of the first "serious" posts during the jokey phase, however, her focusing on Sparks seemed kind of weak because we all know how Sparks is by this point so making reads on him a topic of discussion early just felt a bit easy I guess.
IIRC Sneeks was a Town read for Fanto at this time.
weemadarthur
hi where u at
A wee prod.
I don't see how Aeleus post above is townie. Saying how you meta read people is NAI.
I disagree with this meaning a town read on Aeleus but it sounds more like you're getting an anti w/w read for Aeleus and Sparks than an actual town lean for Ael.
Because you're whole town read on Aeleus disproves your initial point and that's even without me saying that giving meta read insight is NAI because it's so easy for scum and town to do. Saying a scum player wouldn't give insight because it helps people read the person in question is silly.
This could be an insane bus or Sneeks really trying to cement an argument against Aeleus.
After reading back, that Aeleus post really sparked a lot of conversation. It seems like a couple confirmed scum responded to it. So far, not convinced Aeleus is scum.
Hot take, Faddy and Maol are teammates. Zeke does the same thing Faddy did but when Faddy did it, not a peep, when Zeke does it, Maol is in all of a sudden.
Cute, Faddy lies and Maol corrects him.
+1 to my hot take.
For some reason this makes me think Maol isn't scum. Especially with the Faddy flip, I can see Sorian trying to get arguments settled in against them early on to prepare for late(r) game.
Pinging me during my workday will give you results. I'll treat you like the micromanagers at work and tell you ALL about my putting myself through self training on Pivot Tables and how I've had to google where MS stuck the VB section so I can get my stuff done.
Or, you could not. I've never needed to be pressured to show up at my convenience.
Wee's response to the ping. Bae never responds to them. Even after mentioning later on that she doesn't like their posts so far, there's still no pressure there. Nor was there a reason why wee was pinged in the first place. Could be nothing, but something I noticed.
I suppose my Would Not Vote Today list is looking like this so far:
Sawneeks
Monkey
Faddy
Chugg
I don't even know who I'd be fine with voting for yet. I don't feel like I have many thoughts on a lot of the players when I stare at the player list here. A majority of the players have 10 or less posts, so I guess it's not too strange for me to have most people in a Null Zone.
So far I guess I want to hear more from
Aeleus for sure after they've been a major topic of conversation lately, would like to get their thoughts on these discussions.
I also think I want to talk to
Verelios a bit because I feel like we haven't spoken much yet. How's it going, Vere? Do you have your side-eye on anyone yet?
Stuart444 has definitely been too quiet for my tastes and that makes me nervous, but I understand he's out and about right now IRL from what I remember so maybe not as much attention is being given to the game as he would normally give it.
Otherwise yeah, I'd like to get some of the sub-10 post players a chance to chime in some more so I can get a feel for where they're at today.
Oh, there it is. Was there an explanation as to why Sneeks was apart of that list?
I'll drop my hot take before I have to bounce again:
Faddy is town.
Sawneeks is scum.
nin is neutral
vote: Sawneeks
This is a fun take.
I wish to vote out one of the following players:
Monkey
For encouraging this whole dumb back n forth indiscriminately while also distancing herself from having any actual opinion, only denial of opinion.
Theworthyedge
He says I'm right to vote him and I trust him implicitly
Kyanrute
People who love books are very towny but one of them must be scum, i bet it's kyaa.
Pirate Bae
Who are we kidding, she never doesn't roll scum. Why wait around any phases before handling it.
Wee has been going after Bae since the beginning. But the other way around has been a thing, too. Has OMGUS ever been discussed between them? Because if not, this could be a shallow back and forth/bus. I guess I'll learn when I read D2 and D3.
wee's take is so bad I wonder if she's a neutral lyncher. The other three reads aren't reads and the one on me is built from inaccuracies. Seems forced.
I have to agree with Monkey here. It's the reason why I highlighted Monkey above because reading D1 I noticed Monkey was putting in some great work.
Does this nin vote have any actual weight to it?
Also, VOTE: Maolfunction for wagonomics since Faddy is already tied for the lead.
Also, Fanto I see your shit, you are coasting and trying to lead conversation just like you did last time.
Sorian going back and forth between Mao and Faddy. In the meantime, he's making it seem like he doesn't believe nin is scum by questioning the train.
He calls out Fanto.
nevermind then.
you gonna respond to monkey's reply or nah?
Ppl are so mean this game. Waaaah.
I'm literally in bed and gotta get huge calculations done at work tomorrow. I do still hate hecht rhythm due to my work schedule. Some days I'm not much use, what can I say. I only hope like 4 ppl die in N1 to try to control the excess posting as well as the overabundance of players. Etc.
I found this interesting. Why would wee need to respond to that post? There were no questions asked and it's not like wee was being quoted/replied to.
What is this weird nin wagon? These votes are shit.
Questions the nin wagon again.
If you had read the thread (which you clearly haven't), you would know exactly what wagons I prefer. As said above, all you did was go in expecting to read nin badly, looked at maybe half a page of his iso and then came back and pretended like you did some work. Your one reason is that "his posts are filler/fluff" literally enough of a meme line that nin is known for getting mad at people calling his posts fluffy. You pointed to his play style to justify your vote that you aren't even attached to and you didn't use your half baked vote to even pressure someone new or add to the discussion, you just threw it on the vote leader. No one else on that vote is doing much better with reasons.
Shit
Vote
Yep, Sorian was scum. This has his scum playstyle written all over it. lol
Townish Reads:
Chugg
Monkey
Sawneeks
Faddy
Sparks
Bae
Aeleus
Mao
Sneeks still up there.
I don't like wee's posts so far and I agree with whoever said that your posts come across as poking around to see what sticks but never really offering anything yourself.
I think maol is fine, nin is null, still want to see more from terra. Sparks' claim is pretty stupid to pull this early in the game but it got people talking so whatever. I give it a town lean since I doubt scum would bring attention to themselves this early on unless they were fishing for a counterclaim.
There's that post about wee I was referring to earliers. Also, that post about Mao makes still think they are not on the same team together.
what?
Nin I would consider voting for today, I haven't really liked his stuff
that is absolutely not a good reason to vote for Sparks or Sorian. If Sparks' claim is true, that's a huge boon for town and we should absolutely keep him around for as long as possible until it's proven he's scum or someone counterclaims (which I wouldn't expect until later)
Sorian is a high content, quality contributor to town (when town, he's tricky when scum) and should lynch him only if and when he's proven to be scum
I agree with Kalor and TWE though
Hmm. Then why was nin a null read before? Bae went out of her way to say she didn't like wee's posts in the previous post, but never mentioned not liking nin's posts before. Just said he was null…
I need to look into Kalor. Since VA flipped Town, I'm not sure what my initial read is on Kalor.
I know they're not answering questions about it anymore but are we just going to ignore Ael's really sus breadcrumb?
Again scum aiming for an Aeleus argument… Stands out.
i get it's D1 but, really? by this post malus' only ''pressure'' on me was an out-of-nowhere vote that he refused to explain for several hours.
I don't think Malus is scum at this point.
Stole my idea. :x
Let's make it more
Vote: TheWorthyEdge
haven't seen anything from him to suggest he should be kept around.
Given the proximity, something to think about.
Interesting Vere pointed this out. I wish he would have been questioned about it at this time. Not even Sneeks asked him why he said that… Really stuck out to me.
Verelios as well. Time is a funny thing so I'm not going to try and line it all up. Have you (Chuggs) or Vere ever really played with Terra before?
A Chuggs and Vere callout.
Not really a fan of the top 3 votes right now, I could see myself going for Terra but I'd rather see Saw and Ynnek up there or something instead of Faddy and TWE.
The progression of Saw going from WOULD NOT VOTE TODAY to this is amazing.
Woops, was gonna get to Sparks and then completely forgot.
Funky Dude Sparks malus still has a garbage random vote on me that he finally explained hours after the fact. I don't like that monkey praised that as some good push but she's being really pointed in her opinions and that's usually a Town monkey. if malus ends up as scum i'd look at her again though. i think nin is on me too? he said i wasn't 'leading discussion enough' or something and that's a very weak vote as well. Fanto is sheeping monkey I think? Also a meh vote but the outburst earlier of 'let's just kill top posters' didn't feel scummy. Faddy feels like a self preservation vote.
Hot take: Malus isn't scum. Nin isn't scum. Fanto is… Idk.
How did you come to the conclusion that of 25 people who are not you, TWE is the ONE who's not worth keeping? Why him? Why not anyone else? I want some actual reason.
Why not Kalor
Bae
Ynnek
Terra
malus
feps
Mao
nin
wee
literally anyone
I want any sort of a stance or opinion from you. That's all I've been looking for in all these posts. "not worth keeping" is not a stand; it's the literal absence of one and it's something we do in the mafia but it's usually accompanied by the taking of any other positions or forwarding of opinions as well, but there's no sign of you weighing anything all game so far. Just questions, a couple observations, and this.
This is GOOD mafia. Monkey might be my favorite Mafia player now.
i'm more frustrated than anything. i'm catching up and seeing you accuse me of 'being here too much' while nin is saying i'm 'not here enough'. i really thought i was clear with my feelings but i wasnt and now i finally go for something and suddenly that's not ok. i was just super looking forward to jumping back into mafia..
Really throwing nin's name around a lot.
Quick question for anyone who's here. If you were given a gun tonight, who'd you use it on?
Lol
What is the case for Zeke btw? Just that he was being weird or
Hmm… Wanting to know why Zeke was a train. Noted.
if i die look at malus. if malus is scum look at monkey.
Feelin like Malus isn't scum