ket GotY 2019 list
1) Control
It's rare for me to be excited for a game's DLC so the fact that Control's DLC is one of my most anticipated 2020 games is a testament to how great this game is. I loved nearly everything in Control.
The story was great, the combat felt fantastic, The Oldest House was one of the best settings I've ever played in, and I really clicked with this game's style and tone.
2) RE2 Remake
I don't think it's hyperbolic to say that the RE2 remake will end up saving the Resident Evil series. It took Capcom over a decade to find a way to make a 3rd person over-the-shoulder (OTS) Resident Evil work as a survival horror game and with RE2 remake they finally did it.
While RE7 was praised as a return to form, there were some fans who didnt like the FPS gameplay. Now, the series has two equally viable ways (FPS & OTS) to make survival horror RE games and that's great!
3) Hitman 2
Hitman 2 is one of the best games ever made due to its creative, emergent gameplay. It's a goofy, muderous playground that's filled to the brim with possibilities. If there's a stupid, over-the top way to ice a target that you've thought off then it's usually possible to pull that off in this game. The story isn't memorable but the level design and comedic open-ended gameplay makes Hitman 2 a game I'll return to for years to come.
4) Metro Exodus
I played the first two Metro games and came away kinda underwhelmed by both of them. They were fine games but I didn't love them.
However, I feel in love with Metro Exodus. It's one of the most immersive games I've ever played due to how it gamifies its upkeep mechanics (from charging our flashlight to changing your gasmask filters). I surprisingly ended up liking the story as well. It's not perfect but it's close.
5) A Plague Tale: Innocence
When A Plague Tale was first revealed at E3 2018, it came across as a budget The Last of Us clone with rough voice acting and overwrought dialogue. So, when it came out back in May, I was surprised at how well it was reviewing and the gameplay looked like an intriguing mix of stealth & puzzles.
I bought the game while it was on sale and I was genuinely impressed at how well so much of this game worked. The story, the characters, and the worldbuilding were all so well done and the gameplay was more engaging than I was expecting.
6) Star Wars JFO
Much like A Plague Tale, Jedi Fallen Order didn't leave me with a great first impression. Setting yet another piece of Star Wars media between Episode 3 & Episode 4 came across as played out and the protagonist, Cal Kestis, seemed bland.
Thankfully, the actual game (technical issues aside) ended up impressing me considerably. The Metroidvania design and engaging Sekiro-style combat made playing this game a fun, adventurous experience. Despite my reservations with the setting, the story and characters have proved to be compelling so far. I can't wait for a sequel!
7) AC Odyssey
I loved AC Origins but Odyssey looked like an Ancient Greece reskin with some new combat additions. I still ended up buying the game last October but Red Dead Redemption 2 swept me away so I eventually decided to uninstall the (at the time) unremarkable Odyssey to focus on Red Dead.
Earlier this year, I reinstalled Odyssey and had a blast as Kassandra, fearsome warrior and local dumbass. Though the combat is a bit too damage-spongey, Kassandra, the quest & dialogue system, and the fun island hopping were all elements that carried this game for me.
8) RDR2
Even after three and a half playthroughs, Red Dead 2 is still the most immersive open world game I've ever played. You can really live in that world and the story & characters are the among the best I've ever seen in any media.
Though I have issues with the gameplay, it's that gang, the world, and the story that's kept me coming back more than a year after the game came out.
9) Death Stranding
Death Stranding is a game that I should've been bored with but whenever I boot up the game I have to pull myself away from it after a few hours because I really, really love making deliveries. I love walking around, I love climbing up mountains, and I love the unique atmosphere of the game's open world.
That said, the story is pretty bad and the characters are mostly underdeveloped. The game kept trying to sell me on these emotional moments that didn't feel earned at all. And don't get me started on the boring BTs and bland gunplay. Also, the MULES were an interesting monkey wrench in my delivery routes though only occasionally.
Death Stranding is one of the most unique games I've ever played but it's also one of the most flawed. I'm glad the game exists however I couldn't recommend it to someone without a whole lot of caveats.
10) Life is Strange 2
I didn't like how long the gaps were between Life is Strange 2's episodes but, despite the lengthy waits, the story kept me enthralled all year. It would be months since I installed the game after playing an episode but whenever a new one came out I would always set aside time to play that episode.
I don't think this game's story is perfect but I think it resonated with me more than LiS 1's story. I cared about Sean & Daniel (along with all the friends they made during their journey) and the finale to their story tops LiS 1's finale by a mile.