HP: He's been very disengaged from the game, I'm not sure he is acting as discouraged town or lay-lowing scum He has really made any pushes on anyone else to try to prove his innocence and hasn't really evaluated anything day 2. While not far from his regular gameplay, hard to say if this is a scum or town lean. Once again, panicked or poor town play is not indicative of scum. If you flip him and he is scum, please do not shotgun easy reads under the pretense of him getting defended D1. It's more likely some town are willing to defend someone D1 than scum when scum!HP and his team could have told to confirm his role earlier and easily could have saved himself the grief of going to EoD with 5 minutes left. I find it unlikely that HP or ATP are teamed at this point. Null read. Please consider that the scum team is more than one person even if HP ends up being scum and you can't have him be the focal point of discussion every day.
ATP: Given his play has been abrasive and confrontational, I find it hard to believe that it is scum. However, tunneling is NAI because I've seen scum tunnel on town before (MGS Mafia) so just because someone is purposely being obtuse or short-sighted does not give them a town lean. The red check on me is odd given I know I am town so I'm thinking of ways this could make sense. Role switcher, randomizer, tailor, paranoia modifier is what comes to mind but given it's role madness and bastard, only the first two could apply properly. Maybe a neutral win condition to get a rival voted off? Regardless of what I flip, the amount of scum still in the game has not gone down. I have to say he's either wrong or scum given I know my alignment.
Zipped: Seems completely tunneled on HP but I feel the tunnel is more genuine than what ATP did with HP. Hopefully Zipped looks elsewhere besides HP and Blarg because those are two low hanging fruit that any scum could make for a case at any time. I do not like the off-wagon vote on D1 and I feel like it's an easy spot to hide but zipped always has very weird off wagon town votes so it's hard to say, null read
Leo: I like that he's solving and that he's not tunneling on me or HP alone. Please continue doing so. Slight town lean
Ephi: Her EoD at D1 was bad in my eyes, the vote switching on different wagons screams scum rather than town to me. Town should be afraid to jump wagons at the risk of looking bad especially given there was no reasoning and just straight votes. The jumpy votes at EoD makes it harder for town to coordinate and makes other town uneasy. Easy to explain in hindsight what was being done but I still don't like it. The D2 hasn't been much better, asking other people questions comes off as busy work to me. Scum lean. Doesn't feel like genuine solving. Scum lean.
Anex: I like where anex is looking right now and agreeing with a lot of the reads regarding HP. At least we're not voting out HP today so that's a positive on that front. I also heavily agree with the argument that it's unlikely that all of the scum came to the defense of HP at EoD and it was more likely town moving votes. Slight town lean.
Ambulance: I like his posts but there's not enough for me to say he's confidently town. It's very with the flow and very safe play from him so far and maybe it's because the scum are really that obvious? Who knows but I have him as null in my mind. The play is way too safe for me to say otherwise.
Wee: I like the push on LP even if I don't 100% agree with it. I find it hard to believe both are teamed at the moment. Felt too much guesswork on the whole TvT vote wagons and defending of HP. I think it's more likely scum were planted early on the wagons or are hiding off wagon rather than the people moving at EoD (Blarg being an exception). Null read at the moment.
Bojack: Much more active than the last game we played together (especially on D2) but felt like he was tunneling too hard on me. Very easy to probe the person under the most pressure and try to find holes in their stories. Felt like he was asking questions, getting an answer and then asking more questions in hopes of finding something I said was contradictory to what I had wrote and not really listening to what I had to say. Slight scum lean.
Malus: Much better D2 and his frantic vote movement onto the LP wagon which was not gaining steam comes off much more genuine as panicked town movement compared to Ephi. I suppose look at HP's flip and see if Malus movement makes in sense with conjunction with that? Town lean.
Jman: Playing some weird game with the whole role claim thig. Don't think the vote info and post info is enough to make a solid read on his alignment. His EoD for D1 was bad though. Null read.
LP: Honestly this LP seems more helpful than when I saw when he was scum!LP. Some reads, some pushes and less mechanics/discussions talk and less asking questions busy work.
Slight town lean, not teamed with Wee.
Yuta: Still MIA, still no real reads or info. Just a slight D1 push on Sneeks and a lazy vote switch to Blarg. Anyone can vote for Blarg because Blarg always acts anti-town regardless of his alignment. That's not solving. Comes off very disinterested in the outcome of the game. Scum lean.
Blarg: Blarg is Blarg, should have policy voted him out D1 if you don't want to deal with it. If we don't do that, then voting him out on D2 or D3 is dumb because we have much better info to go on besides Blarg being Blarg. If we don't then someone should have checked him N1 so we don't have to deal with him being anti-town as town.
Alignment: Blarg
Royal_Flush: I don't agree any of his reads on re-read besides the Ephi one. Doesn't really feel like solving to me at this point but he has so little info to go off of I can't make a real read on it. Null read.
Fate: Comes off as town, he's always this angry and aggressive and tunnely as town in all the games I've been with him. I haven't read any of his games where he's scum so maybe he's always like this. I'll give him a town read though.
