Aelios
So far a plausible scum for me, let's see what happens with vere, i've detailed this
AllThingsPurple
I believe the claim, seems town
Reki
Has done more solving lately. A lot of the 'apparent' solving is more making observations, like the post where they summarize everything that happened and offer no conclusions. Busywork, made to look like solving. Scum lean remains.
Sawneeks
Not convinced of towniness. Saw has +2 scum points by my read, and likely +2 town points also.
Zippedpinhead
I am mystified. Very little scum hunting. I'd still flip him if i could but wouldn't be shocked if he WAS town, just lost. but by not doing much at all, he can be scum not committing to any statement they'd have to back up later.
LaunchpadMcQ
I'm taking the green check but i've gone both ways on launch durin gthe game.
Stantastic
Has +2 townie points for post content then got cursed.
Dr. Monkey
probably town. I don't have to worry about that because scum will shoot her and reassure me.
empressdonna
probably town, behavior after replacing is doing her best. Predessexcor seemed town.
Fat4all
nullish but a dark horse option for hidden wolf.
TheChuggernaut
Seemed town day one, got cursed and sick, need to reread, might be a "low harm" option to flip given the sitch
rac
Has a lot of +town points from content, didn't notice any +scum points.
Vincent Alexander
Seemed more like he was trying to 'seem' town than that he 'was' town. Subtly blending. Not very conclusive statements. He plays that way as town too. Something in his votes seemed scummy to me iirc.
Conditional-Pancakes
probably town
Maolfunction
Started out towny, dropped off, came back towny. He's slippery as scum. I'd have a hard time defending him against a lunch push because i don't fully believe in his towniness myself.
Kyanrute
Apart from bizarre green check, he behaves like his town self. No +scum points.
MrHedin
I've scum read his town game before and this feels identical. Some solving. Speaks succinctly. Response to my pushing feels genuine. I think he's town.
turmoil7
not town. It's not just the weird way of role claiming, it's Also trying to push that i might not be a gossip even though that was confirmed by the participant. Like, you could be claiming i'm a scum gossip, but this is practically a counterclaim level of "can't be true" and it isn't a town move. Also keeps on fishing for this [alleged-lover] name, and i don't believe anything good will happen to Elyse from him.
Blargonaut
Post content seems? Townish? He did the vote-pushing on day one, that can be done by scum, too, i've seen it, but more often by town. I never try because i can't babysit a thread that way but i appreciate the work that goes into it. He's out there trying to get people to sheep him and giving variously silly thoughts to follow, and analyzing them based off of it.
Funky Dude Sparks
i have nothing. I've tried all kinds of ways to get consistent reads on sparks in various games and I too often guess wrong to even comment.